Red Bull floor declared illegal by FIA

Red Bull floor declared illegal by FIA

2 June 2012 – Formula 1 governing body the FIA has brought an end to the controversy surrounding Red Bull's floor design, forcing the current World Champions to remove the holes that sit in front of the RB8's rear wheels ahead of the Canadian Grand Prix.

Ferrari and McLaren were amongst a number of teams to voice their concerns over the interpretation in Monaco, later threatening to protest. However, despite Mark Webber's victory, nothing was lodged by rival squads and the result stood.

Webber's eighth career victory will stand, as rival teams failed to pursue a protest
The FIA has since reassessed the situation and declared the holes as a breach of the regulations. This was outlined in the pre-Canada technical directive, issued to all teams prior to the race.

"Following on from a number of discussions in Monaco, during which it became clear that certain misunderstandings existed, we feel it would be helpful to make our position clear with respect to the presence of a fully enclosed hole in any surface lying on the step plane," the technical directive (codenamed TD/013-12) explains.

"It has been argued that, as it is not explicitly stated that fully enclosed holes cannot be located in a surface lying on the step plane rearward of a line 450mm forward of the rear face of the cockpit template, then they may be located in such areas. We disagree with this view and consider it implicit that fully enclosed holes may not be located there.

"If they were permitted the opening part of the second paragraph of Article 3.12.5 (which was added to the regulations at the same time as Articles 3.12.9 and 3.12.10 for 2011) would be superfluous.

"Furthermore, locating a fully enclosed hole partly or wholly within the 50mm band which is exempt from the requirements of Article 3.12.10 along the outer edges of the surfaces lying on the step plane does not exempt it from the requirements of Article 3.12.5, those parts lying outboard of Y650 are still parts of the surfaces lying on the step plane."

As Webber's Monaco victory was not protested, his and the team's previous 2012 results will remain in place, but the outfit must make prompt changes to its floor.

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Thursday 25 May 2017

  2. 18:28

    Follow GPUpdate on Instagram in 2017!

    F1
  3. 18:26

    Latest F1 photos: Thursday in Monaco

    F1
  4. Button 'had a little giggle' on F1 return 18:22

    Button 'had a little giggle' on F1 return

    Jenson Button says he "had a little giggle to myself" when he returned to Formula 1 action during practice for the Monaco Grand…

    F1
  5. Bourdais eyes return before end of season 18:07

    Bourdais eyes return before end of season

    Dale Coyne driver Sébastien Bourdais is hopeful he can return to the cockpit before the end of the season, after being…

    Indy
  6. 'STR must not get overexcited' - Kvyat 17:57

    'STR must not get overexcited' - Kvyat

    Daniil Kvyat says Toro Rosso must not get overexcited with its position towards the front of the Formula 1 pack during Thursday…

    F1
  7. Stroll's struggles same as on Playstation 17:18

    Stroll's struggles same as on Playstation

    Williams rookie Lance Stroll says he is struggling with the same sections of the Circuit de Monaco in real life as he does while…

    F1
  8. McLaren confirms it will stick with Honda 16:40

    McLaren confirms it will stick with Honda

    McLaren has made clear that its partnership with Honda will continue through the 2018 season, ending speculation of a switch to…

    F1
  9. Leclerc extends title lead with home pole 16:04

    Leclerc extends title lead with home pole

    Ferrari protégé Charles Leclerc claimed pole position for his home event after topping Formula 2 qualifying in Monaco…

    F2
  10. Mercedes pins slump on set-up direction 15:58

    Mercedes pins slump on set-up direction

    Mercedes' tumble down the order from first to second practice in Monaco was a result of taking the wrong direction with set-up…

    F1
  11. Ricciardo feels Red Bull is 'in the window' 15:47

    Ricciardo feels Red Bull is 'in the window'

    Daniel Ricciardo reckons Red Bull is "in the window" to challenge at the Monaco Grand Prix after featuring towards the top of…

    F1
  12. Vettel still expects 'full force' Mercedes 15:23

    Vettel still expects 'full force' Mercedes

    Sebastian Vettel says he is still expecting a "full force" Mercedes at this weekend's Monaco Grand Prix, after its "weird…

    F1
  13. 14:36

    Monaco Grand Prix: Full Practice 2 results

    F1
  14. Vettel dominates FP2, Mercedes quiet 14:33

    Vettel dominates FP2, Mercedes quiet

    Sebastian Vettel posted a pair of blistering laps to comfortably set the pace during Thursday's second practice session for the…

    F1
  15. Pirelli announces Hungary tyre compounds 13:35

    Pirelli announces Hungary tyre compounds

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli has announced its compound choices for the Hungarian Grand Prix. Pirelli will bring the Super…

    F1
  16. 12:45

    Follow second practice for the Monaco GP!

    F1
  17. Video: Monaco GP carpool with Bottas 12:02

    Video: Monaco GP carpool with Bottas

    Go on a ride through the Monte-Carlo streets Formula 1-style with Mercedes driver Valtteri Bottas.

    F1
  18. 10:37

    Monaco Grand Prix: Full Practice 1 results

    F1
  19. Hamilton sets record pace in first practice 10:32

    Hamilton sets record pace in first practice

    Mercedes' Lewis Hamilton topped Thursday's first practice session for the Monaco Grand Prix with the fastest ever lap around…

    F1
  20. Haas' new Formula 1 livery breaks cover 09:15

    Haas' new Formula 1 livery breaks cover

    Haas' updated Formula 1 livery has made its public debut, after Romain Grosjean and Kevin Magnussen took to the circuit during…

    F1
  21. 08:42

    Follow first practice for the Monaco GP!

    F1
  22. 07:34

    Photos: IndyCar's universal 2018 body kit

    Indy
  23. IndyCar reveals new 2018 concept images 07:32

    IndyCar reveals new 2018 concept images

    IndyCar organisers have released several fresh, rendered images of the car that will be used by all series competitors during…

    Indy
  24. Palmer admits 'it's up to me to deliver now' 07:02

    Palmer admits 'it's up to me to deliver now'

    Renault driver Jolyon Palmer says it is now up to him to deliver points, following a difficult start to his second season in…

    F1
  25. Video of the Day: Ferrari on Monaco GP 05:38

    Video of the Day: Ferrari on Monaco GP

    Ahead of this weekend's action in the Principality, get Ferrari's lowdown on the Monaco Grand Prix.

    F1
  26. Wednesday 24 May 2017

  27. 18:04

    Latest F1 photos: Preparations in Monaco

    F1
  28. Vettel: Ferrari could have won all races 18:02

    Vettel: Ferrari could have won all races

    Sebastian Vettel reckons Ferrari had the potential to win all five races so far this season, but nonetheless feels that "we got…

    F1
  29. Drivers criticise new 'take-off ramp' kerb 17:43

    Drivers criticise new 'take-off ramp' kerb

    Several Formula 1 drivers have criticised the revised kerb laid on the inside of the Turn 16 apex (the exit of Piscine) at the…

    F1
  30. Button tipped to return 'like duck to water' 17:38

    Button tipped to return 'like duck to water'

    Lewis Hamilton reckons Jenson Button will return to Formula 1 action "like a duck to water" when he takes part in this weekend's…

    F1
  31. In photos: Button's return to the paddock 17:27

    In photos: Button's return to the paddock

    Jenson Button will return to Formula 1 action this weekend at McLaren-Honda in place of Indianapolis-bound Fernando Alonso.…

    F1
  32. Force India introduces triple T-wing design 17:04

    Force India introduces triple T-wing design

    Force India has introduced a triple T-wing design for this weekend's Monaco Grand Prix, as teams chase as much downforce as…

    F1
  33. Hamilton: 2017 cars 'like taming a bull' 17:00

    Hamilton: 2017 cars 'like taming a bull'

    Mercedes driver Lewis Hamilton had described the challenge of racing 2017 Formula 1 cars as akin to "taming a bull", following…

    F1
  34. Button thought testing would be 'useless' 14:30

    Button thought testing would be 'useless'

    McLaren-Honda stand-in Jenson Button insists he is happy with his preparations for this weekend's Monaco Grand Prix, claiming…

    F1
  35. Pérez eyes occasional Red Bull challenge 12:22

    Pérez eyes occasional Red Bull challenge

    Force India driver Sergio Pérez is hopeful that the team can occasionally challenge Red Bull in Formula 1 this year, following…

    F1
  36. 11:49

    Gallery: Monaco charity football match

    F1
  37. Video: 'Mini' Monaco Grand Prix guide 11:02

    Video: 'Mini' Monaco Grand Prix guide

    Get a 'mini' Monaco Grand Prix guide with Red Bull drivers Max Verstappen and Daniel Ricciardo.

    F1
  38. Several changes to Monte-Carlo track 10:31

    Several changes to Monte-Carlo track

    Several changes have been made to the Circuit de Monaco ahead of this year's race in the Principality, with track resurfacing…

    F1
  39. Force India to wear breast cancer ribbon 09:55

    Force India to wear breast cancer ribbon

    Force India has announced a multi-year partnership with Breast Cancer Care, which will see the famous pink ribbon displayed on…

    F1
  40. Video: Leclerc's favourite Monaco spots 07:12

    Video: Leclerc's favourite Monaco spots

    Ferrari-backed F2 title leader Charles Leclerc takes you to his favourite spots at home in Monaco.

    F2
  41. Feature: Leclerc on growing up in Monaco 07:02

    Feature: Leclerc on growing up in Monaco

    Ferrari junior and Formula 2 championship leader Charles Leclerc will race around his home streets, in Monte-Carlo, for the…

    F2
  42. Video of the Day: Monaco GP memories 05:32

    Video of the Day: Monaco GP memories

    Lewis Hamilton, Valtteri Bottas and others from the Silver Arrows family share their Monaco memories.

    F1
more news