Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

Court demands Force India payment to Aerolab

22 March 2012 – Force India has been demanded to pay 700,000 pounds in damages to former wind tunnel partner Aerolab. The ruling is the latest twist in the disagreement which has been running since the end of 2009.

The dispute was first known when Aerolab claimed that Force India had not submitted their necessary fees for aerodynamic services. The two parties split and Aerolab began working with Lotus Racing (now Caterham F1) just days later. Responding, Force India accused Aerolab and Lotus Chief Technical Officer Mike Gascoyne (ex Force India Technical Director) of ‘systematic copying’ of the 2009 Force India car when designing the 2010 Lotus.

Force India claimed that Caterham copied its entire 2009 design for the 2010 season, but the court has ruled that this was not the case

In August 2010, the High Court of London ordered Force India to pay Aerolab one million euros (£820,000) in unpaid fees. A date of 16 January 2012 was then set for a court hearing relating to the accusations of copyright infringement.

Aerolab has now admitted that certain employees copied computer files containing some Force India car details; as a result of this Aerolab mistake, GPUpdate.net learned that Caterham had received indennity in the case.

Force India continued to contend that its entire 2009 design was copied, on which a value was placed of 15 million pounds (reduced to 13 million pounds during the trial). Force India, which sacked Gascoyne in 2008, also stressed that Caterham F1 and Gascoyne were jointly responsible for copying the designs. However, the Honourable Mr Justice Arnold does not believe this happened.

“In my view Force India has come nowhere near establishing that (systematic copying of key parts of the Force India car, and in particular systematic copying of the aerodynamically significant parts) was the case,” the judge ruled, claiming that neither Gascoyne nor Caterham are liable for breach of confidence.

The Judge settled the dispute in Aerolab’s favour, ordering Force India to pay 850,000 euros (£706,000) for the unpaid fees. At the same time, Force India was awarded 25,000 euros (£21,000) in compensation for the accidental usage of a small amount of 2009 data, ruled to have been used as a ‘shortcut’ in the Lotus design process.

Force India stated on Wednesday night that it is now referring the matter to Formula 1 governing body the FIA, although it is believed the Silverstone-based team has already been attempting to do this for approximately two years.

A separate hearing has now been arranged to determine the legal costs Force India has incurred across the trial; it is believed they could equate to figures in the region of four million pounds. This blow comes as Kingfisher Airlines, owned by Force India Team Principal Vijay Mallya, is close to bankruptcy.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Monday 21 April 2014

  2. Angry Räikkönen hits out at motivation questions 09:00

    Angry Räikkönen hits out at motivation questions

    An angry Kimi Räikkönen hit out at questions over his motivation after he finished in eighth place during Sunday's Chinese G...

    F1
  3. Winners and Losers at the Chinese Grand Prix 07:00

    Winners and Losers at the Chinese Grand Prix

    The Chinese Grand Prix was another race controlled by Mercedes's Lewis Hamilton, the Briton taking maximum points ahead of...

    F1
  4. Video of the Day: Mercedes celebrates 1-2 05:00

    Video of the Day: Mercedes celebrates 1-2

    Mercedes chiefs celebrate their third 1-2 finish of the 2014 season at the Chinese Grand Prix.

    F1
  5. 03:00

    Championship standings after China

    F1
  6. Sunday 20 April 2014

  7. Hülkenberg hails 'very positive' team result 12:19

    Hülkenberg hails 'very positive' team result

    Nico Hülkenberg described as "very positive" Force India's double points finish in the Chinese Grand Prix, its third of the...

    F1
  8. Ricciardo: I really want that podium! 12:04

    Ricciardo: I really want that podium!

    Daniel Ricciardo joked that he 'really wants' to finish on the podium after second successive fourth place at the Chinese...

    F1
  9. 12:00

    Latest F1 photos: Sunday at Shanghai

    F1
  10. Third successive retirement for Sutil 11:57

    Third successive retirement for Sutil

    Adrian Sutil and Sauber's difficult start to 2014 continued as the German driver was unable to finish in China following an...

    F1
  11. Massa left frustrated by pit stop problem 11:50

    Massa left frustrated by pit stop problem

    Felipe Massa's chance of a good result at the Chinese Grand Prix disappeared after a calamatous pit stop dropped him down...

    F1
  12. Button says McLaren 'not good enough' 11:32

    Button says McLaren 'not good enough'

    Jenson Button has admitted that his McLaren team's performance level is simply "not good enough" after a lacklustre Chinese...

    F1
  13. Gearbox problem prevents first Lotus points 11:27

    Gearbox problem prevents first Lotus points

    Romain Grosjean was left frustrated after a gearbox problem with his Lotus E22 forced him into retirement at the Chinese...

    F1
  14. Kvyat 'very happy' with third points finish 11:16

    Kvyat 'very happy' with third points finish

    Daniil Kvyat was understandably elated after picking up his third points finish from four races during Sunday's Chinese...

    F1
  15. Video: Vettel's "tough luck" radio message 11:08

    Video: Vettel's "tough luck" radio message

    Sebastian Vettel was asked to let Red Bull team-mate Daniel Ricciardo through during Sunday's Chinese Grand Prix. When he...

    F1
  16. Shanghai result modified after flag error 10:58

    Shanghai result modified after flag error

    The Chinese Grand Prix has been cut short by two laps after the chequered flag was waved at Lewis Hamilton earlier than...

    F1
  17. We're still in the fight, Alonso insists 10:40

    We're still in the fight, Alonso insists

    Fernando Alonso says he and Ferrari are "still in the fight" for title glory this season after finishing third in the...

    F1
  18. Rosberg looks forward to 'normal weekend' 10:25

    Rosberg looks forward to 'normal weekend'

    Nico Rosberg says he is looking forward to a "normal" Spanish Grand Prix, after enduring an incident-packed weekend in...

    F1
  19. Hamilton amazed by Mercedes challenger 10:12

    Hamilton amazed by Mercedes challenger

    Lewis Hamilton says he is "amazed" by the performance of Mercedes's 2014 challenger after notching up the first victory...

    F1
  20. 09:45

    In full: Chinese Grand Prix race result

    F1
  21. Hamilton dominates for third successive win 09:44

    Hamilton dominates for third successive win

    Lewis Hamilton delivered a crushing performance during Sunday afternoon's Chinese Grand Prix to claim three successive race...

    F1
  22. 07:58

    Follow the 2014 Chinese Grand Prix live!

    F1
  23. Talks over custom exhaust to improve sound 07:52

    Talks over custom exhaust to improve sound

    The FIA and F1's engine manufacturers have suggested looking at custom exhausts to improve the sound of the sport's new...

    F1
  24. Video of the Day: Hamilton's China pole lap 05:00

    Video of the Day: Hamilton's China pole lap

    Enjoy onboard footage of Lewis Hamilton's pole position lap for the Chinese Grand Prix.

    F1
  25. Saturday 19 April 2014

  26. Inconsistent handling affecting speed – Räikkönen 14:00

    Inconsistent handling affecting speed – Räikkönen

    Ferrari driver Kimi Räikkönen says that the inconsistent handling of the F14T affected his performance during qualifying for...

    F1
  27. Hülkenberg happy after securing Q3 slot 12:00

    Hülkenberg happy after securing Q3 slot

    Nico Hülkenberg says he is happy to be starting the Chinese Grand Prix from within the top ten despite struggling with the...

    F1
  28. Ricciardo: I got everything out of the car 10:49

    Ricciardo: I got everything out of the car

    Daniel Ricciardo says that he extracted the maximum from his Red Bull RB10 during a wet qualifying for the Chinese Grand...

    F1
  29. Rosberg confident despite struggling with brakes 09:47

    Rosberg confident despite struggling with brakes

    Nico Rosberg says he remains confident of collecting a strong result at the Chinese Grand Prix despite suffering from a few...

    F1
  30. Grosjean hoped for even higher grid slot 09:43

    Grosjean hoped for even higher grid slot

    Romain Grosjean says he had hoped for even more than his 10th place result in Saturday's qualifying session for the Chinese...

    F1
  31. Bottas pleased with wet weather progress 09:37

    Bottas pleased with wet weather progress

    Valtteri Bottas says Williams has made clear progress in terms of wet weather performance after a double Q3 showing at the...

    F1
  32. Vergne aiming for points after strong qualifying 09:32

    Vergne aiming for points after strong qualifying

    Toro Rosso driver Jean-Éric Vergne says a top ten finish is his target after progressing through to Q3 during qualifying for...

    F1
  33. McLaren duo downbeat about car performance 09:27

    McLaren duo downbeat about car performance

    McLaren duo Jenson Button and Kevin Magnussen cut downbeat figures after a disappointing qualifying session for the team in...

    F1
  34. Vettel: Ricciardo beating me fair and square 09:22

    Vettel: Ricciardo beating me fair and square

    Sebastian Vettel admits that new Red Bull team-mate Daniel Ricciardo is beating him "fair and square" so far this...

    F1
  35. Hamilton relieved to overcome 'tough' session 09:03

    Hamilton relieved to overcome 'tough' session

    Lewis Hamilton hinted at a feeling of relief after coming out on top in Saturday's rain-affected qualifying session at the...

    F1
  36. Optimistic Alonso eyes Red Bull drivers 08:51

    Optimistic Alonso eyes Red Bull drivers

    Fernando Alonso says he is hoping to be in a position to take the fight to the Red Bull drivers during the Chinese Grand...

    F1
  37. 08:09

    Chinese Grand Prix: Full qualifying results

    F1
  38. Hamilton sets British record with China pole 08:06

    Hamilton sets British record with China pole

    Lewis Hamilton surpassed Jim Clark's British pole position record by topping Saturday's wet qualifying session for the...

    F1
  39. 06:47

    Follow qualifying for the Chinese GP!

    F1
  40. 05:04

    Chinese GP: Full Free Practice 3 results

    F1
  41. Ricciardo quickest in rain-hit final practice 05:03

    Ricciardo quickest in rain-hit final practice

    Daniel Ricciardo set the pace during Saturday morning's rain-affected final practice session for the Chinese Grand Prix. The...

    F1
  42. 04:35

    Latest F1 photos: Saturday at Shanghai

    F1
  43. 03:52

    Follow final practice for the Chinese GP!

    F1