Insight: Pérez threat too much for Alonso...

Insight: Pérez threat too much for Alonso...

13 September 2012 – The F1 silly season is in full swing. Most of us have expected Sergio Pérez to be confirmed alongside Fernando Alonso at Ferrari. But, as explained in this exclusive GPUpdate.net column, whispers coming out of Maranello suggest that the Spaniard is pushing to retain Felipe Massa in order to lower the threat to himself.

Racing drivers are selfish, egotistical and arrogant; that tends to be why people employ them. When it comes to selecting your line-up, in any form of motorsport, the two simple goals tend to be: win the championships for drivers and teams. So, employ the best two drivers to do it? As we have seen on countless occasions in the past, that particular formula can often end in catastrophe.

Over the weekend of the Italian Grand Prix, Ferrari’s home race, all of the attention was on Lewis Hamilton and his possible switch from McLaren to Mercedes. That was great news for the red team, as they remained very much out of the spotlight. Behind the scenes, though, Luca di Montezemolo and Stefano Domenicali have a very tough decision on their hands. We already know - because the team confirmed it on their website - that the pair had a lengthy discussion on Monday.

Think back to the glory years. Michael Schumacher dominated and, although he was treated badly at times, Rubens Barrichello assisted for team glory all the way through from 2000 to 2004. After the episode of Monaco 2005, the Paulista finally slung his hook. But he put up with Austria, 2001 and 2002, because there was simply no other competitive seat that he could have filled. The McLaren and Williams arrangements were sorted and so Rubens lived with the stress. This was ideal for Ferrari; one driver had the edge, meaning the pair of them couldn’t fight each other, to easily sew up double titles time after time. Of course, big reasons for this were the particular struggles of their closest rivals, developing Michelin tyres as the Ferrari-Schumacher-Bridgestone partnership went from strength to strength.

They no longer have that luxury. Several teams are now contending, meaning Ferrari has to have two strong drivers in order to stand any chance of winning the constructors’ title. Think about it. Why wouldn’t Ferrari want Pérez? He is out-racing his customer-engined Sauber and overtook both Ferrari cars at Monza. He’s been on the podium three times and is impressing far more than Massa did in any of his three Sauber campaigns. Surely this one is a no-brainer? Think again.

Fernando Alonso is no idiot. His current circumstances are familiar to 2005 and 2006: race-winning car, slower team-mate and a half decent shot at the title. The problem for Ferrari now is that too many other cars are finishing between Alonso and Massa. Back at Renault, Giancarlo Fisichella may have been slower but, as the grid wasn’t as full of such competitive cars, losing a place or two didn’t prevent them from winning the teams’ title. This leaves Montezemolo in a tricky position.

Ferrari clearly needs Alonso. That has been proven this season alone and the fact that, back in May 2011, they agreed terms up to and including 2016 only backs that up. The issue: as much as Fernando may want Ferrari to win, his own intentions come first. Should a Mexican roadblock be put in place, there are obviously going to be tears. Alonso remembers 2007 all too well and we publically saw how the Spaniard, then the reigning double World Champion, reacted (childishly at times) against Lewis Hamilton, even though both were to blame for their eventual loss of the title. Older and wiser nowadays, there is no chance in hell that he wants a repeat performance. Pérez has a sheer ability when it comes to raw speed and simultaneous tyre management: a vital combination in the modern age of Pirelli tyres. So, could he take on Alonso with identical equipment? Given a while, of course he could.

Equally, Ferrari know as well as anybody that running two star drivers can end in, quite literally, a tragedy. In 1982, there was fierce competition between Gilles Villeneuve and Didier Pironi. In front of their home crowd at Imola, the latter disobeyed team orders to win. Two weeks later, Villeneuve was on the limit in qualifying at Zolder, desperate to beat his team-mate, when he struck the back of Jochen Mass at high-speed and lost his life. Pironi suffered career-ending injuries in Germany that summer and Keke Rosberg won the title for Williams.

Having spoken to sources in Maranello, my understanding is the following. Alonso is desperate to keep Massa. The pair are on good terms and Felipe has proven that he can still perform. Drafting Pérez into the team would only be a distraction. Sure enough, if Massa always did what he did in Italy on Sunday – ie. finish one place behind Alonso in every race – then you can be sure that Ferrari would have signed a fresh contract long ago. One problem. As has been demonstrated between 2010 and now, that is not often the case. Perhaps some similar performances between Singapore and Brazil could yield Massa another year, but it is probably too late.

Alonso has power at Ferrari. Domenicali knows it. So does Montezemolo. And, quite frankly, neither of them can afford more lashings in the Italian press. They must perform and, therefore, they must keep their lead man happy. Pérez has already hinted that he intends to stay at Sauber and, as a member of the Ferrari Driver Academy, his time will come. For now, Ferrari is in need of a solid performer. And that is not Sebastian Vettel, as the Scuderia keeps suggesting; this is no more than a smokescreen to mask reality. Can you really imagine Vettel being allowed to race alongside Alonso, in the squad Fernando is building up? Carnage would ensue.

What Ferrari needs is a proven race winner, hungry for success and deprived of any for the past four years. A cool-headed Finn with experience and respect for his employer and team-mate. I don’t mean Kimi Räikkönen. I mean the man who McLaren used to replace Alonso. Step forward, Heikki Kovalainen.


Gregory Haines
GPUpdate.net Editor

Twitter: GregoryHainesF1

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Sunday 14 February 2016

  2. Wolff expects Manor to be midfield runner 09:44

    Wolff expects Manor to be midfield runner

    Mercedes boss Toto Wolff says Manor Racing should make a substantial step forwards in 2016 and emerge as a "solid midfield…

    F1
  3. Honda unveils 2016 RC213V colours 09:03

    Honda unveils 2016 RC213V colours

    Honda has unveiled its Repsol-associated RC213V, which will be piloted by Marc Márquez and Dani Pedrosa in the upcoming MotoGP…

    MotoGP
  4. Video of the Day: How do FE cars work? 05:00

    Video of the Day: How do FE cars work?

    How do Formula E cars work? This video explains how the components collaborate to produce a racing car.

    FE
  5. Saturday 13 February 2016

  6. Rossi: Two-year contract extension or nothing 10:46

    Rossi: Two-year contract extension or nothing

    Yamaha rider Valentino Rossi says he will only stay in MotoGP beyond the end of 2016 if he is willing to commit to a new…

    MotoGP
  7. In photos: Best Formula 1 test liveries 09:31

    In photos: Best Formula 1 test liveries

    Formula 1 testing is sometimes an opportunity for teams to introduce different ideas away from a Grand Prix weekend.…

    F1
  8. Video of the Day: Standout racing corners 05:34

    Video of the Day: Standout racing corners

    Formula E has put together an eight-strong compilation of some of the most iconic corners in motor racing.

    Misc
  9. Friday 12 February 2016

  10. 17:02

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  11. Armand completes Trident's line-up 16:00

    Armand completes Trident's line-up

    Indonesian racer Philo Paz Armand will make the step up to GP2 with Trident in 2016. Armand, 19, contested a selection of…

    GP2
  12. Ecclestone: Monza future still uncertain 14:53

    Ecclestone: Monza future still uncertain

    Formula 1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone says the future of the Italian Grand Prix at Monza remains uncertain, and that progress over…

    F1
  13. Ferrari: No title in 10 years would be 'tragedy' 13:06

    Ferrari: No title in 10 years would be 'tragedy'

    Ferrari President Sergio Marchionne says that it would be a "tragedy" for the team to go 10 years without a title triumph in…

    F1
  14. Video: Tony Kanaan's Indy 500 tattoo 12:18

    Video: Tony Kanaan's Indy 500 tattoo

    IndyCar champion plus Indy 500 and 24 Hours of Daytona winner Tony Kanaan explains his new tattoo.

    Indy
  15. Baz eager to confirm test crash cause 11:25

    Baz eager to confirm test crash cause

    Loris Baz says he is eager to determine the cause of his high-speed accident during the opening pre-season test at Sepang, which…

    MotoGP
  16. Wolff: Wehrlein, Ocon in F1 'on merit' 10:17

    Wolff: Wehrlein, Ocon in F1 'on merit'

    Mercedes motorsport boss Toto Wolff says that he is "proud" to see young drivers Pascal Wehrlein and Esteban Ocon take on…

    F1
  17. Mexico City ePrix to be streamed in UK 10:05

    Mexico City ePrix to be streamed in UK

    Formula E's Mexico City ePrix will not be aired live on ITV4, with the series instead streaming it across various online…

    FE
  18. Vandoorne seals Super Formula drive 09:46

    Vandoorne seals Super Formula drive

    McLaren test and reserve driver Stoffel Vandoorne has secured a seat in the Japan-based Super Formula series for 2016, the…

    F1
  19. ART confirms Matsushita for second term 08:57

    ART confirms Matsushita for second term

    ART Grand Prix has confirmed that it will run Nobuharu Matsushita for a second GP2 season in 2016. Honda-backed Matsushita…

    GP2
  20. Video of the Day: FE on sustainability 05:12

    Video of the Day: FE on sustainability

    Formula E drivers discuss the importance of a sustainable future for cities such as Buenos Aires.

    FE
  21. Thursday 11 February 2016

  22. Video: Ferrari fires up 2016 engine 16:37

    Video: Ferrari fires up 2016 engine

    Ferrari fires up its 2016 power unit as preparations gather pace for the new Formula 1 season.

    F1
  23. De Jong completes MP Motorsport line-up 14:15

    De Jong completes MP Motorsport line-up

    Daniël de Jong will contest the 2016 GP2 season with MP Motorsport, completing the team's line-up. Dutch racer de Jong, 23…

    GP2
  24. 'Engine parity would improve racing' – Key 12:53

    'Engine parity would improve racing' – Key

    Toro Rosso technical chief James Key says that engine parity would be a clear way of improving the racing in Formula 1, as the…

    F1
  25. Jordan moves into BBC Top Gear role 11:03

    Jordan moves into BBC Top Gear role

    Eddie Jordan has taken on a role with the revamped BBC show Top Gear following the broadcaster's early termination of its…

    F1
  26. Video: Mercedes power unit revealed 10:31

    Video: Mercedes power unit revealed

    Mercedes provides a detailed look at its Formula 1 power unit in the latest episode of its studio show.

    F1
  27. Miller to return to action at Phillip Island 10:12

    Miller to return to action at Phillip Island

    Jack Miller will return to action at next week's Phillip Island pre-season test, Marc VDS has confirmed. Miller, who has…

    MotoGP
  28. Ocon lands Mercedes DTM seat for 2016 09:35

    Ocon lands Mercedes DTM seat for 2016

    GP3 champion Esteban Ocon will contest the DTM in 2016, after landing a seat at Mercedes. Ocon, 19, combined his GP3 duties…

    DTM
  29. Wehrlein wants 'really good' team-mate 09:27

    Wehrlein wants 'really good' team-mate

    Pascal Wehrlein says he hopes that Manor will place a competitive driver alongside him for the 2016 season, as discussions…

    F1
  30. Moreno joins Aguri as reserve driver 09:18

    Moreno joins Aguri as reserve driver

    Ecuadorian racer Julio Moreno has joined Team Aguri as its Formula E reserve driver. Moreno, 20, last year contested FIA…

    FE
  31. MotoGP publishes final 2016 calendar 09:09

    MotoGP publishes final 2016 calendar

    MotoGP organisers have issued a final version of the 2016 calendar, with the Jerez and Brno rounds now fully confirmed, after…

    MotoGP
  32. Video of the Day: Drivers on Phoenix return 05:23

    Video of the Day: Drivers on Phoenix return

    Josef Newgarden, Simon Pagenaud and Juan Pablo Montoya reflect on their recent test session at the Phoenix International…

    Indy
  33. Wednesday 10 February 2016

  34. Wehrlein to use number 94 in Formula 1 14:32

    Wehrlein to use number 94 in Formula 1

    Manor's Pascal Wehrlein will use #94 as his permanent race number in Formula 1. Wehrlein, whose Formula 1 graduation was…

    F1
  35. Background: Who is Pascal Wehrlein? 13:28

    Background: Who is Pascal Wehrlein?

    Pascal Wehrlein becomes the second rookie on the Formula 1 grid for the 2016 season after confirmation of his deal with Manor…

    F1
  36. Manor tips Wehrlein to make 'big impact' 11:35

    Manor tips Wehrlein to make 'big impact'

    Pascal Wehrlein has the talent to make a "big impact" with Manor Racing during his debut season in Formula 1, according to the…

    F1
  37. Manor confirms Wehrlein for 2016 season 11:11

    Manor confirms Wehrlein for 2016 season

    Manor Racing has confirmed that DTM champion Pascal Wehrlein will make his Formula 1 debut with the squad in 2016, meaning…

    F1
  38. Video: Red Bull drivers spur a stampede 10:06

    Video: Red Bull drivers spur a stampede

    Red Bull duo Daniel Ricciardo and Daniil Kvyat spur a stampede in this video for clothing partner Puma.

    F1
  39. Redding: 2016 'make or break' year 09:46

    Redding: 2016 'make or break' year

    Pramac rider Scott Redding has described 2016 as a "make or break" year for his future in MotoGP, as the Briton prepares for a…

    MotoGP
  40. 'Wehrlein secures F1 seat with Manor' 08:52

    'Wehrlein secures F1 seat with Manor'

    DTM champion Pascal Wehrlein has landed a seat at Manor for the 2016 season, with a deal to be announced shortly, according to…

    F1
  41. Video of the Day: Suzuki Sepang review 05:27

    Video of the Day: Suzuki Sepang review

    Suzuki riders Maverick Viñales and Aleix Espargaró review the opening pre-season test in Malaysia.

    MotoGP
  42. Tuesday 9 February 2016

  43. New McLaren passes FIA crash tests 15:57

    New McLaren passes FIA crash tests

    McLaren's new Formula 1 car, the Honda-powered MP4-31, has passed the FIA's mandatory crash tests ahead of pre-season testing…

    F1
  44. 15:43

    Photos: Australian Grand Prix photocall

    F1
  45. MotoGP reveals Baz test crash data 14:02

    MotoGP reveals Baz test crash data

    MotoGP has revealed the full telemetry data from Loris Baz's frightening 290km/h pre-season testing accident at Sepang, with the…

    MotoGP
  46. Video: Rémi Taffin outlines Renault task 12:16

    Video: Rémi Taffin outlines Renault task

    Renault Engine Technical Director Rémi Taffin outlines the task ahead of the company on its works return.

    F1
more news