Analysis: Comparing the points systems

Analysis: Comparing the points systems

24 November 2010 – For the first time in the sport’s history, 2010 saw Formula 1 award World Championship points to the top ten race finishers. But did you know that, under the previous scoring system, Lewis Hamilton would have beaten Mark Webber to third place overall and Jaime Alguersuari would not have celebrated his first F1 points?...

Comparisons of the points systems have been a hot topic this season, although GPUpdate.net’s mathematics confirm just how tight F1 2010 would have remained, regardless of the scoring structure in place.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How the actual 2010 season finished up:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 10 SCORING SYSTEM

Winner 25
Second 18
Third 15
Fourth 12
Fifth 10
Sixth 8
Seventh 6
Eighth 4
Ninth 2
Tenth 1

DRIVERS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Sebastian Vettel – 256
2. Fernando Alonso – 252
3. Mark Webber – 242
4. Lewis Hamilton – 240
5. Jenson Button – 214
6. Felipe Massa – 144
7. Nico Rosberg – 142
8. Robert Kubica – 136
9. Michael Schumacher – 72
10. Rubens Barrichello – 47
11. Adrian Sutil – 47
12. Kamui Kobayashi – 32
13. Vitaly Petrov – 27
14. Nico Hülkenberg – 22
15. Vitantonio Liuzzi – 21
16. Sébastien Buemi – 8
17. Pedro de la Rosa – 6
18. Nick Heidfeld – 6
19. Jaime Alguersuari – 5

CONSTRUCTORS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Red Bull-Renault – 498
2. McLaren-Mercedes – 454
3. Ferrari – 396
4. Mercedes GP – 214
5. Renault – 163
6. Williams-Cosworth – 69
7. Force India-Mercedes – 68
8. Sauber-Ferrari – 44
9. Toro Rosso-Ferrari – 13
10. Lotus-Cosworth – 0
11. Hispania-Cosworth – 0
12. Virgin-Cosworth – 0

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How things would look under the scoring system of the previous seven seasons:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 8 SCORING SYSTEM


Winner 10
Second 8
Third 6
Fourth 5
Fifth 4
Sixth 3
Seventh 2
Eighth 1

DRIVERS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Sebastian Vettel – 104
2. Fernando Alonso – 101
3. Lewis Hamilton – 100
4. Mark Webber – 97
5. Jenson Button – 87
6. Felipe Massa – 57
7. Nico Rosberg – 55
8. Robert Kubica – 52
9. Michael Schumacher – 25
10. Rubens Barrichello – 15
11. Adrian Sutil – 15
12. Kamui Kobayashi – 9
13. Vitaly Petrov – 9
14. Nico Hülkenberg – 6
15. Vitantonio Liuzzi – 5
16. Pedro de la Rosa 2
17. Sébastien Buemi - 1
18. Nick Heidfeld – 1

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Hamilton moves ahead of Webber for P3
- Barrichello and Sutil remain level on points for P10 and P11
- De la Rosa moves ahead of Buemi for P16 and scores more points than Sauber replacement Nick Heidfeld, as opposed to level-pegging
- Alguersuari would not have scored his first F1 points

CONSTRUCTORS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Red Bull-Renault – 201
2. McLaren-Mercedes – 187
3. Ferrari – 158
4. Mercedes GP – 80
5. Renault – 61
6. Williams-Cosworth – 21
7. Force India-Mercedes – 20
8. Sauber-Ferrari – 12
9. Toro Rosso-Ferrari – 1
10. Lotus-Cosworth – 0
11. Hispania Cosworth – 0
12. Virgin-Cosworth – 0

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Williams would still beat Force India to P6 by a single point
- Toro Rosso would score only a single point, equalling its lowest points haul to date (2006 – the team’s first season)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How things would look under the scoring system of 1991-2002:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 6 SCORING SYSTEM


Winner 10
Second 6
Third 4
Fourth 3
Fifth 2
Sixth 1

DRIVERS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Sebastian Vettel – 84
2. Fernando Alonso – 81
3. Mark Webber – 76
4. Lewis Hamilton – 76
5. Jenson Button – 61
6. Felipe Massa – 34
7. Nico Rosberg – 28
8. Robert Kubica – 26
9. Michael Schumacher – 11
10. Rubens Barrichello – 6
11. Adrian Sutil – 5
12. Vitaly Petrov – 3
13. Kamui Kobayashi – 1
14. Nico Hülkenberg – 1
15. Vitantonio Liuzzi – 1

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Only the top nine drivers would move into double figures
- Hamilton would draw level with Webber, although the Australian would retain P3 due to having four races wins to Hamilton’s three
- Barrichello would score more points than Sutil for P10, as opposed to level-pegging
- Petrov would move ahead of Kobayashi for P12, as the Japanese draws level with the points sums of Hülkenberg and Liuzzi
- Buemi, de la Rosa, Heidfeld and Alguersuari would all fail to score

CONSTRUCTORS’ CHAMPIONSHIP

1. Red Bull-Renault – 160
2. McLaren-Mercedes – 137
3. Ferrari – 115
4. Mercedes GP – 39
5. Renault – 29
6. Williams-Cosworth – 7
7. Force India-Mercedes – 6
8. Sauber-Ferrari – 1
9. Toro Rosso-Ferrari – 0
10. Lotus-Cosworth – 0
11. Hispania-Cosworth – 0
12. Virgin-Cosworth – 0

Notable effects in comparison with actual 2010 results:

- Williams would still beat Force India to P6 by a single point
- Sauber would score only a single point
- Toro Rosso would fail to score

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
How things would look in the top five of the Drivers' Championship under Bernie Ecclestone’s proposed medals system, which would hand out awards of gold, silver and bronze to podium finishers:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. Sebastian Vettel – 5 gold, 2 silver, 3 bronze but 3 fourth places
2. Fernando Alonso – 5 gold, 2 silver, 3 bronze and 2 fourth places
3. Mark Webber – 4 gold
4. Lewis Hamilton – 3 gold
5. Jenson Button – 2 gold



Gregory Haines

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Thursday 26 March 2015

  2. Video: Dealing with the heat at Sepang 19:14

    Video: Dealing with the heat at Sepang

    Fred Fernando, head of Ferrari medical partner Medex, talks about the challenges of racing at Sepang.

    F1
  3. Márquez sets pace in opening Qatar session 17:55

    Márquez sets pace in opening Qatar session

    Reigning double World Champion Marc Márquez set the pace as the new MotoGP season began under the lights at Losail in…

    MotoGP
  4. Ex-tester Frijns joins Blancpain Series 14:37

    Ex-tester Frijns joins Blancpain Series

    Former Formula 1 test driver Robin Frijns has switched to endurance racing for 2015 after signing a deal to race for the WRT…

    Misc
  5. Amberg joins Lazarus for GP2 campaign 14:10

    Amberg joins Lazarus for GP2 campaign

    Zoël Amberg will make his GP2 Series debut next month after penning a deal to race for Lazarus. Amberg has spent the last…

    GP2
  6. Hamilton: Red Bull equalisation call 'funny' 13:55

    Hamilton: Red Bull equalisation call 'funny'

    Lewis Hamilton says Christian Horner's call for the FIA to rein in Mercedes is "funny", considering the success his Red Bull…

    F1
  7. IndyCar season preview: Five key questions 13:21

    IndyCar season preview: Five key questions

    When the green flag drops on the streets of St. Petersburg on Sunday, it will have been almost seven months since the last…

    Indy
  8. 12:31

    Latest F1 photos: Thursday at Sepang

    F1
  9. Manor Marussia fires up car at Sepang 12:28

    Manor Marussia fires up car at Sepang

    Manor Marussia has fired up its car for the first time ahead of this weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix. The outfit made the…

    F1
  10. Sepang circuit boss wants late-season slot 11:43

    Sepang circuit boss wants late-season slot

    Malaysian Grand Prix boss Razlan Razali is hopeful that Sepang will extend its stay on the Formula 1 calendar, and has set his…

    F1
  11. Kobayashi joins Toyota's WEC effort 10:46

    Kobayashi joins Toyota's WEC effort

    Former Formula 1 driver Kamui Kobayashi has joined Toyota's World Endurance Championship squad as its official test and reserve…

    LM
  12. Rosberg: Unfair to say we're further ahead 10:41

    Rosberg: Unfair to say we're further ahead

    Nico Rosberg says it is unfair to suggest that Mercedes has increased its advantage over the rest of the Formula 1 field this…

    F1
  13. Williams signs Sutil as reserve driver 10:03

    Williams signs Sutil as reserve driver

    Williams has announced Adrian Sutil as its official reserve driver for the 2015 campaign. The German, who lost his Sauber…

    F1
  14. Bottas makes car changes to aid back 09:14

    Bottas makes car changes to aid back

    Valtteri Bottas says he has changed the seat and pedal positions in his Williams in a bid to prevent a repeat of the back issue…

    F1
  15. Alonso says steering 'locked' for testing crash 08:19

    Alonso says steering 'locked' for testing crash

    McLaren-Honda driver Fernando Alonso has gone against the team's official explanation of his testing crash, revealing that he…

    F1
  16. Alonso, Bottas declared fit to race 05:22

    Alonso, Bottas declared fit to race

    McLaren-Honda's Fernando Alonso and Williams driver Valtteri Bottas have been declared fit to compete at this weekend's…

    F1
  17. Sepang memories: Räikkönen's first win 05:14

    Sepang memories: Räikkönen's first win

    Watch as McLaren's Kimi Räikkönen claims his first Formula 1 victory at the 2003 Malaysian Grand Prix.

    F1
  18. Wednesday 25 March 2015

  19. Stewart sure Alonso will have no problems 14:45

    Stewart sure Alonso will have no problems

    Three-time Formula 1 World Champion Sir Jackie Stewart believes that Fernando Alonso will have "no trouble at all" when the…

    F1
  20. Button: Malaysia heat to test McLaren 13:08

    Button: Malaysia heat to test McLaren

    Jenson Button believes that the high temperatures expected at this weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix will test McLaren after a…

    F1
  21. 12:47

    Latest F1 photos: Preparations at Sepang

    F1
  22. Allison expecting Ferrari to close gap 10:51

    Allison expecting Ferrari to close gap

    Ferrari Technical Director James Allison is confident that the team will be closer to Mercedes at the Malaysian Grand Prix than…

    F1
  23. Renault: Not just engine restricting Red Bull 10:20

    Renault: Not just engine restricting Red Bull

    Renault Managing Director Cyril Abiteboul says it is not just the power unit which is limiting Red Bull's prospects in 2015…

    F1
  24. Factfile: The 2015 Malaysian Grand Prix 08:23

    Factfile: The 2015 Malaysian Grand Prix

    After a two week pause, the Formula 1 season continues with the Malaysian Grand Prix. Ahead of the event, which takes place at…

    F1
  25. Preview: Five key questions for Malaysia 07:12

    Preview: Five key questions for Malaysia

    Formula 1 heads from Australia to Malaysia for the second round of the season. As a preview to this weekend's Grand Prix…

    F1
  26. Sepang memories: Massa's visor drama 05:02

    Sepang memories: Massa's visor drama

    Shortly after officials red flagged the 2009 Malaysian Grand Prix, Ferrari driver Felipe Massa and Race Engineer Rob Smedley…

    F1
  27. Tuesday 24 March 2015

  28. 16:36

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  29. Video: Ricciardo drives Targa Florio 15:04

    Video: Ricciardo drives Targa Florio

    Red Bull driver Daniel Ricciardo takes a break from F1 to drive the Alfa Romeo T33 at Targa Florio.

    F1
  30. Alonso 'ready' for Malaysia comeback 12:58

    Alonso 'ready' for Malaysia comeback

    McLaren-Honda driver Fernando Alonso says he feels "ready to go" in the run up to this weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix, where he…

    F1
  31. Hamilton hopes to sign new deal this week 12:26

    Hamilton hopes to sign new deal this week

    Lewis Hamilton says he hopes to sign a new deal with Mercedes before the Malaysian Grand Prix. The reigning World Champion is…

    F1
  32. Pirelli to be bought by Chinese firm 11:50

    Pirelli to be bought by Chinese firm

    China National Chemical Corporation (ChemChina) has agreed to buy Italian tyre manufacturer Pirelli. Pirelli has acted as…

    F1
  33. Fong secures Lotus development role 08:49

    Fong secures Lotus development role

    Adderly Fong has joined the Lotus Formula 1 team as a development driver. The 25-year-old Hong Kong racer, who made his…

    F1
  34. Sepang memories: Schumacher, Montoya touch 05:04

    Sepang memories: Schumacher, Montoya touch

    Relive the dramatic start to the 2002 Malaysian Grand Prix, which saw Ferrari driver Michael Schumacher and Williams rival Juan…

    F1
  35. Monday 23 March 2015

  36. Marciello to replace Nasr in first practice 15:14

    Marciello to replace Nasr in first practice

    Sauber has confirmed that Felipe Nasr will step aside for test and reserve driver Raffaele Marciello during first practice at…

    F1
  37. McLaren: Alonso to return in Malaysia 14:24

    McLaren: Alonso to return in Malaysia

    McLaren-Honda has stated that, subject to final FIA medical checks, Fernando Alonso will return to action at this weekend's…

    F1
  38. Manor Marussia eyes 'typical race weekend' 13:11

    Manor Marussia eyes 'typical race weekend'

    Manor Marussia team boss John Booth is optimistic that the outfit will experience a "more typical race weekend" at the Malaysian…

    F1
  39. Bottas confident he will be cleared to return 12:27

    Bottas confident he will be cleared to return

    Valtteri Bottas says he has "taken the necessary measures" to ensure that he returns to action at the Malaysian Grand Prix…

    F1
  40. Video: Rosberg training in Malaysia 11:26

    Video: Rosberg training in Malaysia

    Join Nico Rosberg for a training run to the top of the Petronas Towers in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

    F1
  41. Hülkenberg braced for 'tough' run of races 10:42

    Hülkenberg braced for 'tough' run of races

    Force India driver Nico Hülkenberg says he is expecting to endure a "tough" run of races, despite the team's positive start to…

    F1
  42. Pirelli: At least two pit-stops in Malaysia 10:17

    Pirelli: At least two pit-stops in Malaysia

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli expects a return to at least two pit-stops per driver in Malaysia. Most of the drivers to…

    F1
  43. Sepang memories: Vettel versus Webber 05:22

    Sepang memories: Vettel versus Webber

    Relive the intense battle between Sebastian Vettel and Mark Webber in the closing stages of the 2013 Malaysian Grand Prix.…

    F1
  44. Sunday 22 March 2015

  45. Mercedes attempted 2015 Hockenheim deal 11:32

    Mercedes attempted 2015 Hockenheim deal

    Constructors' champions Mercedes offered to cover half of any potential losses encountered by the host of the now-abandoned 2015…

    F1
more news