A1 Team Germany chastises decision

A1 Team Germany chastises decision

26 February 2008 – At the seventh round of the A1GP World Cup of Motorsport in Durban on 24 February, A1 Team Germany was disqualified from the sprint race by a decision of the stewards, thus being deprived of any chance to fight for the title.

In the opinion of the stewards there was no doubt that A1 Team Germany was at fault in the accident between its car and that of A1 Team Netherlands. In the subsequent feature race, there were numerous further accidents and incidents in which A1 Team Germany was among the victims. In none of these cases did the stewards impose a disqualification as a penalty. Willi Weber, Seat Holder of A1 Team Germany, is dismayed about the inconsistency of the decisions. 

"As a team that has been contesting the series ever since its inaugural season, we have been supporting the fantastic idea and concept of the A1GP World Cup of Motorsport since 2005," states the seasoned motorsport manager from Stuttgart. "Up to now, A1GP has been consistently moving forwards. In the meantime, I've become more sceptical. The city street race in Durban last Sunday saw an unusually high number of controversial incidents on the track. The stewards took the time to carefully analyse the events after the race. That's why we chose not to pass any final judgment in our initial comment on Sunday. But the further analyses and evaluation of the race by the stewards is scandalous."

Weber adds, "I deeply regret that the many fans at the venue were deprived of a consistent, flowing race as no less than four safety car phases interrupted the main race for a longer period of time. Outright scandalous, however, is the fact that there were extreme differences in the penalties imposed for the very serious incidents that occurred. Our racing car, for example, was turned around on lap four of the main race. Another driver was unable to avoid our car, hit us, and that was the end of our race. Before that, we had been disqualified from the sprint race.

'We have no knowledge of the driver who ended our race having received any significant penalty. But there are further examples. On lap 39, a young driver, after making a mistake in a blind area, performed an extremely risky manoeuvre, which provoked an accident. This ruined the race of the Brit Oliver Jarvis. Prior to this incident, we had been accused of having caused an 'avoidable' accident. So what about this crash, hadn't this one been avoidable as well?

'Finally, on lap 42, Jeroen Bleekemolen was turned around again, but his opponent in the accident was not disqualified. Instead, the race was stopped and the previous lap classified. Originally, this was done in the sprint race as well - the old status quo in the points standings was restored again, and nobody suffered any disadvantage. But then we were disqualified and the old status quo was no longer valid. In the main race, as well, the order in the standings before the accident was restored when the race was stopped. However, there were no penalties imposed against anyone who had caused an accident. Quite to the contrary, Adrian Zaugg received only a minor penalty that does not even affect the points score. I am not the only one who cannot help getting the impression that the decisions involve a double standard. The reactions by German media are interesting, to put it mildly."

In view of these events, Willi Weber is drawing some first conclusions: "It is not understandable why the penalties imposed differ so greatly, considering the seriousness of the incidents. It cannot be in the best interest of sport that sporting penalties are primarily characterised by unpredictability. That this happened in the midst of a title fight is particularly unfortunate. It is a mystery to me how something like this is possible. Before our team will take any further steps, I will try to discuss the issue with the people in charge. But one thing is certain: I expect to receive clear answers, and I will not let up on this matter."

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Friday 12 February 2016

  2. Ferrari: No title in 10 years would be 'tragedy' 13:06

    Ferrari: No title in 10 years would be 'tragedy'

    Ferrari President Sergio Marchionne says that it would be a "tragedy" for the team to go 10 years without a title triumph in…

    F1
  3. Video: Tony Kanaan's Indy 500 tattoo 12:18

    Video: Tony Kanaan's Indy 500 tattoo

    IndyCar champion plus Indy 500 and 24 Hours of Daytona winner Tony Kanaan explains his new tattoo.

    Indy
  4. Baz eager to confirm test crash cause 11:25

    Baz eager to confirm test crash cause

    Loris Baz says he is eager to determine the cause of his high-speed accident during the opening pre-season test at Sepang, which…

    MotoGP
  5. Wolff: Wehrlein, Ocon in F1 'on merit' 10:17

    Wolff: Wehrlein, Ocon in F1 'on merit'

    Mercedes motorsport boss Toto Wolff says that he is "proud" to see young drivers Pascal Wehrlein and Esteban Ocon take on…

    F1
  6. Mexico City ePrix to be streamed in UK 10:05

    Mexico City ePrix to be streamed in UK

    Formula E's Mexico City ePrix will not be aired live on ITV4, with the series instead streaming it across various online…

    FE
  7. Vandoorne seals Super Formula drive 09:46

    Vandoorne seals Super Formula drive

    McLaren test and reserve driver Stoffel Vandoorne has secured a seat in the Japan-based Super Formula series for 2016, the…

    F1
  8. ART confirms Matsushita for second term 08:57

    ART confirms Matsushita for second term

    ART Grand Prix has confirmed that it will run Nobuharu Matsushita for a second GP2 season in 2016. Honda-backed Matsushita…

    GP2
  9. Video of the Day: FE on sustainability 05:12

    Video of the Day: FE on sustainability

    Formula E drivers discuss the importance of a sustainable future for cities such as Buenos Aires.

    FE
  10. Thursday 11 February 2016

  11. Video: Ferrari fires up 2016 engine 16:37

    Video: Ferrari fires up 2016 engine

    Ferrari fires up its 2016 power unit as preparations gather pace for the new Formula 1 season.

    F1
  12. De Jong completes MP Motorsport line-up 14:15

    De Jong completes MP Motorsport line-up

    Daniël de Jong will contest the 2016 GP2 season with MP Motorsport, completing the team's line-up. Dutch racer de Jong, 23…

    GP2
  13. 'Engine parity would improve racing' – Key 12:53

    'Engine parity would improve racing' – Key

    Toro Rosso technical chief James Key says that engine parity would be a clear way of improving the racing in Formula 1, as the…

    F1
  14. Jordan moves into BBC Top Gear role 11:03

    Jordan moves into BBC Top Gear role

    Eddie Jordan has taken on a role with the revamped BBC show Top Gear following the broadcaster's early termination of its…

    F1
  15. Video: Mercedes power unit revealed 10:31

    Video: Mercedes power unit revealed

    Mercedes provides a detailed look at its Formula 1 power unit in the latest episode of its studio show.

    F1
  16. Miller to return to action at Phillip Island 10:12

    Miller to return to action at Phillip Island

    Jack Miller will return to action at next week's Phillip Island pre-season test, Marc VDS has confirmed. Miller, who has…

    MotoGP
  17. Ocon lands Mercedes DTM seat for 2016 09:35

    Ocon lands Mercedes DTM seat for 2016

    GP3 champion Esteban Ocon will contest the DTM in 2016, after landing a seat at Mercedes. Ocon, 19, combined his GP3 duties…

    DTM
  18. Wehrlein wants 'really good' team-mate 09:27

    Wehrlein wants 'really good' team-mate

    Pascal Wehrlein says he hopes that Manor will place a competitive driver alongside him for the 2016 season, as discussions…

    F1
  19. Moreno joins Aguri as reserve driver 09:18

    Moreno joins Aguri as reserve driver

    Ecuadorian racer Julio Moreno has joined Team Aguri as its Formula E reserve driver. Moreno, 20, last year contested FIA…

    FE
  20. MotoGP publishes final 2016 calendar 09:09

    MotoGP publishes final 2016 calendar

    MotoGP organisers have issued a final version of the 2016 calendar, with the Jerez and Brno rounds now fully confirmed, after…

    MotoGP
  21. Video of the Day: Drivers on Phoenix return 05:23

    Video of the Day: Drivers on Phoenix return

    Josef Newgarden, Simon Pagenaud and Juan Pablo Montoya reflect on their recent test session at the Phoenix International…

    Indy
  22. Wednesday 10 February 2016

  23. Wehrlein to use number 94 in Formula 1 14:32

    Wehrlein to use number 94 in Formula 1

    Manor's Pascal Wehrlein will use #94 as his permanent race number in Formula 1. Wehrlein, whose Formula 1 graduation was…

    F1
  24. Background: Who is Pascal Wehrlein? 13:28

    Background: Who is Pascal Wehrlein?

    Pascal Wehrlein becomes the second rookie on the Formula 1 grid for the 2016 season after confirmation of his deal with Manor…

    F1
  25. Manor tips Wehrlein to make 'big impact' 11:35

    Manor tips Wehrlein to make 'big impact'

    Pascal Wehrlein has the talent to make a "big impact" with Manor Racing during his debut season in Formula 1, according to the…

    F1
  26. Manor confirms Wehrlein for 2016 season 11:11

    Manor confirms Wehrlein for 2016 season

    Manor Racing has confirmed that DTM champion Pascal Wehrlein will make his Formula 1 debut with the squad in 2016, meaning…

    F1
  27. Video: Red Bull drivers spur a stampede 10:06

    Video: Red Bull drivers spur a stampede

    Red Bull duo Daniel Ricciardo and Daniil Kvyat spur a stampede in this video for clothing partner Puma.

    F1
  28. Redding: 2016 'make or break' year 09:46

    Redding: 2016 'make or break' year

    Pramac rider Scott Redding has described 2016 as a "make or break" year for his future in MotoGP, as the Briton prepares for a…

    MotoGP
  29. 'Wehrlein secures F1 seat with Manor' 08:52

    'Wehrlein secures F1 seat with Manor'

    DTM champion Pascal Wehrlein has landed a seat at Manor for the 2016 season, with a deal to be announced shortly, according to…

    F1
  30. Video of the Day: Suzuki Sepang review 05:27

    Video of the Day: Suzuki Sepang review

    Suzuki riders Maverick Viñales and Aleix Espargaró review the opening pre-season test in Malaysia.

    MotoGP
  31. Tuesday 9 February 2016

  32. New McLaren passes FIA crash tests 15:57

    New McLaren passes FIA crash tests

    McLaren's new Formula 1 car, the Honda-powered MP4-31, has passed the FIA's mandatory crash tests ahead of pre-season testing…

    F1
  33. 15:43

    Photos: Australian Grand Prix photocall

    F1
  34. MotoGP reveals Baz test crash data 14:02

    MotoGP reveals Baz test crash data

    MotoGP has revealed the full telemetry data from Loris Baz's frightening 290km/h pre-season testing accident at Sepang, with the…

    MotoGP
  35. Video: Rémi Taffin outlines Renault task 12:16

    Video: Rémi Taffin outlines Renault task

    Renault Engine Technical Director Rémi Taffin outlines the task ahead of the company on its works return.

    F1
  36. In photos: Magnussen's journey to Renault 11:20

    In photos: Magnussen's journey to Renault

    Last week, Kevin Magnussen's return to Formula 1 was confirmed, with the Dane securing a seat at the works Renault team. In this…

    F1
  37. Palmer: Maldonado 'not a bad driver' 10:06

    Palmer: Maldonado 'not a bad driver'

    Jolyon Palmer has defended Pastor Maldonado's abilities behind the wheel after the Venezuelan lost his Formula 1 drive at…

    F1
  38. Mercedes expects 'big gains' at McLaren 09:27

    Mercedes expects 'big gains' at McLaren

    World Champion team Mercedes says that it approaches the 2016 season expecting to be beaten by Ferrari, and has also described…

    F1
  39. Taffin: Renault integration will take time 08:52

    Taffin: Renault integration will take time

    Renault's Engine Technical Director Rémi Taffin says it will take time for the two sides of the reformed outfit to work…

    F1
  40. Video of the Day: Ocon reflects on F3 05:12

    Video of the Day: Ocon reflects on F3

    Newly appointed Renault reserve driver Esteban Ocon reflects on his title-winning F3 campaign in 2014.

    F3
  41. Monday 8 February 2016

  42. Sauber's new car passes crash tests 16:23

    Sauber's new car passes crash tests

    Sauber's new Formula 1 challenger, the C35, has passed the FIA's mandatory crash tests, clearing it for pre-season testing…

    F1
  43. Ghiotto graduates to GP2 with Trident 15:08

    Ghiotto graduates to GP2 with Trident

    GP3 Series runner-up Luca Ghiotto and Trident will continue their partnership this year after the team confirmed that he will…

    GP2
  44. Andretti could field Frijns in IndyCar 14:35

    Andretti could field Frijns in IndyCar

    Michael Andretti says it is "very possible" that Formula E racer Robin Frijns could make his IndyCar debut with Andretti…

    Indy
  45. Hamilton has up to '10 years' left in F1 12:57

    Hamilton has up to '10 years' left in F1

    Triple World Champion Lewis Hamilton could continue to compete in Formula 1 for the next 10 years, taking him through the 2025…

    F1
more news