Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

22 March 2012 – Force India has been demanded to pay 700,000 pounds in damages to former wind tunnel partner Aerolab. The ruling is the latest twist in the disagreement which has been running since the end of 2009.

The dispute was first known when Aerolab claimed that Force India had not submitted their necessary fees for aerodynamic services. The two parties split and Aerolab began working with Lotus Racing (now Caterham F1) just days later. Responding, Force India accused Aerolab and Lotus Chief Technical Officer Mike Gascoyne (ex Force India Technical Director) of ‘systematic copying’ of the 2009 Force India car when designing the 2010 Lotus.

Force India claimed that Caterham copied its entire 2009 design for the 2010 season, but the court has ruled that this was not the case

In August 2010, the High Court of London ordered Force India to pay Aerolab one million euros (£820,000) in unpaid fees. A date of 16 January 2012 was then set for a court hearing relating to the accusations of copyright infringement.

Aerolab has now admitted that certain employees copied computer files containing some Force India car details; as a result of this Aerolab mistake, GPUpdate.net learned that Caterham had received indennity in the case.

Force India continued to contend that its entire 2009 design was copied, on which a value was placed of 15 million pounds (reduced to 13 million pounds during the trial). Force India, which sacked Gascoyne in 2008, also stressed that Caterham F1 and Gascoyne were jointly responsible for copying the designs. However, the Honourable Mr Justice Arnold does not believe this happened.

“In my view Force India has come nowhere near establishing that (systematic copying of key parts of the Force India car, and in particular systematic copying of the aerodynamically significant parts) was the case,” the judge ruled, claiming that neither Gascoyne nor Caterham are liable for breach of confidence.

The Judge settled the dispute in Aerolab’s favour, ordering Force India to pay 850,000 euros (£706,000) for the unpaid fees. At the same time, Force India was awarded 25,000 euros (£21,000) in compensation for the accidental usage of a small amount of 2009 data, ruled to have been used as a ‘shortcut’ in the Lotus design process.

Force India stated on Wednesday night that it is now referring the matter to Formula 1 governing body the FIA, although it is believed the Silverstone-based team has already been attempting to do this for approximately two years.

A separate hearing has now been arranged to determine the legal costs Force India has incurred across the trial; it is believed they could equate to figures in the region of four million pounds. This blow comes as Kingfisher Airlines, owned by Force India Team Principal Vijay Mallya, is close to bankruptcy.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Sunday 21 September 2014

  2. Video of the Day: Formula 1's Safety Car 05:03

    Video of the Day: Formula 1's Safety Car

    There has never been a Singapore Grand Prix without the appearance of Formula 1's Safety Car. Ahead of the night race,...

    F1
  3. Grosjean hits out at Renault problems 05:00

    Grosjean hits out at Renault problems

    Romain Grosjean has hit out at continual Renault problems, which he says is having a negative impact on the morale of his...

    F1
  4. Pérez sure of Force India race recovery 01:00

    Pérez sure of Force India race recovery

    Force India driver Sergio Pérez says he is sure that he can recover from a lowly grid spot and notch up a top 10 finish in...

    F1
  5. Saturday 20 September 2014

  6. Massa encouraged by Williams improvements 18:32

    Massa encouraged by Williams improvements

    Felipe Massa says he is encouraged by the progress which Williams has made since Friday's practice sessions after qualifying...

    F1
  7. 17:25

    Latest F1 photos: Saturday in Singapore

    F1
  8. Magnussen seeks help from Safety Car 17:24

    Magnussen seeks help from Safety Car

    Kevin Magnussen says he is hoping to see the Safety Car called into action during Sunday evening's Singapore Grand...

    F1
  9. Alonso hopeful of fighting for victory 17:09

    Alonso hopeful of fighting for victory

    Ferrari driver Fernando Alonso is hopeful that he will be able to challenge for victory during Sunday's Singapore Grand...

    F1
  10. Vettel reckons pole position was possible 16:42

    Vettel reckons pole position was possible

    Sebastian Vettel feels he could have had a shot at claiming pole position in Singapore with a cleaner final qualifying...

    F1
  11. Rosberg ruing late change of brakes 16:16

    Rosberg ruing late change of brakes

    Nico Rosberg was left to rue a change of brakes after Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton beat him to pole position in...

    F1
  12. Hamilton pleased to recover from early error 15:57

    Hamilton pleased to recover from early error

    Lewis Hamilton says he was pleased with his recovery after an early error threatened to ruin his final qualifying attempt in...

    F1
  13. 15:08

    Singapore GP: Qualifying results in full

    F1
  14. Hamilton pips Rosberg to Singapore pole 15:07

    Hamilton pips Rosberg to Singapore pole

    Lewis Hamilton beat Mercedes team-mate Nico Rosberg to pole position during a tight qualifying session in Singapore, with...

    F1
  15. 13:52

    Follow qualifying for the Singapore GP!

    F1
  16. 12:16

    Singapore GP: Full Free Practice 3 results

    F1
  17. Alonso back on top in final Singapore practice 12:03

    Alonso back on top in final Singapore practice

    Fernando Alonso returned to the head of the field during final practice for the Singapore Grand Prix, putting his Ferrari...

    F1
  18. 10:55

    Follow final practice for the Singapore GP!

    F1
  19. Full radio ban delayed to ensure 'fairness' 10:31

    Full radio ban delayed to ensure 'fairness'

    The FIA backtracked on its plans to introduce a full radio clampdown in Singapore to ensure "fairness". After announcing...

    F1
  20. Video: Maldonado crashes out of practice 09:56

    Video: Maldonado crashes out of practice

    Lotus driver Pastor Maldonado suffered this heavy crash during Friday evening's second practice session in Singapore. The...

    F1
  21. Maldonado gets new chassis after crash 09:49

    Maldonado gets new chassis after crash

    Pastor Maldonado has been forced to switch to a new chassis for the remainder of the Singapore Grand Prix weekend, after...

    F1
  22. 07:06

    Photos: Historic F1 action in Singapore

    F1
  23. Ravetto: Caterham already working on 2015 06:01

    Ravetto: Caterham already working on 2015

    Newly-appointed Caterham Team Principal Manfredi Ravetto insists that there are long-term plans in place at the outfit,...

    F1
  24. Video of the Day: Wind tunnel guide - Part 8 05:00

    Video of the Day: Wind tunnel guide - Part 8

    Sauber's Head of Aerodynamics, Willem Toet, concludes his talk on the science of F1 wind tunnel design.

    F1
  25. Friday 19 September 2014

  26. Ferrari reasonably competitive, says Alonso 19:49

    Ferrari reasonably competitive, says Alonso

    Fernando Alonso reckons that Ferrari put in a "reasonably competitive" performance during Friday's free practice sessions...

    F1
  27. Button sure of 'decent opportunity' for McLaren 18:39

    Button sure of 'decent opportunity' for McLaren

    Jenson Button believes that this weekend's Singapore Grand Prix presents a "decent opportunity" for McLaren as the team bids...

    F1
  28. Pirelli admits tyre gap bigger than expected 18:17

    Pirelli admits tyre gap bigger than expected

    F1 tyre supplier Pirelli admits that the time difference between its supplied compounds in Singapore has been larger than it...

    F1
  29. Vettel praises mechanics for 'massive job' 18:02

    Vettel praises mechanics for 'massive job'

    Red Bull driver Sebastian Vettel has praised his mechanics for the work they completed between practice sessions in...

    F1
  30. Rosberg positive despite ruined attempt 17:37

    Rosberg positive despite ruined attempt

    Nico Rosberg was in a positive frame of mind after the opening day of practice for the Singapore Grand Prix, despite failing...

    F1
  31. Hamilton still not happy with car balance 17:15

    Hamilton still not happy with car balance

    Lewis Hamilton says he is still not comfortable with the handling of his car, despite topping Friday's combined timesheets...

    F1
  32. 16:48

    Latest F1 photos: Friday in Singapore

    F1
  33. Verstappen could get Suzuka practice outing 16:44

    Verstappen could get Suzuka practice outing

    Max Verstappen could take part in his first official Formula 1 session at the Japanese Grand Prix. The 16-year-old Dutch...

    F1
  34. 16:13

    Singapore GP: Full Free Practice 2 results

    F1
  35. Hamilton moves ahead in second practice 16:03

    Hamilton moves ahead in second practice

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton moved to the top of the times during Friday's second practice session for the Singapore Grand...

    F1
  36. 14:16

    Follow second practice for the Singapore GP!

    F1
  37. Ferrari paying tribute to Botín in Singapore 13:46

    Ferrari paying tribute to Botín in Singapore

    Ferrari is paying tribute to Emilio Botín in Singapore, following the death of the Santander Chairman. Botín, who passed a...

    F1
  38. Ecclestone wants third cars from 2015 13:22

    Ecclestone wants third cars from 2015

    Formula 1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone feels the sport should adopt three-car teams for 2015. With certain teams struggling...

    F1
  39. 12:50

    Singapore GP: Full Free Practice 1 results

    F1
  40. Alonso edges Mercedes duo in first practice 12:32

    Alonso edges Mercedes duo in first practice

    Ferrari driver Fernando Alonso set the pace during Friday evening's first free practice session for the Singapore Grand...

    F1
  41. 10:46

    Follow first practice for the Singapore GP!

    F1
  42. Radio ban revised to driver performance only 08:44

    Radio ban revised to driver performance only

    Formula 1's governing body, the FIA, has revised its proposed clampdown on pit-to-car radio and pit board messages after...

    F1
  43. Video of the Day: Hamilton's Singapore guide 05:06

    Video of the Day: Hamilton's Singapore guide

    Join Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton for a lap of the Marina Bay Street Circuit.

    F1
more news