Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

22 March 2012 – Force India has been demanded to pay 700,000 pounds in damages to former wind tunnel partner Aerolab. The ruling is the latest twist in the disagreement which has been running since the end of 2009.

The dispute was first known when Aerolab claimed that Force India had not submitted their necessary fees for aerodynamic services. The two parties split and Aerolab began working with Lotus Racing (now Caterham F1) just days later. Responding, Force India accused Aerolab and Lotus Chief Technical Officer Mike Gascoyne (ex Force India Technical Director) of ‘systematic copying’ of the 2009 Force India car when designing the 2010 Lotus.

Force India claimed that Caterham copied its entire 2009 design for the 2010 season, but the court has ruled that this was not the case

In August 2010, the High Court of London ordered Force India to pay Aerolab one million euros (£820,000) in unpaid fees. A date of 16 January 2012 was then set for a court hearing relating to the accusations of copyright infringement.

Aerolab has now admitted that certain employees copied computer files containing some Force India car details; as a result of this Aerolab mistake, GPUpdate.net learned that Caterham had received indennity in the case.

Force India continued to contend that its entire 2009 design was copied, on which a value was placed of 15 million pounds (reduced to 13 million pounds during the trial). Force India, which sacked Gascoyne in 2008, also stressed that Caterham F1 and Gascoyne were jointly responsible for copying the designs. However, the Honourable Mr Justice Arnold does not believe this happened.

“In my view Force India has come nowhere near establishing that (systematic copying of key parts of the Force India car, and in particular systematic copying of the aerodynamically significant parts) was the case,” the judge ruled, claiming that neither Gascoyne nor Caterham are liable for breach of confidence.

The Judge settled the dispute in Aerolab’s favour, ordering Force India to pay 850,000 euros (£706,000) for the unpaid fees. At the same time, Force India was awarded 25,000 euros (£21,000) in compensation for the accidental usage of a small amount of 2009 data, ruled to have been used as a ‘shortcut’ in the Lotus design process.

Force India stated on Wednesday night that it is now referring the matter to Formula 1 governing body the FIA, although it is believed the Silverstone-based team has already been attempting to do this for approximately two years.

A separate hearing has now been arranged to determine the legal costs Force India has incurred across the trial; it is believed they could equate to figures in the region of four million pounds. This blow comes as Kingfisher Airlines, owned by Force India Team Principal Vijay Mallya, is close to bankruptcy.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Friday 31 October 2014

  2. 23:25

    Latest Formula 1 photos: Friday in Austin

    F1
  3. Vettel sets sights on race-day recovery 23:16

    Vettel sets sights on race-day recovery

    Sebastian Vettel dedicated the opening day of practice at the Circuit of The Americas to race preparation, following...

    F1
  4. Räikkönen pleased with Friday progress 22:50

    Räikkönen pleased with Friday progress

    Kimi Räikkönen was encouraged by the progress he made between the first and second practice sessions at the Circuit of The A...

    F1
  5. Hamilton unconcerned by practice issues 22:04

    Hamilton unconcerned by practice issues

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton has played down the issues he suffered on the opening day of practice for the United States...

    F1
  6. Caterham appeals to 'credible' parties 21:43

    Caterham appeals to 'credible' parties

    Caterham's administrators say they are holding discussions with several "credible" parties with regards to the potential...

    F1
  7. Ecclestone says grid could drop to 14 cars 21:07

    Ecclestone says grid could drop to 14 cars

    Formula 1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone has warned that there could be only 14 cars on the 2015 grid as a result of the sport's...

    F1
  8. 20:41

    United States GP: Full Free Practice 2 results

    F1
  9. Hamilton stays on top in second practice 20:37

    Hamilton stays on top in second practice

    Lewis Hamilton remained at the top of the timesheets during second practice for the United States Grand Prix, although his...

    F1
  10. 18:51

    Follow FP2 for the United States GP!

    F1
  11. Horner: Vettel will take part in qualifying 17:30

    Horner: Vettel will take part in qualifying

    Red Bull team boss Christian Horner has made clear that Sebastian Vettel will partake in qualifying for the United States...

    F1
  12. 16:54

    United States GP: Full Free Practice 1 results

    F1
  13. Hamilton fastest in opening Austin practice 16:36

    Hamilton fastest in opening Austin practice

    Lewis Hamilton set the pace during Friday morning's opening free practice session for the United States Grand Prix, edging...

    F1
  14. Administrators: Caterham almost raced in Austin 16:21

    Administrators: Caterham almost raced in Austin

    The administrators attempting to save the Caterham Formula 1 team say the outfit came close to racing at this weekend's...

    F1
  15. 14:44

    Follow FP1 for the United States GP!

    F1
  16. Hernández gets 2015 Ducati support 12:11

    Hernández gets 2015 Ducati support

    Yonny Hernández will continue with Pramac Racing in 2015 after Ducati confirmed that the Colombian has taken on an enhanced...

    MotoGP
  17. FR3.5 exploring 18-inch tyres for 2016 10:43

    FR3.5 exploring 18-inch tyres for 2016

    Renault Sport has revealed that its principal junior championship – the Formula Renault 3.5 Series – is evaluating a switch t...

    FR 3.5
  18. Verstappen would prefer Vergne as team-mate 10:01

    Verstappen would prefer Vergne as team-mate

    Max Verstappen says he would like to have Jean-Éric Vergne as his team-mate when he makes his Formula 1 debut with Toro...

    F1
  19. Kaltenborn 'disturbed' by plight of F1 09:52

    Kaltenborn 'disturbed' by plight of F1

    Sauber Team Principal Monisha Kaltenborn says she is "disturbed" that Formula 1 was unable to take measures to prevent two...

    F1
  20. Video of the Day: Hamilton's Austin track guide 09:03

    Video of the Day: Hamilton's Austin track guide

    Join Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton for a virtual lap of the Circuit of The Americas.

    F1
  21. Räikkönen sure Ferrari can make 'big leap' 08:55

    Räikkönen sure Ferrari can make 'big leap'

    Kimi Räikkönen says he is sure that Ferrari will make a "big leap" forward next year after enduring a troublesome 2014 c...

    F1
  22. Thursday 30 October 2014

  23. 21:32

    Latest F1 photos: Thursday in Austin

    F1
  24. Qualifying revised due to smaller field 21:31

    Qualifying revised due to smaller field

    Formula 1 will adopt a revised qualifying format for this weekend's United States Grand Prix, due to the absence of the...

    F1
  25. Alonso excited by 'very ambitious' plan 19:44

    Alonso excited by 'very ambitious' plan

    Fernando Alonso chose to remain coy over his future during the build up to the United States Grand Prix, explaining only...

    F1
  26. Button to take five-place gearbox penalty 17:58

    Button to take five-place gearbox penalty

    Jenson Button will take a gearbox penalty at this weekend's United States Grand Prix. Under Formula 1's current...

    F1
  27. Vergne says he is 'best option' for Toro Rosso 17:45

    Vergne says he is 'best option' for Toro Rosso

    Jean-Éric Vergne reckons he is the "best option" out of the drivers vying to race alongside Max Verstappen at Toro Rosso...

    F1
  28. Drivers open to three-car F1 teams 17:12

    Drivers open to three-car F1 teams

    Formula 1 drivers say they are open to being a part of three-car teams, as the debate over grid size continues. With...

    F1
  29. Domenicali to start work at Audi this week 15:28

    Domenicali to start work at Audi this week

    Stefano Domenicali will begin work at Audi on November 1, the German manufacturer has confirmed to...

    Misc
  30. IndyCar announces 2015 calendar 14:51

    IndyCar announces 2015 calendar

    IndyCar officials presented a 17-race calendar for the 2015 season on Thursday. As previously confirmed, the campaign...

    Indy
  31. Family: Bianchi remains critical but stable 14:23

    Family: Bianchi remains critical but stable

    Jules Bianchi remains in a critical but stable condition at the Mie General Medical Center in Yokkaichi following his...

    F1
  32. Vettel: Red Bull blocked early release 13:32

    Vettel: Red Bull blocked early release

    Quadruple World Champion Sebastian Vettel has confirmed that Red Bull has prevented him from exiting his contract early...

    F1
  33. Video: Haas F1 factory build time-lapse 11:14

    Video: Haas F1 factory build time-lapse

    Relive the 339-day construction of Haas F1 Team's new facility in Kannapolis in this time-lapse video.

    F1
  34. 10:32

    MotoGP photos: Stoner in action at Motegi

    MotoGP
  35. Stoner describes 'very positive' Motegi test 10:31

    Stoner describes 'very positive' Motegi test

    Casey Stoner has described his two-day test with Honda's 2015 bike at Motegi as "very positive". The two-time MotoGP...

    MotoGP
  36. 09:56

    F1 photos: Ocon tests F10 at Fiorano

    F1
  37. Ferrari praises Ocon after F1 test 09:51

    Ferrari praises Ocon after F1 test

    Ferrari has heaped praise on Esteban Ocon after the French teenager's prize Formula 1 test at Fiorano on Wednesday. Ocon,...

    F1
  38. Warwick confirmed as Austin steward 08:59

    Warwick confirmed as Austin steward

    Derek Warwick has been confirmed as the FIA's driver representative steward for this weekend's United States Grand...

    F1
  39. USGP memories: Hamilton wins, 2012 05:02

    USGP memories: Hamilton wins, 2012

    Relive the inaugural USGP at the Circuit of The Americas, where Lewis Hamilton overcame Sebastian Vettel.

    F1
  40. Wednesday 29 October 2014

  41. Hawksworth joins Sato at Foyt for 2015 20:02

    Hawksworth joins Sato at Foyt for 2015

    British driver Jack Hawksworth will join Takuma Sato at AJ Foyt Racing in IndyCar next season as the squad expands to a...

    Indy
  42. Vettel set to sit out qualifying for USGP 18:00

    Vettel set to sit out qualifying for USGP

    Sebastian Vettel says he will probably sit out qualifying for the United States Grand Prix as Red Bull is likely to make a...

    F1
  43. Mercedes awarded the Dewar Trophy 14:18

    Mercedes awarded the Dewar Trophy

    Mercedes has been awarded the Dewar Trophy for producing the best power unit under Formula 1's new technical...

    F1
more news