Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

22 March 2012 – Force India has been demanded to pay 700,000 pounds in damages to former wind tunnel partner Aerolab. The ruling is the latest twist in the disagreement which has been running since the end of 2009.

The dispute was first known when Aerolab claimed that Force India had not submitted their necessary fees for aerodynamic services. The two parties split and Aerolab began working with Lotus Racing (now Caterham F1) just days later. Responding, Force India accused Aerolab and Lotus Chief Technical Officer Mike Gascoyne (ex Force India Technical Director) of ‘systematic copying’ of the 2009 Force India car when designing the 2010 Lotus.

Force India claimed that Caterham copied its entire 2009 design for the 2010 season, but the court has ruled that this was not the case
In August 2010, the High Court of London ordered Force India to pay Aerolab one million euros (£820,000) in unpaid fees. A date of 16 January 2012 was then set for a court hearing relating to the accusations of copyright infringement.

Aerolab has now admitted that certain employees copied computer files containing some Force India car details; as a result of this Aerolab mistake, GPUpdate.net learned that Caterham had received indennity in the case.

Force India continued to contend that its entire 2009 design was copied, on which a value was placed of 15 million pounds (reduced to 13 million pounds during the trial). Force India, which sacked Gascoyne in 2008, also stressed that Caterham F1 and Gascoyne were jointly responsible for copying the designs. However, the Honourable Mr Justice Arnold does not believe this happened.

“In my view Force India has come nowhere near establishing that (systematic copying of key parts of the Force India car, and in particular systematic copying of the aerodynamically significant parts) was the case,” the judge ruled, claiming that neither Gascoyne nor Caterham are liable for breach of confidence.

The Judge settled the dispute in Aerolab’s favour, ordering Force India to pay 850,000 euros (£706,000) for the unpaid fees. At the same time, Force India was awarded 25,000 euros (£21,000) in compensation for the accidental usage of a small amount of 2009 data, ruled to have been used as a ‘shortcut’ in the Lotus design process.

Force India stated on Wednesday night that it is now referring the matter to Formula 1 governing body the FIA, although it is believed the Silverstone-based team has already been attempting to do this for approximately two years.

A separate hearing has now been arranged to determine the legal costs Force India has incurred across the trial; it is believed they could equate to figures in the region of four million pounds. This blow comes as Kingfisher Airlines, owned by Force India Team Principal Vijay Mallya, is close to bankruptcy.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Tuesday 28 July 2015

  2. Video of the Day: Haas on Formula 1 entry 05:34

    Video of the Day: Haas on Formula 1 entry

    Haas F1 owner, Gene Haas, discusses how his team is progressing ahead of its planned 2016 entry.

    F1
  3. Monday 27 July 2015

  4. 16:37

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  5. Arrivabene pleased to prove critics wrong 15:03

    Arrivabene pleased to prove critics wrong

    Ferrari team boss Maurizio Arrivabene says he was pleased to prove doubters wrong as Sebastian Vettel claimed the marque's…

    F1
  6. Wolff: Rushed stop cost Rosberg victory 14:21

    Wolff: Rushed stop cost Rosberg victory

    Mercedes boss Toto Wolff reckons rushing Nico Rosberg's pit-stop under the Virtual Safety Car and putting on the slower tyre…

    F1
  7. Hungarian Grand Prix: Winners and Losers 14:12

    Hungarian Grand Prix: Winners and Losers

    Sebastian Vettel returned Ferrari to the top step, others pulled off surprise results, and some struggled at the Hungarian Grand…

    F1
  8. Teams back Pirelli extension for 2017 12:46

    Teams back Pirelli extension for 2017

    Senior figures from Formula 1 teams have backed the notion of Pirelli extending its tenure as Formula 1's sole tyre supplier for…

    F1
  9. Video: Rosberg's Hungaroring blog 11:32

    Video: Rosberg's Hungaroring blog

    Nico Rosberg reflects on his eighth-place finish at the end of a dramatic Hungarian Grand Prix; the German was running second…

    F1
  10. Maldonado says stewards were 'very strict' 11:22

    Maldonado says stewards were 'very strict'

    Pastor Maldonado believes that the Hungarian Grand Prix stewards were "very strict" as the Lotus driver picked up a number of…

    F1
  11. Forward Racing to miss Indianapolis round 10:49

    Forward Racing to miss Indianapolis round

    Forward Racing has announced that it has taken the "painful decision" to pull out of the upcoming MotoGP round at Indianapolis…

    MotoGP
  12. Renault enjoys return to the sharp end 10:02

    Renault enjoys return to the sharp end

    Renault hailed another step forward as supplied teams Red Bull and Toro Rosso occupied three of the top four positions at the…

    F1
  13. Massa rues pointless Hungary weekend 09:17

    Massa rues pointless Hungary weekend

    Felipe Massa has described Williams' second non-scoring weekend of the 2015 season as "a blow" to the team's championship…

    F1
  14. Hamilton among drivers given penalty points 08:14

    Hamilton among drivers given penalty points

    Lewis Hamilton was among the drivers handed penalty points by the stewards as a result of incidents which took place during…

    F1
  15. Video of the Day: Meet the Nasr family 05:02

    Video of the Day: Meet the Nasr family

    Sauber Formula 1 driver Felipe Nasr introduces his family, which is half Brazilian, half Lebanese.

    F1
  16. 01:12

    Championship standings after Hungary

    F1
  17. Sunday 26 July 2015

  18. 21:15

    Latest F1 photos: Sunday at the Hungaroring

    F1
  19. Booth proud of Manor after tough week 21:14

    Booth proud of Manor after tough week

    John Booth paid tribute to his Manor Marussia squad at the end of a "tough week" for the team, following the death of Jules…

    F1
  20. Räikkönen frustrated to miss out on 1-2 19:02

    Räikkönen frustrated to miss out on 1-2

    Kimi Räikkönen expressed his frustration after Ferrari missed out on a "very easy" 1-2 finish in Sunday's Hungarian Grand…

    F1
  21. Verstappen hails 'unbelievable' result 18:50

    Verstappen hails 'unbelievable' result

    Max Verstappen was initially lost for words after achieving the best result of his Formula 1 career to date at the Hungarian…

    F1
  22. Alonso: Fifth place 'a nice little present' 18:31

    Alonso: Fifth place 'a nice little present'

    Fernando Alonso has described his top five finish at the Hungarian Grand Prix as "a nice little present" for the McLaren-Honda…

    F1
  23. Rosberg says Ricciardo at fault for clash 18:12

    Rosberg says Ricciardo at fault for clash

    Nico Rosberg feels that Daniel Ricciardo was at fault for their collision in the closing stages of Sunday's Hungarian Grand…

    F1
  24. Ricciardo: Podium feels like a victory 17:47

    Ricciardo: Podium feels like a victory

    Daniel Ricciardo says his podium finish at the Hungarian Grand Prix "felt like a victory" after Red Bull's trying start to the…

    F1
  25. Marchionne: Ferrari victory is for Bianchi 17:24

    Marchionne: Ferrari victory is for Bianchi

    Ferrari President Sergio Marchionne has dedicated the squad's victory in the Hungarian Grand Prix to the late Jules…

    F1
  26. Kvyat rewarded after 'never giving up' 16:59

    Kvyat rewarded after 'never giving up'

    Red Bull driver Daniil Kvyat spoke of a "never give up" attitude after recording his maiden podium finish at the Hungarian Grand…

    F1
  27. Hülkenberg had little warning over failure 16:49

    Hülkenberg had little warning over failure

    Nico Hülkenberg said he had little prior warning over the failure of his front wing as he suffered a dramatic exit at the…

    F1
  28. Hamilton laments 'really bad performance' 16:42

    Hamilton laments 'really bad performance'

    World Champion Lewis Hamilton said he put in one of his worst performances in recent years as he slumped to sixth at the…

    F1
  29. Vettel dedicates victory to Bianchi 16:13

    Vettel dedicates victory to Bianchi

    Ferrari's Sebastian Vettel has dedicated his victory at the Hungarian Grand Prix to the late Jules Bianchi, who passed away last…

    F1
  30. 15:07

    In full: Hungarian Grand Prix race result

    F1
  31. Vettel wins dramatic Hungarian Grand Prix 15:05

    Vettel wins dramatic Hungarian Grand Prix

    Ferrari realised its two-win target for 2015 as Sebastian Vettel triumphed in a dramatic Hungarian Grand Prix, with Red Bull's…

    F1
  32. Formula 1 holds minute's silence for Bianchi 12:46

    Formula 1 holds minute's silence for Bianchi

    Formula 1 collectively paid tribute to the late Jules Bianchi by holding a minute's silence ahead of Sunday afternoon's…

    F1
  33. Eriksson penalty hands podium to Parry 12:40

    Eriksson penalty hands podium to Parry

    Jimmy Eriksson has been handed a time penalty for cutting a corner in the second GP3 race, handing his third place finish to…

    GP3
  34. 12:01

    Starting grid for the Hungarian Grand Prix

    F1
  35. 10:30

    Latest GP2 photos: Sunday at Hungaroring

    GP2
  36. Matsushita takes maiden win in ART 1-2 10:28

    Matsushita takes maiden win in ART 1-2

    Nobuharu Matsushita dominated the GP2 Sprint Race at the Hungaroring to take his first win in the category, leading home ART…

    GP2
  37. Grosjean boosted by 'miracle' qualifying 09:22

    Grosjean boosted by 'miracle' qualifying

    Lotus driver Romain Grosjean is looking to return to the points after securing what he described as a "miracle" top 10 starting…

    F1
  38. 09:04

    Latest GP3 photos: Sunday at Hungaroring

    GP3
  39. Ceccon cruises to second GP3 win 09:01

    Ceccon cruises to second GP3 win

    Arden driver Kevin Ceccon secured his second successive Sunday win after controlling proceedings in race two at the…

    GP3
  40. Williams duo aim to repeat strong starts 07:12

    Williams duo aim to repeat strong starts

    Williams duo Valtteri Bottas and Felipe Massa have set their sights on repeating the starts they made at the British Grand Prix…

    F1
  41. Video of the Day: Max vs Carlos - Paper planes 05:24

    Video of the Day: Max vs Carlos - Paper planes

    Toro Rosso duo Max Verstappen and Carlos Sainz Jr. go head-to-head as they make and fly paper planes.

    F1
  42. Saturday 25 July 2015

  43. 21:46

    Latest F1 photos: Saturday at Hungaroring

    F1
  44. Verstappen 'achieved maximum' with ninth 21:32

    Verstappen 'achieved maximum' with ninth

    Toro Rosso rookie Max Verstappen says he achieved the maximum result possible with ninth position in Hungarian Grand Prix…

    F1
more news