Analysis: Comparing the points systems

Analysis: Comparing the points systems

24 November 2010 – For the first time in the sport’s history, 2010 saw Formula 1 award World Championship points to the top ten race finishers. But did you know that, under the previous scoring system, Lewis Hamilton would have beaten Mark Webber to third place overall and Jaime Alguersuari would not have celebrated his first F1 points?...

Comparisons of the points systems have been a hot topic this season, although GPUpdate.net’s mathematics confirm just how tight F1 2010 would have remained, regardless of the scoring structure in place.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How the actual 2010 season finished up:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 10 SCORING SYSTEM

Winner 25
Second 18
Third 15
Fourth 12
Fifth 10
Sixth 8
Seventh 6
Eighth 4
Ninth 2
Tenth 1

DRIVERS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Sebastian Vettel – 256
2. Fernando Alonso – 252
3. Mark Webber – 242
4. Lewis Hamilton – 240
5. Jenson Button – 214
6. Felipe Massa – 144
7. Nico Rosberg – 142
8. Robert Kubica – 136
9. Michael Schumacher – 72
10. Rubens Barrichello – 47
11. Adrian Sutil – 47
12. Kamui Kobayashi – 32
13. Vitaly Petrov – 27
14. Nico Hülkenberg – 22
15. Vitantonio Liuzzi – 21
16. Sébastien Buemi – 8
17. Pedro de la Rosa – 6
18. Nick Heidfeld – 6
19. Jaime Alguersuari – 5

CONSTRUCTORS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Red Bull-Renault – 498
2. McLaren-Mercedes – 454
3. Ferrari – 396
4. Mercedes GP – 214
5. Renault – 163
6. Williams-Cosworth – 69
7. Force India-Mercedes – 68
8. Sauber-Ferrari – 44
9. Toro Rosso-Ferrari – 13
10. Lotus-Cosworth – 0
11. Hispania-Cosworth – 0
12. Virgin-Cosworth – 0

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How things would look under the scoring system of the previous seven seasons:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 8 SCORING SYSTEM


Winner 10
Second 8
Third 6
Fourth 5
Fifth 4
Sixth 3
Seventh 2
Eighth 1

DRIVERS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Sebastian Vettel – 104
2. Fernando Alonso – 101
3. Lewis Hamilton – 100
4. Mark Webber – 97
5. Jenson Button – 87
6. Felipe Massa – 57
7. Nico Rosberg – 55
8. Robert Kubica – 52
9. Michael Schumacher – 25
10. Rubens Barrichello – 15
11. Adrian Sutil – 15
12. Kamui Kobayashi – 9
13. Vitaly Petrov – 9
14. Nico Hülkenberg – 6
15. Vitantonio Liuzzi – 5
16. Pedro de la Rosa 2
17. Sébastien Buemi - 1
18. Nick Heidfeld – 1

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Hamilton moves ahead of Webber for P3
- Barrichello and Sutil remain level on points for P10 and P11
- De la Rosa moves ahead of Buemi for P16 and scores more points than Sauber replacement Nick Heidfeld, as opposed to level-pegging
- Alguersuari would not have scored his first F1 points

CONSTRUCTORS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Red Bull-Renault – 201
2. McLaren-Mercedes – 187
3. Ferrari – 158
4. Mercedes GP – 80
5. Renault – 61
6. Williams-Cosworth – 21
7. Force India-Mercedes – 20
8. Sauber-Ferrari – 12
9. Toro Rosso-Ferrari – 1
10. Lotus-Cosworth – 0
11. Hispania Cosworth – 0
12. Virgin-Cosworth – 0

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Williams would still beat Force India to P6 by a single point
- Toro Rosso would score only a single point, equalling its lowest points haul to date (2006 – the team’s first season)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How things would look under the scoring system of 1991-2002:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 6 SCORING SYSTEM


Winner 10
Second 6
Third 4
Fourth 3
Fifth 2
Sixth 1

DRIVERS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Sebastian Vettel – 84
2. Fernando Alonso – 81
3. Mark Webber – 76
4. Lewis Hamilton – 76
5. Jenson Button – 61
6. Felipe Massa – 34
7. Nico Rosberg – 28
8. Robert Kubica – 26
9. Michael Schumacher – 11
10. Rubens Barrichello – 6
11. Adrian Sutil – 5
12. Vitaly Petrov – 3
13. Kamui Kobayashi – 1
14. Nico Hülkenberg – 1
15. Vitantonio Liuzzi – 1

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Only the top nine drivers would move into double figures
- Hamilton would draw level with Webber, although the Australian would retain P3 due to having four races wins to Hamilton’s three
- Barrichello would score more points than Sutil for P10, as opposed to level-pegging
- Petrov would move ahead of Kobayashi for P12, as the Japanese draws level with the points sums of Hülkenberg and Liuzzi
- Buemi, de la Rosa, Heidfeld and Alguersuari would all fail to score

CONSTRUCTORS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Red Bull-Renault – 160
2. McLaren-Mercedes – 137
3. Ferrari – 115
4. Mercedes GP – 39
5. Renault – 29
6. Williams-Cosworth – 7
7. Force India-Mercedes – 6
8. Sauber-Ferrari – 1
9. Toro Rosso-Ferrari – 0
10. Lotus-Cosworth – 0
11. Hispania-Cosworth – 0
12. Virgin-Cosworth – 0

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Williams would still beat Force India to P6 by a single point
- Sauber would score only a single point
- Toro Rosso would fail to score

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How things would look in the top five of the Drivers' Championship under Bernie Ecclestone’s proposed medals system, which would hand out awards of gold, silver and bronze to podium finishers:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Sebastian Vettel – 5 gold, 2 silver, 3 bronze but 3 fourth places
2. Fernando Alonso – 5 gold, 2 silver, 3 bronze and 2 fourth places
3. Mark Webber – 4 gold
4. Lewis Hamilton – 3 gold
5. Jenson Button – 2 gold



Gregory Haines

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Saturday 27 August 2016

  2. 14:06

    Belgian Grand Prix: Full qualifying results

    F1
  3. Rosberg beats Verstappen to Belgian GP pole 14:05

    Rosberg beats Verstappen to Belgian GP pole

    Mercedes driver Nico Rosberg beat Red Bull's Max Verstappen to pole position for the Belgian Grand Prix, taking full advantage…

    F1
  4. Gutiérrez hit with five-place grid penalty 13:34

    Gutiérrez hit with five-place grid penalty

    Haas' Esteban Gutiérrez has been handed a five-place grid penalty for the Belgian Grand Prix following an incident with Manor…

    F1
  5. 12:46

    Follow qualifying for the Belgian Grand Prix!

    F1
  6. Hamilton up to 55-place grid penalty at Spa 11:08

    Hamilton up to 55-place grid penalty at Spa

    Mercedes has confirmed that it has carried out further changes to Lewis Hamilton's F1 W07 Hybrid on Saturday morning in Belgium…

    F1
  7. 11:06

    Belgian Grand Prix: Full Practice 3 results

    F1
  8. Räikkönen puts Ferrari on top in final practice 11:04

    Räikkönen puts Ferrari on top in final practice

    Kimi Räikkönen put Ferrari on top during final practice for the Belgian Grand Prix, ahead of Red Bull's Daniel Ricciardo and…

    F1
  9. Wolff: I'll make sure Vandoorne gets seat 10:37

    Wolff: I'll make sure Vandoorne gets seat

    Mercedes boss Toto Wolff has promised to find Stoffel Vandoorne a seat in Formula 1 for the 2017 season, if McLaren-Honda does…

    F1
  10. 09:52

    Follow final practice for the Belgian GP!

    F1
  11. Leclerc extends title lead with Belgium pole 09:19

    Leclerc extends title lead with Belgium pole

    Charles Leclerc extended his GP3 Series title lead as he stormed to pole position for the opening race of the weekend at…

    GP3
  12. Sauber pair able to note gains from new parts 08:34

    Sauber pair able to note gains from new parts

    Sauber pair Marcus Ericsson and Felipe Nasr say they were able to note gains made by the team after it introduced a raft of…

    F1
  13. Alonso sure Honda update marks 'step forward' 08:16

    Alonso sure Honda update marks 'step forward'

    Fernando Alonso says he is sure that Honda's updated power unit will mark a "step forward", despite his limited and dialled-down…

    F1
  14. Massa: Williams/Force India fight 'tough' 07:36

    Massa: Williams/Force India fight 'tough'

    Felipe Massa says Williams faces a "tough" fight against Force India to secure fourth in the standings, with the two teams…

    F1
  15. Wehrlein: Hot weather should boost Manor 06:42

    Wehrlein: Hot weather should boost Manor

    Manor driver Pascal Wehrlein believes high temperatures should suit the team, following an eye-catching display during Friday's…

    F1
  16. Video of the Day: Past, present and future race 05:42

    Video of the Day: Past, present and future race

    Fernando Alonso takes on McLaren team-mates Jenson Button and Stoffel Vandoorne, and ex-Formula 1 racers Mika Häkkinen and…

    F1
  17. Friday 26 August 2016

  18. Force India 'not perfect' despite strong pace 17:04

    Force India 'not perfect' despite strong pace

    Force India's Nico Hülkenberg believes there is still more pace to come from the VJM09, after an encouraging pair of practice…

    F1
  19. Grosjean critical of high tyre pressures 16:57

    Grosjean critical of high tyre pressures

    Haas driver Romain Grosjean has criticised Pirelli's mandatory tyre pressures at the Belgian Grand Prix, which he says makes the…

    F1
  20. 16:24

    F1 photos: Friday at Spa-Francorchamps

    F1
  21. Mercedes used five tokens for Spa upgrade 16:16

    Mercedes used five tokens for Spa upgrade

    Mercedes has revealed that it used up five of its engine development tokens on its Belgian Grand Prix upgrade, leaving it with…

    F1
  22. Vettel: Opening day 'very tricky' for Ferrari 16:07

    Vettel: Opening day 'very tricky' for Ferrari

    Sebastian Vettel has labelled the first day of practice for the Belgian Grand Prix as "very tricky", after he finished fourth…

    F1
  23. Rosberg: Halo device did not disturb me 15:52

    Rosberg: Halo device did not disturb me

    Nico Rosberg has described his test with the 'halo' cockpit protection device during Belgian Grand Prix practice as a…

    F1
  24. Hamilton thanks mechanics after 'tough' day 15:45

    Hamilton thanks mechanics after 'tough' day

    Lewis Hamilton heaped praise on his Mercedes mechanics after a "tough day" of work in Belgium, prior to taking a substantial…

    F1
  25. 15:32

    GP2 photos: Friday at Spa-Francorchamps

    GP2
  26. Giovinazzi beats team-mate Gasly to pole 15:30

    Giovinazzi beats team-mate Gasly to pole

    Antonio Giovinazzi edged out Prema team-mate Pierre Gasly to secure his second GP2 Series pole position of the season at…

    GP2
  27. Verstappen: Red Bull 'better than expected' 15:13

    Verstappen: Red Bull 'better than expected'

    Max Verstappen admits that Red Bull is performing "better than expected" at the Belgian Grand Prix, but is refusing to get…

    F1
  28. 14:34

    Belgian Grand Prix: Full Practice 2 results

    F1
  29. Verstappen leads Red Bull 1-2 in second practice 14:32

    Verstappen leads Red Bull 1-2 in second practice

    Max Verstappen led team-mate Daniel Ricciardo in a Red Bull 1-2 during Friday afternoon's second practice session for the…

    F1
  30. 12:52

    Follow second practice for the Belgian GP!

    F1
  31. Alonso faces hefty grid drop for new PU 12:25

    Alonso faces hefty grid drop for new PU

    McLaren-Honda driver Fernando Alonso faces a grid drop worth 35 places at this weekend's Belgian Grand Prix, having taken on a…

    F1
  32. Ericsson set for 10-place grid penalty 11:16

    Ericsson set for 10-place grid penalty

    Sauber driver Marcus Ericsson is set to drop 10 places from wherever he qualifies after a new Turbocharger, his sixth of the…

    F1
  33. 10:35

    Belgian Grand Prix: Full Practice 1 results

    F1
  34. Rosberg comfortably tops first Spa practice 10:33

    Rosberg comfortably tops first Spa practice

    Nico Rosberg topped the timesheets during Friday morning's first practice session for the Belgian Grand Prix, ahead of Mercedes…

    F1
  35. 08:51

    Follow first practice for the Belgian GP!

    F1
  36. Wehrlein: Ocon arrival won't change approach 08:34

    Wehrlein: Ocon arrival won't change approach

    Manor driver Pascal Wehrlein says he is "looking forward" to taking on new team-mate Esteban Ocon, but insists the arrival of…

    F1
  37. IndyCar reveals 17-race 2017 calendar 08:02

    IndyCar reveals 17-race 2017 calendar

    IndyCar officials have revealed an expanded 17-race 2017 calendar, which features a trip to the Gateway Motorsports Park for the…

    Indy
  38. Steiner perplexed by Gutiérrez comments 07:03

    Steiner perplexed by Gutiérrez comments

    Haas team boss Guenther Steiner says it is "status quo" for the outfit regarding its 2017 driver pairing, after Esteban…

    F1
  39. Video of the Day: Räikkönen previews Belgian GP 05:06

    Video of the Day: Räikkönen previews Belgian GP

    Ferrari driver Kimi Räikkönen looks ahead to the Belgian Grand Prix, an event he has won four times.

    F1
  40. Thursday 25 August 2016

  41. 18:16

    F1 photos: Thursday at Spa-Francorchamps

    F1
  42. Rosberg: Hamilton drop means Spa 'less difficult' 18:14

    Rosberg: Hamilton drop means Spa 'less difficult'

    Nico Rosberg admits that Lewis Hamilton's grid penalty will make his Belgian Grand Prix weekend "less difficult" but nonetheless…

    F1
  43. Vettel confident over Belgian GP tyre selection 16:10

    Vettel confident over Belgian GP tyre selection

    Sebastian Vettel says that he has faith in Ferrari's aggressive tyre selection for the Belgian Grand Prix, despite anticipated…

    F1
more news