Stewart questions FIA-McLaren situation

Stewart questions FIA-McLaren situation

9 April 2009 – Former World Champion Jackie Stewart has admitted that he is confused over the severity of the situation in which the McLaren team finds itself at the moment; the Woking-based squad faces race bans or even the possibility of being thrown out of this year's World Championship after giving false information to race stewards regarding an incident in the Australian Grand Prix.

"My understanding is that the McLaren officials tried to contact Charlie (Whiting, race director) in the tower, by radio link, to ask for his position on the situation which had occurred between Hamilton and his Toyota rival, Jarno Trulli," Stewart explained. "But Charlie was apparently unavailable, trying to sort out the Sebastien Vettel problem in which the German was involved in a crash with BMW's Robert Kubica, and completed the last three laps with one of his tyres hanging off the car."

Stewart took the title in 1969, '71 and '73
The Hamilton-Trulli incident took place under the second and last safety car of the race, as Trulli lost third place to the McLaren after running wide and onto the grass. Hamilton then slowed to let the Italian through, only to explain (with sporting director Dave Ryan) to the stewards after the race that he had in fact not yielded. The FIA then investigated the radio communication between the two, revealing that the World Champion had been given clear instructions to allow the Toyota to retake the position. "It seems strange that only one person has the authority to deal with these inquiries, which could be result-changing in a multi-million-pound sport," Stewart continued. "When you have four stewards at the race, you would think they would have been able to clarify McLaren's position by radio, if Charlie was otherwise engaged. As it is, we now have a potentially serious state of affairs for McLaren - it is hard to see how they can escape stringent sanctions when Lewis has already apologised publicly and the team has admitted that it got things wrong, which leaves them at the mercy of the FIA.

"I am surprised that McLaren have been caught up in something like this, and if there were lies told, they will have to suffer the consequences and it is difficult to believe they will get off with simply a financial penalty, considering that the World Council fined them $100m for their role in an alleged spy scandal involving Ferrari as recently as 2007. We have to put things in perspective - yes, this episode has reminded us that Hamilton is still an inexperienced driver in the grand scheme of things and there is no excuse for telling fibs, if that is what happened."

Stewart added that the aftermath of the incident which brought out the safety car, though, should have been dealt with more seriously. "In my opinion, what Vettel did in Melbourne was potentially more serious than what McLaren have been accused of; that loose wheel could have flown into the crowd and killed somebody, yet he was only penalised 10 places on the grid at the next race, which is no more than a strong slap on the wrist." The German's Red Bull team was also handed with a fine of $50,000 for instructing their driver to attempt to finish the race, despite lacking the wheel.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Saturday 30 May 2015

  2. Muñoz wins chaotic, rain-shortened Race 1 22:35

    Muñoz wins chaotic, rain-shortened Race 1

    Andretti Autosport's Carlos Muñoz was one of many drivers who gambled on their race strategy at Belle Isle on Saturday, but he…

    Indy
  3. Rain threat moves up Detroit start 20:25

    Rain threat moves up Detroit start

    IndyCar officials have announced that the start time for the first of the Detroit doubleheader weekend will be moved forward by…

    Indy
  4. 15:06

    Latest FR3.5 photos: Saturday at Spa Francorchamps

    FR 3.5
  5. Vaxivière takes victory at Spa Francorchamps 15:02

    Vaxivière takes victory at Spa Francorchamps

    Matthieu Vaxivière recovered from a sub-par start to take his second Formula Renault 3.5 victory of the season at Spa…

    FR 3.5
  6. 14:04

    Latest MotoGP photos: Saturday at Mugello

    MotoGP
  7. Iannone secures maiden MotoGP pole 14:01

    Iannone secures maiden MotoGP pole

    Ducati's Andrea Iannone secured the maiden pole position of his MotoGP career for his and the team's home race at Mugello as…

    MotoGP
  8. Sainz Jr. to demo Red Bull F1 car in Peru 10:43

    Sainz Jr. to demo Red Bull F1 car in Peru

    Toro Rosso racer Carlos Sainz Jr. will demonstrate Red Bull Formula 1 machinery on the streets of Peruvian capital Lima on…

    F1
  9. Silverstone: British GP 95 per cent sold out 09:56

    Silverstone: British GP 95 per cent sold out

    Organisers of the British Grand Prix say that 95 per cent of the tickets for this year's event at Silverstone have been…

    F1
  10. Lorenzo sets record pace in third practice 09:49

    Lorenzo sets record pace in third practice

    Yamaha's Jorge Lorenzo continued his form by setting the quickest ever MotoGP lap around Mugello during Saturday's third…

    MotoGP
  11. GPUpdate's stars of the future: Raffaele Marciello 08:54

    GPUpdate's stars of the future: Raffaele Marciello

    As part of a series running throughout the 2015 campaign, GPUpdate.net is getting to know up-and-coming motor racing talents.…

    F1
  12. Video of the Day: Special Williams cufflinks 05:03

    Video of the Day: Special Williams cufflinks

    Hackett London and Williams combined to create a set of cufflinks re-engineered from a Formula 1 gearbox.

    F1
  13. Friday 29 May 2015

  14. Power takes Race 1 pole at Detroit 22:04

    Power takes Race 1 pole at Detroit

    Will Power broke another track record en route to taking pole for the first of two races in Detroit this weekend. The…

    Indy
  15. García returns for Moscow ePrix 19:21

    García returns for Moscow ePrix

    Spanish driver Antonio García will return to the Formula E Championship for next weekend's round in Moscow. García will…

    FE
  16. 16:32

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  17. Video: Stirling Moss at Mille Miglia 15:51

    Video: Stirling Moss at Mille Miglia

    Sir Stirling Moss and his Mille Miglia-winning Mercedes-Benz 300 SLR reunite, 60 years on from victory.

    F1
  18. Grosjean annoyed by brake test claims 14:34

    Grosjean annoyed by brake test claims

    Romain Grosjean says he was left annoyed by accusations that he brake tested Max Verstappen before their clash at the Monaco…

    F1
  19. 14:16

    Latest MotoGP photos: Friday at Mugello

    MotoGP
  20. Dovizioso stays on top in second practice 14:12

    Dovizioso stays on top in second practice

    Andrea Dovizioso kept Ducati on top during Friday afternoon's second free practice session for the Italian Grand Prix at…

    MotoGP
  21. Ecclestone sets Indian GP deadline 11:30

    Ecclestone sets Indian GP deadline

    Bernie Ecclestone has set a two month deadline for Indian Grand Prix organisers to get the event back on the calendar for the…

    F1
  22. Video: Force India drivers quizzed 10:23

    Video: Force India drivers quizzed

    Force India drivers Nico Hülkenberg and Sergio Pérez are quizzed on how well they know each other.

    F1
  23. Dovizioso tops first Mugello practice 09:58

    Dovizioso tops first Mugello practice

    Andrea Dovizioso and Ducati topped the times as their home Grand Prix weekend at Mugello got underway on Friday…

    MotoGP
  24. Bottas sure Monaco showing a one-off 08:02

    Bottas sure Monaco showing a one-off

    Valtteri Bottas is sure that his Williams team will return to form at the Canadian Grand Prix, after a highly challenging…

    F1
  25. Video of the Day: McLaren in Monaco 05:26

    Video of the Day: McLaren in Monaco

    McLaren celebrated the 10th year of its Johnnie Walker partnership with a special night out in Monaco.

    F1
  26. Thursday 28 May 2015

  27. FIA opens selection process for new team 21:04

    FIA opens selection process for new team

    Formula 1's governing body, the FIA, has officially opened up a new selection process to identify a candidate team to join the…

    F1
  28. Video: Drivers preview 'Dual in Detroit' 14:44

    Video: Drivers preview 'Dual in Detroit'

    Hélio Castroneves, Scott Dixon and Simon Pagenaud preview the 2015 'Dual in Detroit'.

    Indy
  29. Todt: No ban on alcohol sponsorship 12:36

    Todt: No ban on alcohol sponsorship

    FIA President Jean Todt has made clear that there will be no ban on alcohol sponsorship in Formula 1, describing such a move as…

    F1
  30. Jos Verstappen to join Max in F1 demo 11:24

    Jos Verstappen to join Max in F1 demo

    Max Verstappen will be joined on track by father Jos during next month's 'Italia a Zandvoort' event. While Max demonstrates a…

    F1
  31. Räikkönen given qualifying 'homework' 10:33

    Räikkönen given qualifying 'homework'

    Ferrari team boss Maurizio Arrivabene has urged Kimi Räikkönen to improve his qualifying performances at future Grands Prix…

    F1
  32. González, Vautier get Detroit seats 09:51

    González, Vautier get Detroit seats

    Rodolfo González and Tristan Vautier will reclaim seats at the Dale Coyne Racing squad for this weekend's IndyCar double-header…

    Indy
  33. Mark Sutton: Story Behind the Shot - Monaco 09:48

    Mark Sutton: Story Behind the Shot - Monaco

    Especially for lovers of motorsport photography, GPUpdate.net's race-by-race series, Story Behind the Shot, continues throughout…

    F1
  34. Magnussen: Vandoorne deserves F1 seat 09:07

    Magnussen: Vandoorne deserves F1 seat

    McLaren reserve Kevin Magnussen says there would be "something wrong" if GP2 championship leader Stoffel Vandoorne does not…

    F1
  35. Video of the Day: Brundle's Force India drive 05:00

    Video of the Day: Brundle's Force India drive

    Ex-F1 driver turned TV pundit Martin Brundle tests – and crashes – the Force India VJM08 at Silverstone.

    F1
  36. Wednesday 27 May 2015

  37. Hinchcliffe released from hospital 16:48

    Hinchcliffe released from hospital

    James Hinchcliffe was released from hospital on Tuesday, following surgery for the injuries he sustained during practice for the…

    Indy
  38. Wilson to make FE debut in Moscow 15:33

    Wilson to make FE debut in Moscow

    Justin Wilson will make his Formula E debut with Andretti Autosport at next month's Moscow round. Wilson competed in last…

    FE
  39. Grosjean 'didn't brake test' Verstappen 14:39

    Grosjean 'didn't brake test' Verstappen

    Lotus says it has data to prove that Romain Grosjean did not brake test Toro Rosso rival Max Verstappen prior to their collision…

    F1
  40. Video: Nico Rosberg's Monaco blog 14:16

    Video: Nico Rosberg's Monaco blog

    Nico Rosberg reflects on a dramatic Monaco Grand Prix that yielded his third straight win in the principality.

    F1
  41. Mallya targets constant points with new car 12:28

    Mallya targets constant points with new car

    Force India team boss Vijay Mallya has set his sights on recording constant points finishes when the outfit's full 2015…

    F1
  42. Verstappen vows to come back stronger 10:51

    Verstappen vows to come back stronger

    Toro Rosso rookie Max Verstappen says he will emerge a stronger driver from his dramatic accident at last weekend's Monaco Grand…

    F1
  43. Rossi in 'perfect' place for Mugello 10:35

    Rossi in 'perfect' place for Mugello

    MotoGP championship leader Valentino Rossi says he arrives at Mugello in a "perfect" frame of mind after his strong start to the…

    MotoGP
  44. 10:15

    Gallery: Best photos from the Monaco GP

    F1
more news