Stewart questions FIA-McLaren situation

Stewart questions FIA-McLaren situation

9 April 2009 – Former World Champion Jackie Stewart has admitted that he is confused over the severity of the situation in which the McLaren team finds itself at the moment; the Woking-based squad faces race bans or even the possibility of being thrown out of this year's World Championship after giving false information to race stewards regarding an incident in the Australian Grand Prix.

"My understanding is that the McLaren officials tried to contact Charlie (Whiting, race director) in the tower, by radio link, to ask for his position on the situation which had occurred between Hamilton and his Toyota rival, Jarno Trulli," Stewart explained. "But Charlie was apparently unavailable, trying to sort out the Sebastien Vettel problem in which the German was involved in a crash with BMW's Robert Kubica, and completed the last three laps with one of his tyres hanging off the car."

Stewart took the title in 1969, '71 and '73

The Hamilton-Trulli incident took place under the second and last safety car of the race, as Trulli lost third place to the McLaren after running wide and onto the grass. Hamilton then slowed to let the Italian through, only to explain (with sporting director Dave Ryan) to the stewards after the race that he had in fact not yielded. The FIA then investigated the radio communication between the two, revealing that the World Champion had been given clear instructions to allow the Toyota to retake the position. "It seems strange that only one person has the authority to deal with these inquiries, which could be result-changing in a multi-million-pound sport," Stewart continued. "When you have four stewards at the race, you would think they would have been able to clarify McLaren's position by radio, if Charlie was otherwise engaged. As it is, we now have a potentially serious state of affairs for McLaren - it is hard to see how they can escape stringent sanctions when Lewis has already apologised publicly and the team has admitted that it got things wrong, which leaves them at the mercy of the FIA.

"I am surprised that McLaren have been caught up in something like this, and if there were lies told, they will have to suffer the consequences and it is difficult to believe they will get off with simply a financial penalty, considering that the World Council fined them $100m for their role in an alleged spy scandal involving Ferrari as recently as 2007. We have to put things in perspective - yes, this episode has reminded us that Hamilton is still an inexperienced driver in the grand scheme of things and there is no excuse for telling fibs, if that is what happened."

Stewart added that the aftermath of the incident which brought out the safety car, though, should have been dealt with more seriously. "In my opinion, what Vettel did in Melbourne was potentially more serious than what McLaren have been accused of; that loose wheel could have flown into the crowd and killed somebody, yet he was only penalised 10 places on the grid at the next race, which is no more than a strong slap on the wrist." The German's Red Bull team was also handed with a fine of $50,000 for instructing their driver to attempt to finish the race, despite lacking the wheel.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Tuesday 22 July 2014

  2. D'Ambrosio joins Dragon Racing team 16:27

    D'Ambrosio joins Dragon Racing team

    Jérôme d'Ambrosio has completed Dragon Racing's line-up for the inaugural Formula E season. The 28-year-old Belgian, who p...

    Formula E
  3. Vergne to demo Red Bull F1 car at Assen 16:20

    Vergne to demo Red Bull F1 car at Assen

    Toro Rosso driver Jean-Éric Vergne will showcase a modern Formula 1 car at Assen next week. The Frenchman, contesting his...

    F1
  4. Hembery wants to keep testing in Bahrain 15:08

    Hembery wants to keep testing in Bahrain

    Pirelli Motorsport Director Paul Hembery is still hoping that Bahrain will be able to host a portion of pre-season testing...

    F1
  5. 14:09

    Photos: German GP in black and white

    F1
  6. Video: Pirelli's guide to the Hungarian GP 13:30

    Video: Pirelli's guide to the Hungarian GP

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli previews this weekend's Hungarian Grand Prix at the Hungaroring.

    F1
  7. Giovesi joins Caterham driver programme 11:58

    Giovesi joins Caterham driver programme

    Kevin Giovesi has become the second member of Caterham's new driver development programme. The 20-year-old Italian, who...

    F1
  8. Tost: Kvyat is doing a fantastic job 10:52

    Tost: Kvyat is doing a fantastic job

    Toro Rosso team boss Franz Tost has heaped praise on Daniil Kvyat for "doing a fantastic job" during the first half of his...

    F1
  9. Ecclestone: No doubts over Russian GP 10:16

    Ecclestone: No doubts over Russian GP

    Bernie Ecclestone says he has no doubts over the Russian Grand Prix following the MH17 tragedy. Malaysia Airlines Flight...

    F1
  10. Winners and Losers at the German Grand Prix 09:15

    Winners and Losers at the German Grand Prix

    Hockenheim played host to the 10th round of the season as Nico Rosberg claimed a comfortable victory, while Mercedes...

    F1
  11. Vettel out to keep up the momentum in Hungary 08:00

    Vettel out to keep up the momentum in Hungary

    Sebastian Vettel says he will work hard this coming weekend to "keep up the momentum" and get another strong result in...

    F1
  12. Pirelli expects usual two stops in Hungary 07:00

    Pirelli expects usual two stops in Hungary

    Pirelli Motorsport Director Paul Hembery believes teams and drivers will opt for the usual two stops in the Hungarian Grand...

    F1
  13. Hungaroring memories: Mansell secures title, 1992 05:00

    Hungaroring memories: Mansell secures title, 1992

    Relive the 1992 Hungarian Grand Prix, where Ayrton Senna won and Nigel Mansell finished second to secure the title.

    F1
  14. Monday 21 July 2014

  15. Formula E reveals Buenos Aires track layout 17:23

    Formula E reveals Buenos Aires track layout

    Formula E has revealed the track layout and location for the Buenos Aires ePrix, round four in the inaugural 2014/2015...

    Formula E
  16. Boullier: Useful clutch of points squandered 16:45

    Boullier: Useful clutch of points squandered

    Eric Boullier believes McLaren lost out on scoring a "useful clutch of points" in the German Grand Prix. Jenson Button...

    F1
  17. Video: Rosberg reflects on German GP win 16:00

    Video: Rosberg reflects on German GP win

    Mercedes driver Nico Rosberg reflects on his victory on home soil in the German Grand Prix.

    F1
  18. Horner wants clarification after brake change 15:13

    Horner wants clarification after brake change

    Red Bull team boss Christian Horner has asked the FIA to clarify why Lewis Hamilton was allowed to switch brake suppliers...

    F1
  19. Smedley: Both cars on podium aim now 14:34

    Smedley: Both cars on podium aim now

    Rob Smedley has said that Williams now wants a double podium finish in the wake of Valtteri Bottas' latest success in the...

    F1
  20. Hamilton: I can't focus more or work harder 13:55

    Hamilton: I can't focus more or work harder

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton says he cannot do any more to win the title this season and that he is already giving...

    F1
  21. Video: Montoya, Aleshin crash out in Toronto 13:30

    Video: Montoya, Aleshin crash out in Toronto

    Footage of Juan Pablo Montoya and Mikhail Aleshin crashing out in Race 2 in Toronto.

    Indy
  22. Wolff: German GP results 'feels' like 1-2 12:48

    Wolff: German GP results 'feels' like 1-2

    Mercedes boss Toto Wolff has said the team's double podium in the German Grand Prix 'feels' likes a one-two, given Lewis...

    F1
  23. Penalty point for Vergne after track limits breach 11:52

    Penalty point for Vergne after track limits breach

    Toro Rosso driver Jean-Éric Vergne has been given a penalty point on his licence following the German Grand Prix. Vergne...

    F1
  24. Button: I overreacted to Hamilton clash 11:29

    Button: I overreacted to Hamilton clash

    McLaren driver Jenson Button has backtracked on comments he made after he clashed with Lewis Hamilton in the German Grand...

    F1
  25. Kvyat: I saw smoke and flames in the mirrors 11:05

    Kvyat: I saw smoke and flames in the mirrors

    Toro Rosso driver Daniil Kvyat made a dramatic and fiery exit from the German Grand Prix last weekend. The incident...

    F1
  26. Vettel in 'fun' Hockenheim fight with Alonso 10:28

    Vettel in 'fun' Hockenheim fight with Alonso

    Sebastian Vettel says he enjoyed his scrap with Fernando Alonso during the German Grand Prix. It was a case of déjà-vu at...

    F1
  27. Alonso: Ferrari made small step forward 09:56

    Alonso: Ferrari made small step forward

    Fernando Alonso believes the Scuderia made a "small step forward" at the German Grand Prix. Alonso enjoyed battles with...

    F1
  28. Hungaroring memories: Inoue hit by medical car 05:00

    Hungaroring memories: Inoue hit by medical car

    Taki Inoue was dramatically hit by a medical car after retiring from the 1995 Hungarian Grand Prix.

    F1
  29. Sunday 20 July 2014

  30. Conway wins wet, chaotic Race 2 in Toronto 22:59

    Conway wins wet, chaotic Race 2 in Toronto

    Mike Conway has won by 3.5 seconds in a dramatic wet/dry second race in IndyCar's Toronto doubleheader. Pitting earlier...

    Indy
  31. Räikkönen blames damage for slump 17:15

    Räikkönen blames damage for slump

    Kimi Räikkönen has blamed car damage for his disappointing finish in Sunday's German Grand Prix. The Finn, on an opposing...

    F1
  32. Bourdais wins in Race 1 at Toronto, first since 2007 17:14

    Bourdais wins in Race 1 at Toronto, first since 2007

    Sebastien Bourdais has won his first open wheel race since 2007, claiming victory in the first race of the IndyCar Toronto...

    Indy
  33. Eriksson loses Hockenheim podium finish 16:58

    Eriksson loses Hockenheim podium finish

    Jimmy Eriksson's GP3 title bid has taken a hit after losing his podium in Sunday's race at Hockenheim. The Koiranen GP...

    GP3
  34. Button critical of Hamilton after clash 16:38

    Button critical of Hamilton after clash

    Jenson Button was left bemused by Lewis Hamilton's driving after the pair clashed during Sunday's German Grand Prix at...

    F1
  35. 16:37

    Latest F1 photos: Sunday at Hockenheim

    F1
  36. Ricciardo: Hockenheim was 'awesome fun' 16:36

    Ricciardo: Hockenheim was 'awesome fun'

    Red Bull driver Daniel Ricciardo hailed his German Grand Prix as 'awesome fun' after he recovered from an unfortunate...

    F1
  37. Force India duo struggle with front tyres 16:23

    Force India duo struggle with front tyres

    Force India duo Nico Hülkenberg and Sergio Pérez were left to lament heavy front tyre degradation during the German Grand P...

    F1
  38. Bottas: Engineers key in Hamilton battle 16:13

    Bottas: Engineers key in Hamilton battle

    Valtteri Bottas has paid tribute to his engineers for their assistance amid his late German Grand Prix battle with Lewis...

    F1
  39. Massa hits out at Magnussen after clash 16:07

    Massa hits out at Magnussen after clash

    Felipe Massa laid the blame fully at Kevin Magnussen's door after the duo collided on the opening lap of the German Grand...

    F1
  40. Hamilton left with mixed feelings after comeback 15:56

    Hamilton left with mixed feelings after comeback

    Lewis Hamilton was left with mixed feelings after his storming drive from 20th to third in the German Grand Prix. The...

    F1
  41. Nico Rosberg hails 'very special' victory 15:30

    Nico Rosberg hails 'very special' victory

    Nico Rosberg described as 'very special' his home victory in Sunday afternoon's German Grand Prix. The Mercedes driver,...

    F1
  42. 14:53

    In full: German Grand Prix race results

    F1
  43. Rosberg cruises to German Grand Prix win 14:40

    Rosberg cruises to German Grand Prix win

    Nico Rosberg took a comfortable victory during Sunday afternoon's German Grand Prix at Hockenheim. The Mercedes driver...

    F1
more news