A1 Team Germany chastises decision

A1 Team Germany chastises decision

26 February 2008 – At the seventh round of the A1GP World Cup of Motorsport in Durban on 24 February, A1 Team Germany was disqualified from the sprint race by a decision of the stewards, thus being deprived of any chance to fight for the title.

In the opinion of the stewards there was no doubt that A1 Team Germany was at fault in the accident between its car and that of A1 Team Netherlands. In the subsequent feature race, there were numerous further accidents and incidents in which A1 Team Germany was among the victims. In none of these cases did the stewards impose a disqualification as a penalty. Willi Weber, Seat Holder of A1 Team Germany, is dismayed about the inconsistency of the decisions. 

"As a team that has been contesting the series ever since its inaugural season, we have been supporting the fantastic idea and concept of the A1GP World Cup of Motorsport since 2005," states the seasoned motorsport manager from Stuttgart. "Up to now, A1GP has been consistently moving forwards. In the meantime, I've become more sceptical. The city street race in Durban last Sunday saw an unusually high number of controversial incidents on the track. The stewards took the time to carefully analyse the events after the race. That's why we chose not to pass any final judgment in our initial comment on Sunday. But the further analyses and evaluation of the race by the stewards is scandalous."

Weber adds, "I deeply regret that the many fans at the venue were deprived of a consistent, flowing race as no less than four safety car phases interrupted the main race for a longer period of time. Outright scandalous, however, is the fact that there were extreme differences in the penalties imposed for the very serious incidents that occurred. Our racing car, for example, was turned around on lap four of the main race. Another driver was unable to avoid our car, hit us, and that was the end of our race. Before that, we had been disqualified from the sprint race.

'We have no knowledge of the driver who ended our race having received any significant penalty. But there are further examples. On lap 39, a young driver, after making a mistake in a blind area, performed an extremely risky manoeuvre, which provoked an accident. This ruined the race of the Brit Oliver Jarvis. Prior to this incident, we had been accused of having caused an 'avoidable' accident. So what about this crash, hadn't this one been avoidable as well?

'Finally, on lap 42, Jeroen Bleekemolen was turned around again, but his opponent in the accident was not disqualified. Instead, the race was stopped and the previous lap classified. Originally, this was done in the sprint race as well - the old status quo in the points standings was restored again, and nobody suffered any disadvantage. But then we were disqualified and the old status quo was no longer valid. In the main race, as well, the order in the standings before the accident was restored when the race was stopped. However, there were no penalties imposed against anyone who had caused an accident. Quite to the contrary, Adrian Zaugg received only a minor penalty that does not even affect the points score. I am not the only one who cannot help getting the impression that the decisions involve a double standard. The reactions by German media are interesting, to put it mildly."

In view of these events, Willi Weber is drawing some first conclusions: "It is not understandable why the penalties imposed differ so greatly, considering the seriousness of the incidents. It cannot be in the best interest of sport that sporting penalties are primarily characterised by unpredictability. That this happened in the midst of a title fight is particularly unfortunate. It is a mystery to me how something like this is possible. Before our team will take any further steps, I will try to discuss the issue with the people in charge. But one thing is certain: I expect to receive clear answers, and I will not let up on this matter."

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Thursday 30 March 2017

  2. 17:02

    Follow GPUpdate on Instagram in 2017!

    F1
  3. Button to demonstrate M23 at Laguna Seca 16:17

    Button to demonstrate M23 at Laguna Seca

    Jenson Button will get behind the wheel of Emerson Fittipaldi's 1974 title-winning McLaren M23 as part of the Rolex Monterey…

    Misc
  4. 15:44

    Latest Formula 2 photos: Sakhir - Day 2

    F2
  5. Latifi quickest on second Bahrain test day 15:41

    Latifi quickest on second Bahrain test day

    DAMS driver Nicholas Latifi recorded the quickest time on the second day of the final pre-season Formula 2 test in Bahrain on…

    F2
  6. Insight: Bratches on F1's digital facelift 14:02

    Insight: Bratches on F1's digital facelift

    Formula 1's new season opened last weekend with overhauled regulations, forming a different on-track spectacle, but there have…

    F1
  7. Background: Whiting on F1's new rules 12:36

    Background: Whiting on F1's new rules

    Charlie Whiting spoke at length about Formula 1's new rules and their application at the Australian Grand Prix. GPUpdate.net…

    F1
  8. Video: Mexico City ePrix Season 2 re-cap 10:32

    Video: Mexico City ePrix Season 2 re-cap

    Ahead of this weekend's Mexico City ePrix, Formula E looks back at last year's controversial inaugural race.

    FE
  9. Allison gives credit to 'very quick' Ferrari 09:41

    Allison gives credit to 'very quick' Ferrari

    James Allison has given credit to former team Ferrari after it beat new employer Mercedes to victory at last weekend's…

    F1
  10. Horner: Red Bull needs to find half a second 08:12

    Horner: Red Bull needs to find half a second

    Red Bull needs to find around half a second per lap in order to fight on a level playing field with pace-setting rivals Ferrari…

    F1
  11. Video of the Day: Rosberg in Monaco 05:38

    Video of the Day: Rosberg in Monaco

    Nico Rosberg shares his memories of growing up in Monaco and is stopped by police mid-interview!

    F1
  12. Wednesday 29 March 2017

  13. McLaren working with Amazon on TV series 17:32

    McLaren working with Amazon on TV series

    McLaren has been working with global internet retailer Amazon on a multi-part documentary series about the team's 2017 season in…

    F1
  14. 17:08

    Latest Formula 2 photos: Sakhir - Day 1

    F2
  15. Matsushita loses best lap, Leclerc fastest 17:05

    Matsushita loses best lap, Leclerc fastest

    Nobuharu Matsushita has lost the pace-setting time he posted on the first day of Formula 2's test in Bahrain over a red flag…

    F2
  16. MotoGP drops penalty points system 16:52

    MotoGP drops penalty points system

    MotoGP organisers have scrapped the series' penalty points system. MotoGP introduced a penalty points system ahead of the…

    MotoGP
  17. Matsushita beats Leclerc on first test day 16:02

    Matsushita beats Leclerc on first test day

    Nobuharu Matsushita set the pace on the first day of Formula 2's second pre-season test in Bahrain, denying Charles Leclerc with…

    F2
  18. IndyCar reveals new images of 2018 design 15:34

    IndyCar reveals new images of 2018 design

    IndyCar has revealed new images of the series' planned 2018 car design. IndyCar's latest computer-generated images cover…

    Indy
  19. Iannone: I must avoid being 'impulsive' 14:32

    Iannone: I must avoid being 'impulsive'

    Andrea Iannone has admitted he must try to rein in his aggression, having squandered a potential podium position on his Suzuki…

    MotoGP
  20. Video: Mexico City ePrix key statistics 13:02

    Video: Mexico City ePrix key statistics

    Formula E previews the Mexico City ePrix at the Autódromo Hermanos Rodríguez with some key statistics.

    FE
  21. Renault's 'biggest step' to come in Canada 11:22

    Renault's 'biggest step' to come in Canada

    Helmut Marko has expressed optimism over a sizeable upgrade that Renault is planning for the Canadian Grand Prix, but admits Red…

    F1
  22. Mark Sutton: Story behind the shot - Australia 11:02

    Mark Sutton: Story behind the shot - Australia

    Especially for lovers of motorsport photography, GPUpdate.net's race-by-race series, Story Behind the Shot, continues throughout…

    F1
  23. Vettel: Ferrari work starting to pay off 09:38

    Vettel: Ferrari work starting to pay off

    Sebastian Vettel believes that the work undertaken at Ferrari over the past couple of years is "slowly" starting to pay off…

    F1
  24. Aprilia hails 'extraordinary' Espargaró 08:16

    Aprilia hails 'extraordinary' Espargaró

    Aprilia has praised an "extraordinary" showing from Aleix Espargaró and believes the cancellation of qualifying prevented the…

    MotoGP
  25. Video of the Day: Mick on the road - Part 2 05:32

    Video of the Day: Mick on the road - Part 2

    Mick Schumacher continues his driving lessons in Mercedes-Benz's special car-com series.

    Misc
  26. Tuesday 28 March 2017

  27. Mann returns to Dale Coyne for Indy 500 19:30

    Mann returns to Dale Coyne for Indy 500

    Pippa Mann will return to the Indianapolis 500 after being signed to drive Dale Coyne Racing's third car for the prestigious…

    Indy
  28. Fernley: Double points 'fantastic reward' 16:16

    Fernley: Double points 'fantastic reward'

    Force India Deputy Team Principal Bob Fernley says a double points finish for the squad at the Australian Grand Prix is a…

    F1
  29. Hamilton sure of gains on tyre usage 15:44

    Hamilton sure of gains on tyre usage

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton says the team understands where it is lacking in terms of tyre usage, after he missed out on…

    F1
  30. Zarco vows to learn after starring debut 14:05

    Zarco vows to learn after starring debut

    Tech 3 rider Johann Zarco has vowed to learn from his race-ending mistake, in the wake of a shock spell in the lead on his…

    MotoGP
  31. Lack of preparation hurt Renault - Abiteboul 12:18

    Lack of preparation hurt Renault - Abiteboul

    Renault chief Cyril Abiteboul reckons the team's prospects at the Australian Grand Prix were hindered by a lack of preparation…

    F1
  32. Video: Lewis Hamilton explores Melbourne 11:02

    Video: Lewis Hamilton explores Melbourne

    Follow Lewis Hamilton as he explores Melbourne during the Australian Grand Prix weekend.

    F1
  33. Webber: Alonso might not do whole season 09:45

    Webber: Alonso might not do whole season

    Ex-Formula 1 driver Mark Webber has suggested that Fernando Alonso might not see out the 2017 season with McLaren-Honda, as he…

    F1
  34. Grosjean sees 'huge potential' despite exit 09:40

    Grosjean sees 'huge potential' despite exit

    Romain Grosjean expressed confidence that Haas' VF-17 has "huge potential", despite the team suffering a double retirement at…

    F1
  35. Hyman gets F2 test outing with Campos 08:44

    Hyman gets F2 test outing with Campos

    South African racer Raoul Hyman will sample Formula 2 machinery with Campos during this week's second pre-season test in…

    F2
  36. Opinion: Don't judge 2017 overtaking on opener 07:55

    Opinion: Don't judge 2017 overtaking on opener

    The 2017 Formula 1 season-opener in Australia featured a relative lack of overtaking, drawing complaints from some quarters, but…

    F1
  37. Video: Onboard with Rahal at Barber 05:24

    Video: Onboard with Rahal at Barber

    Ride onboard with Graham Rahal at the Barber Motorsports Park, ahead of next weekend's Indy Grand Prix of Alabama at the venue.

    Indy
  38. Monday 27 March 2017

  39. Australian Grand Prix: Winners and Losers 16:22

    Australian Grand Prix: Winners and Losers

    Sebastian Vettel opened the season with victory at the Australian Grand Prix, setting up the prospect of a title battle with…

    F1
  40. Márquez: Tyre change was 'biggest mistake' 15:36

    Márquez: Tyre change was 'biggest mistake'

    Reigning World Champion Marc Márquez labelled a tyre change pre-race as the "biggest mistake" as he slipped away from…

    MotoGP
  41. Canamasas to test again for Trident 14:32

    Canamasas to test again for Trident

    GP2 veteran Sergio Canamasas will again conduct Formula 2 testing with Trident for the second pre-season group running in…

    F2
  42. Hülkenberg 'just couldn't overtake' Alonso 14:10

    Hülkenberg 'just couldn't overtake' Alonso

    Renault's Nico Hülkenberg was left frustrated after dropping behind McLaren-Honda rival Fernando Alonso on the opening lap of…

    F1
  43. Vandoorne: McLaren race finish a milestone 12:02

    Vandoorne: McLaren race finish a milestone

    Stoffel Vandoorne says that reaching the finish of the Australian Grand Prix represented a milestone for McLaren-Honda…

    F1
  44. Sauber baffled at no Magnussen penalty 11:42

    Sauber baffled at no Magnussen penalty

    Sauber Team Principal Monisha Kaltenborn blasted an "incomprehensible" decision by the stewards not to penalise Kevin Magnussen…

    F1
more news