Stewart: Schumacher should not have returned

Stewart: Schumacher should not have returned

27 May 2010 – Sir Jackie Stewart has questioned Michael Schumacher's Formula 1 comeback, believing that the 7-time World Champion seriously risks damaging his reputation as a winner. The Scot points the finger at the German's 'early' retirement at the end of the 2006 season.

Sir Jackie Stewart

With Ferrari keen to hire Kimi Räikkönen at the time and with Schumacher having built up a friendly relationship with team-mate Felipe Massa, some consider the Kerpen man to have felt obliged to depart the sport earlier than planned, so as to not force the Brazilian out of a top seat.

Triple Champion Stewart believes, however, that the Mercedes driver is now more vulnerable than previously.

"I'd rather that Michael hadn't come back because of the enormous achievements he had and the reputation he created," the title winner of 1969, 1971 and 1973 explained to the Press Association. "There's no doubt that, if he doesn't become a serial winner now, he is no longer the Michael Schumacher the world knew.

"Juan Manuel Fangio probably did one race too many but Michael is doing one season too many; Michael didn't win the championship in his last year and has then come back, so he risks altering the perception of what he's achieved."

4th in Spain is Schumacher's best 2010 result to date

However, Stewart hints that the decision made three and a half years ago was arguably a greater error than that of last Christmas.

"The problem was that Michael retired too early, leaving before he got the bug that motor racing provides out of his system," Sir Jackie continued. "Had he thought more about it and taken longer to make the decision, he wouldn't have retired. Since he hadn't got it out of his system, he went riding superbikes in Germany and fell off more than once - it doesn't make sense at all.

"Mercedes-Benz looked like the perfect opportunity but, had Jim Clark retired, he would not have come back. When I retired I never once had the desire to return, despite a whole bunch of offers including one for six million. I got over it, something that Michael hasn't managed to do."

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Monday 22 September 2014

  2. Red Bull not yet considering team orders 11:11

    Red Bull not yet considering team orders

    Red Bull says it is not yet considering team orders, despite Daniel Ricciardo keeping himself within touching distance of...

    F1
  3. Video: 360-degree onboard with Buemi in Assen 10:18

    Video: 360-degree onboard with Buemi in Assen

    Sébastien Buemi put a Red Bull Formula 1 car through its paces in front of 82,000 spectators last month, as part of the...

    F1
  4. Caterham encouraged despite Kobayashi non-start 10:16

    Caterham encouraged despite Kobayashi non-start

    Caterham Team Principal Manfredi Ravetto says he is encouraged by the outfit's performance in the Singapore Grand Prix, even...

    F1
  5. Gutiérrez: Almost impossible to achieve good results 09:40

    Gutiérrez: Almost impossible to achieve good results

    Esteban Gutiérrez says it is almost impossible for Sauber to achieve good results after the Mexican slumped to his sixth...

    F1
  6. Video: Rosberg reflects on Singapore retirement 09:35

    Video: Rosberg reflects on Singapore retirement

    Nico Rosberg looks back on his short-lived Singapore Grand Prix; after starting from the pit lane and retiring amid...

    F1
  7. Wolff admits Mercedes needs better reliability 08:58

    Wolff admits Mercedes needs better reliability

    Mercedes boss Toto Wolff has admitted that the squad needs to improve its reliability as the championship fight enters its...

    F1
  8. Mattiacci upbeat over Ferrari progress in Singapore 07:34

    Mattiacci upbeat over Ferrari progress in Singapore

    Ferrari Team Principal Marco Mattiacci says he is confident that his squad is improving following its showing in the...

    F1
  9. Video of the Day: UPS delivers special Ferrari 05:03

    Video of the Day: UPS delivers special Ferrari

    UPS delivered a special F1 car, made of bark and fittonia, to Singapore. Representing Ferrari's partnership with the...

    F1
  10. 03:04

    Championship standings after Singapore

    F1
  11. Sunday 21 September 2014

  12. Alonso rues timing of Safety Car deployment 18:54

    Alonso rues timing of Safety Car deployment

    Fernando Alonso was left to rue the timing of the Safety Car as he raced to fourth position in the Singapore Grand...

    F1
  13. Bottas links late slump to power steering 17:53

    Bottas links late slump to power steering

    Valtteri Bottas says an issue with his power steering system contributed to his tumble down the order in the Singapore Grand...

    F1
  14. 17:45

    Latest F1 photos: Sunday in Singapore

    F1
  15. Force India reclaims fifth from McLaren 17:31

    Force India reclaims fifth from McLaren

    Force India boss Vijay Mallya was suitably elated after his team moved ahead of McLaren in the battle for fifth in the...

    F1
  16. Magnussen treated for burns after scoring point 17:05

    Magnussen treated for burns after scoring point

    Kevin Magnussen was treated for burns by doctors after the McLaren driver battled to 10th place at the Singapore Grand...

    F1
  17. Vergne fights back to earn best result of season 17:05

    Vergne fights back to earn best result of season

    Outgoing Toro Rosso driver Jean-Éric Vergne recorded his best finish in over a year as he battled to sixth in the Singapore...

    F1
  18. Vettel questions timing of Hamilton move 16:35

    Vettel questions timing of Hamilton move

    Sebastian Vettel reckons Lewis Hamilton took more risks than he needed to when passing him during Sunday's Singapore Grand...

    F1
  19. Hamilton hails 'clean' Singapore weekend 16:13

    Hamilton hails 'clean' Singapore weekend

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton was pleased after a "clean" Singapore Grand Prix weekend culminated in him taking a vital...

    F1
  20. Rosberg urges Mercedes to improve reliability 15:51

    Rosberg urges Mercedes to improve reliability

    Nico Rosberg has urged Mercedes to improve its reliability after his costly retirement from Sunday night's Singapore Grand...

    F1
  21. 15:27

    In full: Singapore Grand Prix race result

    F1
  22. Hamilton takes title lead with Singapore win 15:10

    Hamilton takes title lead with Singapore win

    Lewis Hamilton moved into the lead of the championship with a commanding victory in Sunday night's Singapore Grand Prix,...

    F1
  23. 12:35

    Follow the 2014 Singapore Grand Prix live!

    F1
  24. Video: Hill, Herbert become mechanics 10:44

    Video: Hill, Herbert become mechanics

    Watch as Damon Hill and Johnny Herbert become Marussia mechanics for a practice session in Singapore.

    F1
  25. 10:42

    Photos: Historic F1 race in Singapore

    F1
  26. Hamilton: Rosberg relations 'back to normal' 10:41

    Hamilton: Rosberg relations 'back to normal'

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton says that his relationship with team-mate Nico Rosberg is 'back to normal' following the...

    F1
  27. Grosjean hits out at Renault problems 07:02

    Grosjean hits out at Renault problems

    Romain Grosjean has hit out at continual Renault problems, which he says are having a negative impact on the morale of his...

    F1
  28. 06:32

    Photos: Special helmets for Singapore

    F1
  29. Video of the Day: Formula 1's Safety Car 05:03

    Video of the Day: Formula 1's Safety Car

    There has never been a Singapore Grand Prix without the appearance of Formula 1's Safety Car. Ahead of the night race,...

    F1
  30. Pérez sure of Force India race recovery 01:04

    Pérez sure of Force India race recovery

    Force India driver Sergio Pérez says he is sure that he can recover from a lowly grid spot and notch up a top 10 finish in...

    F1
  31. 00:35

    Starting grid for the Singapore Grand Prix

    F1
  32. Saturday 20 September 2014

  33. Massa encouraged by Williams improvements 18:32

    Massa encouraged by Williams improvements

    Felipe Massa says he is encouraged by the progress which Williams has made since Friday's practice sessions after qualifying...

    F1
  34. 17:25

    Latest F1 photos: Saturday in Singapore

    F1
  35. Magnussen seeks help from Safety Car 17:24

    Magnussen seeks help from Safety Car

    Kevin Magnussen says he is hoping to see the Safety Car called into action during Sunday evening's Singapore Grand...

    F1
  36. Alonso hopeful of fighting for victory 17:09

    Alonso hopeful of fighting for victory

    Ferrari driver Fernando Alonso is hopeful that he will be able to challenge for victory during Sunday's Singapore Grand...

    F1
  37. Vettel reckons pole position was possible 16:42

    Vettel reckons pole position was possible

    Sebastian Vettel feels he could have had a shot at claiming pole position in Singapore with a cleaner final qualifying...

    F1
  38. Rosberg ruing late change of brakes 16:16

    Rosberg ruing late change of brakes

    Nico Rosberg was left to rue a change of brakes after Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton beat him to pole position in...

    F1
  39. Hamilton pleased to recover from early error 15:57

    Hamilton pleased to recover from early error

    Lewis Hamilton says he was pleased with his recovery after an early error threatened to ruin his final qualifying attempt in...

    F1
  40. 15:08

    Singapore GP: Qualifying results in full

    F1
  41. Hamilton pips Rosberg to Singapore pole 15:07

    Hamilton pips Rosberg to Singapore pole

    Lewis Hamilton beat Mercedes team-mate Nico Rosberg to pole position during a tight qualifying session in Singapore, with...

    F1
  42. 13:52

    Follow qualifying for the Singapore GP!

    F1
  43. 12:16

    Singapore GP: Full Free Practice 3 results

    F1
more news