Stewart: Schumacher should not have returned

Stewart: Schumacher should not have returned

27 May 2010 – Sir Jackie Stewart has questioned Michael Schumacher's Formula 1 comeback, believing that the 7-time World Champion seriously risks damaging his reputation as a winner. The Scot points the finger at the German's 'early' retirement at the end of the 2006 season.

Sir Jackie Stewart
With Ferrari keen to hire Kimi Räikkönen at the time and with Schumacher having built up a friendly relationship with team-mate Felipe Massa, some consider the Kerpen man to have felt obliged to depart the sport earlier than planned, so as to not force the Brazilian out of a top seat.

Triple Champion Stewart believes, however, that the Mercedes driver is now more vulnerable than previously.

"I'd rather that Michael hadn't come back because of the enormous achievements he had and the reputation he created," the title winner of 1969, 1971 and 1973 explained to the Press Association. "There's no doubt that, if he doesn't become a serial winner now, he is no longer the Michael Schumacher the world knew.

"Juan Manuel Fangio probably did one race too many but Michael is doing one season too many; Michael didn't win the championship in his last year and has then come back, so he risks altering the perception of what he's achieved."

4th in Spain is Schumacher's best 2010 result to date
However, Stewart hints that the decision made three and a half years ago was arguably a greater error than that of last Christmas.

"The problem was that Michael retired too early, leaving before he got the bug that motor racing provides out of his system," Sir Jackie continued. "Had he thought more about it and taken longer to make the decision, he wouldn't have retired. Since he hadn't got it out of his system, he went riding superbikes in Germany and fell off more than once - it doesn't make sense at all.

"Mercedes-Benz looked like the perfect opportunity but, had Jim Clark retired, he would not have come back. When I retired I never once had the desire to return, despite a whole bunch of offers including one for six million. I got over it, something that Michael hasn't managed to do."

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Monday 24 April 2017

  2. 17:02

    Follow GPUpdate on Instagram in 2017!

    F1
  3. Video: Alonso press conference at Barber 16:04

    Video: Alonso press conference at Barber

    Watch as Fernando Alonso fields questions about his upcoming attempt at the Indianapolis 500.

    F1
  4. In photos: Alonso visits IndyCar paddock 12:35

    In photos: Alonso visits IndyCar paddock

    Fernando Alonso attended last weekend's Grand Prix of Alabama as part of his preparations for an assault on the Indianapolis 500…

    F1
  5. Video: Performing a perfect FE pit-stop 12:02

    Video: Performing a perfect FE pit-stop

    Venturi driver Maro Engel talks through the key elements to pull off a perfect Formula E pit-stop.

    FE
  6. Viñales vows to return 'stronger' after crash 11:12

    Viñales vows to return 'stronger' after crash

    Maverick Viñales says he will quickly put his crash at the Grand Prix of the Americas to the back of his mind and return…

    MotoGP
  7. Venturi calls up Dillmann for Paris ePrix 10:20

    Venturi calls up Dillmann for Paris ePrix

    Tom Dillmann will make his Formula E debut with Venturi in next month's Paris ePrix. Dillmann, who won the Formula V8 3.5…

    FE
  8. Rossi's 2017 title lead 'a great surprise' 10:02

    Rossi's 2017 title lead 'a great surprise'

    Valentino Rossi says it comes as "a great surprise" to himself and Yamaha that he leads the MotoGP title race after the first…

    MotoGP
  9. Video: IndyCar GP of Alabama highlights 09:32

    Video: IndyCar GP of Alabama highlights

    Watch highlights of Sunday's IndyCar Grand Prix of Alabama at the Barber Motorsports Park.

    Indy
  10. Márquez 'back' in title race with Austin win 09:16

    Márquez 'back' in title race with Austin win

    Repsol Honda rider Marc Márquez says he is "back in the championship" fight after his victory at the Grand Prix of the Americas…

    MotoGP
  11. Video of the Day: Prema's 'Guess the song' 05:24

    Video of the Day: Prema's 'Guess the song'

    Prema Formula 2 drivers Charles Leclerc and Antonio Fuoco, along with Formula 4 pair Juri Vips and Juan Manuel Correa, challenge…

    F2
  12. 03:10

    MotoGP standings after GP of the Americas

    MotoGP
  13. Sunday 23 April 2017

  14. 22:50

    Latest IndyCar photos: Sunday at Barber

    Indy
  15. Newgarden wins after Power's puncture 22:48

    Newgarden wins after Power's puncture

    Josef Newgarden won for the first time as a Penske driver, holding off Scott Dixon at the Grand Prix of Alabama after race…

    Indy
  16. 21:10

    Latest MotoGP photos: Sunday at Austin

    MotoGP
  17. 21:07

    In full: GP of the Americas race results

    MotoGP
  18. Márquez takes fifth straight Austin victory 20:53

    Márquez takes fifth straight Austin victory

    Reigning World Champion Marc Márquez preserved his perfect record at the Circuit of the Americas as he claimed victory, while…

    MotoGP
  19. 19:00

    Starting grid for the GP of the Americas

    MotoGP
  20. Video: Super Formula Suzuka highlights 13:59

    Video: Super Formula Suzuka highlights

    Watch race highlights from Sunday's opening round of the 2017 Super Formula season at Suzuka.

    SF
  21. Nakajima wins race, Gasly top rookie 13:23

    Nakajima wins race, Gasly top rookie

    Former Formula 1 driver Kazuki Nakajima triumphed at the opening Super Formula round of the season at Suzuka as Red Bull reserve…

    SF
  22. Lorenzo pleased to confirm 'good feeling' 13:06

    Lorenzo pleased to confirm 'good feeling'

    Jorge Lorenzo says he was lifted by confirming the "good feeling" he developed at the preceding round in Argentina, as he…

    MotoGP
  23. Video: GP of Alabama qualifying highlights 10:56

    Video: GP of Alabama qualifying highlights

    Watch highlights from Saturday's track action for the Grand Prix of Alabama at the Barber Motorsports Park.

    Indy
  24. Márquez 'didn't expect' Austin pole position 09:24

    Márquez 'didn't expect' Austin pole position

    Marc Márquez says he "didn't expect" to claim pole position for the Grand Prix of the Americas, having struggled across the…

    MotoGP
  25. Video of the Day: Verstappen photobombs fans 05:34

    Video of the Day: Verstappen photobombs fans

    Red Bull Formula 1 driver Max Verstappen surprises customers at a supermarket in his native Netherlands...

    F1
  26. Saturday 22 April 2017

  27. 23:16

    Latest IndyCar photos: Saturday at Barber

    Indy
  28. Power leads Penske trio in Barber qualifying 23:12

    Power leads Penske trio in Barber qualifying

    Will Power led a Penske/Chevy 1–2–3 in qualifying at Barber Motorsports Park on Saturday, earning the 46th pole of his…

    Indy
  29. 21:34

    Latest MotoGP photos: Saturday at Austin

    MotoGP
  30. Injured Rins to fly home for wrist surgery 21:33

    Injured Rins to fly home for wrist surgery

    Suzuki rider Álex Rins will undergo surgery in his native Spain, after fracturing his left wrist, with no time frame yet placed…

    MotoGP
  31. Márquez beats Viñales in qualifying thriller 21:00

    Márquez beats Viñales in qualifying thriller

    Reigning World Champion Marc Márquez maintained his unbeaten record at the Circuit of the Americas after prevailing in a…

    MotoGP
  32. Avintia continues with Ducati for 2018 20:14

    Avintia continues with Ducati for 2018

    Avintia has renewed its contract as a customer Ducati squad, with both of its riders set to use the Italian manufacturer's 2017…

    MotoGP
  33. Viñales heads crash-filled COTA FP3 17:14

    Viñales heads crash-filled COTA FP3

    Championship leader Maverick Viñales returned to the top of the leaderboard for Yamaha during a crash-strewn third practice…

    MotoGP
  34. Steiner: 'Big three' teams will remain clear 14:46

    Steiner: 'Big three' teams will remain clear

    Haas Team Principal Guenther Steiner says he expects the leading three teams – Mercedes, Ferrari and Red Bull – to remain…

    F1
  35. Video: Onboard with Hunter-Reay at Barber 12:24

    Video: Onboard with Hunter-Reay at Barber

    Ride onboard with Andretti driver Ryan Hunter-Reay ahead of this weekend's Grand Prix of Alabama at the Barber Motorsports Park

    Indy
  36. Ricciardo to conduct Budapest demo run 10:28

    Ricciardo to conduct Budapest demo run

    Daniel Ricciardo will demonstrate Red Bull Formula 1 machinery during an event in Hungary's capital, Budapest, next…

    F1
  37. Abraham fractures ankle in Bautista clash 08:28

    Abraham fractures ankle in Bautista clash

    Aspar rider Karel Abraham has sustained a fractured right ankle following a collision with team-mate Álvaro Bautista during…

    MotoGP
  38. Video of the Day: 2017 strategy so far... 05:36

    Video of the Day: 2017 strategy so far...

    3 races down, 17 to go. Using Mercedes' 'Pure Pit Wall', Chief Strategist James Vowles talks about tyre degradation, overtakes…

    F1
  39. Friday 21 April 2017

  40. 21:04

    Latest MotoGP photos: Friday at Austin

    MotoGP
  41. Márquez moves ahead in Austin FP2 21:01

    Márquez moves ahead in Austin FP2

    Reigning World Champion Marc Márquez vaulted to the top of the timesheets during the second practice session at the Circuit of…

    MotoGP
  42. Viñales comfortably quickest in FP1 17:04

    Viñales comfortably quickest in FP1

    MotoGP championship leader Maverick Viñales comfortably set the pace during Friday's first practice session for the Grand Prix…

    MotoGP
  43. Kvyat aims for complete home showing 15:32

    Kvyat aims for complete home showing

    Toro Rosso driver Daniil Kvyat has targeted a more complete performance at his home Grand Prix in Russia next weekend, after…

    F1
  44. Honda feels it is 'heading in right direction' 13:12

    Honda feels it is 'heading in right direction'

    McLaren engine partner Honda is confident that it is "heading in the right direction" following a positive conclusion to this…

    F1
more news