A1 Team Germany chastises decision

A1 Team Germany chastises decision

26 February 2008 – At the seventh round of the A1GP World Cup of Motorsport in Durban on 24 February, A1 Team Germany was disqualified from the sprint race by a decision of the stewards, thus being deprived of any chance to fight for the title.

In the opinion of the stewards there was no doubt that A1 Team Germany was at fault in the accident between its car and that of A1 Team Netherlands. In the subsequent feature race, there were numerous further accidents and incidents in which A1 Team Germany was among the victims. In none of these cases did the stewards impose a disqualification as a penalty. Willi Weber, Seat Holder of A1 Team Germany, is dismayed about the inconsistency of the decisions. 

"As a team that has been contesting the series ever since its inaugural season, we have been supporting the fantastic idea and concept of the A1GP World Cup of Motorsport since 2005," states the seasoned motorsport manager from Stuttgart. "Up to now, A1GP has been consistently moving forwards. In the meantime, I've become more sceptical. The city street race in Durban last Sunday saw an unusually high number of controversial incidents on the track. The stewards took the time to carefully analyse the events after the race. That's why we chose not to pass any final judgment in our initial comment on Sunday. But the further analyses and evaluation of the race by the stewards is scandalous."

Weber adds, "I deeply regret that the many fans at the venue were deprived of a consistent, flowing race as no less than four safety car phases interrupted the main race for a longer period of time. Outright scandalous, however, is the fact that there were extreme differences in the penalties imposed for the very serious incidents that occurred. Our racing car, for example, was turned around on lap four of the main race. Another driver was unable to avoid our car, hit us, and that was the end of our race. Before that, we had been disqualified from the sprint race.

'We have no knowledge of the driver who ended our race having received any significant penalty. But there are further examples. On lap 39, a young driver, after making a mistake in a blind area, performed an extremely risky manoeuvre, which provoked an accident. This ruined the race of the Brit Oliver Jarvis. Prior to this incident, we had been accused of having caused an 'avoidable' accident. So what about this crash, hadn't this one been avoidable as well?

'Finally, on lap 42, Jeroen Bleekemolen was turned around again, but his opponent in the accident was not disqualified. Instead, the race was stopped and the previous lap classified. Originally, this was done in the sprint race as well - the old status quo in the points standings was restored again, and nobody suffered any disadvantage. But then we were disqualified and the old status quo was no longer valid. In the main race, as well, the order in the standings before the accident was restored when the race was stopped. However, there were no penalties imposed against anyone who had caused an accident. Quite to the contrary, Adrian Zaugg received only a minor penalty that does not even affect the points score. I am not the only one who cannot help getting the impression that the decisions involve a double standard. The reactions by German media are interesting, to put it mildly."

In view of these events, Willi Weber is drawing some first conclusions: "It is not understandable why the penalties imposed differ so greatly, considering the seriousness of the incidents. It cannot be in the best interest of sport that sporting penalties are primarily characterised by unpredictability. That this happened in the midst of a title fight is particularly unfortunate. It is a mystery to me how something like this is possible. Before our team will take any further steps, I will try to discuss the issue with the people in charge. But one thing is certain: I expect to receive clear answers, and I will not let up on this matter."

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Wednesday 1 July 2015

  2. 17:04

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  3. Formula 1 needs to be more competitive – fans 16:53

    Formula 1 needs to be more competitive – fans

    Almost 90 per cent of Formula 1 fans hold the view that the sport needs to be more competitive, according to the results of a…

    F1
  4. Button: Test mileage motivating for McLaren 14:39

    Button: Test mileage motivating for McLaren

    Jenson Button says that the mileage completed by McLaren during the post-race test in Austria has given the squad extra…

    F1
  5. Video: Räikkönen previews Silverstone 12:34

    Video: Räikkönen previews Silverstone

    Ferrari driver Kimi Räikkönen looks ahead to this weekend's British Grand Prix at Silverstone.

    F1
  6. Horner: Formula E won't rival Formula 1 12:02

    Horner: Formula E won't rival Formula 1

    Red Bull team boss Christian Horner has opposed Sir Richard Branson's view that Formula E will become a rival to and ultimately…

    F1
  7. Qatar 'close to agreement' for F1 race 11:43

    Qatar 'close to agreement' for F1 race

    Qatar is closer than ever to securing a place on the Formula 1 calendar, according to the head of the Qatar Motor and Motorcycle…

    F1
  8. Cecotto Jr. in for Sørensen at Carlin 11:15

    Cecotto Jr. in for Sørensen at Carlin

    GP2 race winner Johnny Cecotto Jr. has been drafted in to race for Carlin at this weekend's Silverstone event, following Marco…

    GP2
  9. Wolff: Mercedes must maintain high level 10:56

    Wolff: Mercedes must maintain high level

    Toto Wolff says that his Mercedes team must maintain its current high level in order to prevent rivals from having any…

    F1
  10. Factfile: The 2015 British Grand Prix 09:49

    Factfile: The 2015 British Grand Prix

    Formula 1 heads to Silverstone for the British Grand Prix this week, with pleasant summer conditions expected. Prior to the…

    F1
  11. Sauber appoints new Technical Director 09:28

    Sauber appoints new Technical Director

    Sauber has announced that Mark Smith will join the team as its Technical Director later this month. Smith was most recently…

    F1
  12. Vergne: FE performances show ability 09:11

    Vergne: FE performances show ability

    Former Toro Rosso driver Jean-Éric Vergne says that the speed he has displayed during the inaugural Formula E championship…

    F1
  13. Preview: Five key questions for Britain 07:11

    Preview: Five key questions for Britain

    Formula 1 returns 'home' this weekend for the British Grand Prix at Silverstone. Ahead of the popular event in the countryside…

    F1
  14. Silverstone memories: Hill, Schumacher collide 05:17

    Silverstone memories: Hill, Schumacher collide

    Watch as Damon Hill and Michael Schumacher clash while fighting for the lead of the 1995 British Grand Prix. Both drivers were…

    F1
  15. Tuesday 30 June 2015

  16. Video: Williams FW13B at Goodwood 16:30

    Video: Williams FW13B at Goodwood

    Ride onboard with Williams development driver Alex Lynn as he demonstrates the FW13B at Goodwood.

    F1
  17. Williams confident of podium challenge 15:10

    Williams confident of podium challenge

    Williams' Rob Smedley says that the squad should be able to challenge for the podium at this weekend's British Grand Prix, with…

    F1
  18. Alonso could face further engine penalties 14:51

    Alonso could face further engine penalties

    McLaren's Fernando Alonso could face further engine penalties at this weekend's British Grand Prix, with Honda investigating the…

    F1
  19. Horner: Formula 1 at a 'critical stage' 13:45

    Horner: Formula 1 at a 'critical stage'

    Red Bull Team Principal Christian Horner reckons Formula 1 is at a "critical stage" and that drivers need to be given more of a…

    F1
  20. Ricciardo not ruling out Red Bull departure 12:51

    Ricciardo not ruling out Red Bull departure

    Daniel Ricciardo says that he cannot completely rule out departing Red Bull at the end of 2015, as the team continues to examine…

    F1
  21. Hamilton vows to go 'all out' for home win 12:00

    Hamilton vows to go 'all out' for home win

    World Champion Lewis Hamilton says he will go 'all out' in his bid to record a third home victory at the British Grand Prix this…

    F1
  22. Baku construction work to begin this week 10:44

    Baku construction work to begin this week

    Construction work for next year's European Grand Prix around the streets of Azerbaijan's capital city, Baku, is set to begin…

    F1
  23. Barcelona set to host 2016 pre-season testing 10:36

    Barcelona set to host 2016 pre-season testing

    The Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya, home of the Formula 1 Spanish Grand Prix, is set to host next year's pre-season testing…

    F1
  24. Bradl has surgery on fractured scaphoid 09:44

    Bradl has surgery on fractured scaphoid

    Forward Racing rider Stefan Bradl has undergone surgery for a fractured scaphoid, following a crash at the Dutch TT last…

    MotoGP
  25. Feature: How has Formula E fared? 07:23

    Feature: How has Formula E fared?

    When the chequered flag fell at the London ePrix and Nelson Piquet Jr.'s seventh position ensured he beat Sébastien Buemi to…

    FE
  26. Silverstone memories: Trulli crashes out 05:06

    Silverstone memories: Trulli crashes out

    Jarno Trulli escaped from this massive accident during the 2004 British Grand Prix at Silverstone.

    F1
  27. Monday 29 June 2015

  28. Marciello gets Sauber practice outing 14:16

    Marciello gets Sauber practice outing

    Sauber reserve driver Raffaele Marciello will participate in the opening practice session for the British Grand Prix, his third…

    F1
  29. Video: Nico Rosberg's Goodwood diary 13:21

    Video: Nico Rosberg's Goodwood diary

    Nico Rosberg demonstrates what it's like to be a Formula 1 driver at the Goodwood Festival of Speed.

    F1
  30. Force India excited by new car potential 12:26

    Force India excited by new car potential

    Force India team boss Vijay Mallya says the entire squad is "full of anticipation" as it prepares to launch its new car on home…

    F1
  31. Horner extends contract with Red Bull 11:16

    Horner extends contract with Red Bull

    Christian Horner has extended his contract with Red Bull, the team has confirmed to GPUpdate.net. Amid a challenging start to…

    F1
  32. Video: Button drives Senna's McLaren MP4/6 10:28

    Video: Button drives Senna's McLaren MP4/6

    Watch as Jenson Button drives Ayrton Senna's McLaren MP4/6 at the Goodwood Festival of Speed.

    F1
  33. Renault's F1 future depends on governance 10:22

    Renault's F1 future depends on governance

    Renault's Chief Executive, Carlos Ghosn, says the French manufacturer is still yet to decide on its future involvement in…

    F1
  34. Leclerc, Günther, Giovinazzi win at the Norisring 10:03

    Leclerc, Günther, Giovinazzi win at the Norisring

    Charles Leclerc, Maximilian Günther and Antonio Giovinazzi shared the wins during last weekend's FIA European Formula 3 round…

    F3
  35. Silverstone memories: Schumacher vs Häkkinen 05:02

    Silverstone memories: Schumacher vs Häkkinen

    Relive the battle between Michael Schumacher and Mika Häkkinen during a rain-hit 1998 British Grand Prix. After pouncing on a…

    F1
  36. Sunday 28 June 2015

  37. Piquet Jr. overwhelmed by Formula E crown 17:45

    Piquet Jr. overwhelmed by Formula E crown

    Nelson Piquet Jr. expressed his amazement at claiming the maiden Formula E championship as he recovered from 16th on the grid to…

    FE
  38. Bird wins, Piquet Jr. takes title in action-packed finale 16:59

    Bird wins, Piquet Jr. takes title in action-packed finale

    Nelson Piquet Jr. beat Sébastien Buemi to the inaugural Formula E championship by a single point as Sam Bird claimed victory in…

    FE
  39. Verstappen bemoans too much 'technical stuff' 11:46

    Verstappen bemoans too much 'technical stuff'

    Toro Rosso youngster Max Verstappen says that Formula 1 needs to get rid of the abundance of "technical stuff" and place control…

    F1
  40. Video: Briscoe escapes huge IndyCar crash 10:55

    Video: Briscoe escapes huge IndyCar crash

    Ryan Briscoe escaped unharmed following a terrifying flip during Saturday's IndyCar race at Fontana.

    Indy
  41. Márquez calls Assen podium 'moral victory' 08:06

    Márquez calls Assen podium 'moral victory'

    Marc Márquez was left encouraged by his return to form at the Dutch TT as he called his second place finish at Assen a 'moral…

    MotoGP
  42. Video of the Day: F1 2015 TV advert 05:11

    Video of the Day: F1 2015 TV advert

    Watch the official TV advert for Codemasters' upcoming F1 2015 title, to be launched on July 10.

    F1
  43. Rahal leads the pack in thrilling fashion at Fontana 01:24

    Rahal leads the pack in thrilling fashion at Fontana

    Graham Rahal broke a 125-race winless streak that stretched back seven years to win a thrilling and record-setting MAVTV 500 at…

    Indy
  44. Saturday 27 June 2015

  45. Buemi win sets up three-way title fight 16:57

    Buemi win sets up three-way title fight

    Sébastien Buemi cruised to victory around Battersea Park to set-up a three-way fight for the inaugural Formula E championship…

    FE
more news