Column: Addressing the weight issue

Column: Addressing the weight issue

5 April 2014 – Height is an important yet frequently disregarded aspect of a sportsperson. In football, taller players tend to be goalkeepers due to the greater height and reach, thus being able to protect more of the goal. Up front, attackers must play to their strength. The likes of Lionel Messi [5ft 7in/169cm] can weave in and out of defenders due to his agility, while others such as Zlatan Ibrahimović [6ft 5in/195cm] have more strength and visibility.

Both have pulled off the sublime and the ridiculous; Messi's goal against Arsenal in the Champions League in 2011, or his solo effort against Real Madrid in the same competition show his brilliance. For Ibrahimović, witness his goal for Sweden against England for sheer wonderment. Would Ibrahimović have been able to do what Messi did, or vice versa? Possibly, but unlikely. They played to their strengths and did so in captivating fashion.

So what relevance does this have in the world of Formula 1?

Well, talent comes in all shapes and sizes yet in Formula 1 this season the tallest drivers are supremely disadvantaged. Lighter drivers are at an advantage in terms of ballast; those with additional height simply cannot be as light as their shorter rivals. Sauber's Adrian Sutil has been most vocal about the subject.

"There is a danger," said Sutil. "You are driving more than 300 kilometres per hour on the straights and we need to be in good shape, in our bodies and our mind. It's not so easy any more, and you can't guarantee every driver is 100 per cent from a physical point of view. And I can feel it. I lost three or four kilos compared to last year.

"All the tall drivers, not just me, have to lose so much weight. There's not so much you can lose anyway. You can't even train because you want to lose the muscles you have. It's a difficult situation at the moment and I don't think it's fair. Small drivers can eat whatever they want, get a belly, yet because we are naturally heavier we get a penalty, something like half a second per lap or more. That's not because they are better drivers, just because they are lighter. This is not as it should be in Formula One because I still see it as a sport."

It would be naïve to suggest that Sutil could suddenly become a top competitor if the weight issue is resolved, for some of his issues are caused by Sauber's heavy car, but he has a point. Mark Webber revealed last year on social media that the minimum weight has been too low for "ages", and says 60/65kg is the target for drivers.

The minimum weight limit for 2014 is 691kg, up from 642kg in 2013, but the majority of that has been taken up by the new, heavier power units. Every driver has been slimming beyond belief across the winter to hit the minimum limit, with a couple now looking absurdly skinny. The figure banded about for an extra 10kg is in the region of 0.3s/lap, with heavier drivers also penalised in terms of the distribution of ballast. So why has Formula 1 once again found itself in a predicament?

"The lightest drivers have a problem with it, they block it," said Sutil of possible rule changes. "I think it's unfair. I wouldn't like to win against a driver who is 20kg heavier. If I win by a tenth in qualifying, this is not the truth."

"We want to have a good sport and us drivers could do a bit more if we hold together. Everyone should think about what we do and why we are in this situation. Is there any reason for it? No. The sport would be the same or better if we had a normal weight limit. We could eat properly, be happy at the circuit and not have this discussion.

Of course, as ever in Formula 1 it is about gaining a competitive advantage. Felipe Massa, one of the shortest drivers on the grid and therefore least affected by the weight issue, takes a different viewpoint.

"I think this is a problem with his team," said Massa. "If a team has a heavier engine or a heavier car, it's up to them to do a better job. I am light, and I am happy to be light, but if I was 10kg heavier I wouldn't have any problems. My team did a better job and I don't think it's fair for a team that did a better job on the rules to be put on that level. It's like if somebody finds something better with the engine or aerodynamics. These are the rules."

Massa has an advantage that neither he nor Williams will want to give up in a sport dominated by politics and money, the latter of which is of vital importance to any team. However, Massa misses the point. Sauber can undoubtedly improve their car and make it lighter, but no amount of tweaks to a front wing or changes to a bargeboard will alter the fact that Sutil will never be able to be as slim as Massa. It is a physical impossibility that leaves him at a disadvantage. This is not just a Sutil versus Massa battle, as it affects drivers up and down the grid but it is an issue that needs resolving in the interests of the sport. Just last week Lewis Hamilton, a driver towards the shorter end of the height spectrum, tweeted a picture of himself looking forlornly at a jar of cookies, captioned 'if only'. No-one would be foolish enough to suggest that drivers are only winning because of their height, but it is absurd when Nico Hülkenberg is praised for a strong race and pundits have to add "considering his height".

For next season, the minimum weight limit will be raised by 10kg to 2015, which will ultimately be seen as aiding the plight of the taller drivers. The move was voted on by the F1 Strategy Group to come into force for 2014, but one team objected. Yet designers will always design a car to be as quick as possible, irrespective of the driver, who is just seen as a fleshy inconvenience. Teams will still require drivers to be as slim as possible, and so the problem will remain. A fairer method in the Machiavellian world of Formula 1 would be to introduce a minimum limit for the combination of a driver plus his seat. In theory, that would result in a level playing field.

This might not happen, but something has to be done to avoid taller drivers putting themselves in danger. Formula 1 should be able to appreciate both the Messis and Ibrahimovićs of the racing world.

Phillip Horton
Twitter: @PHortonF1

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Thursday 3 September 2015

  2. 15:02

    Latest F1 photos: Preparations at Monza

    F1
  3. Van Buuren and Binder join MP Motorsport 14:24

    Van Buuren and Binder join MP Motorsport

    Meindert van Buuren and René Binder will comprise the driver line-up for MP Motorsport at this weekend's round of the GP2…

    GP2
  4. Pirelli presents Belgian GP conclusions 13:54

    Pirelli presents Belgian GP conclusions

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli has presented its conclusions following a detailed investigation into the two separate tyre…

    F1
  5. Further engine penalties for McLaren pair 13:29

    Further engine penalties for McLaren pair

    McLaren-Honda drivers Fernando Alonso and Jenson Button are set endure further grid penalties at the Italian Grand Prix, after…

    F1
  6. Pérez expects new Force India deal 'soon' 12:03

    Pérez expects new Force India deal 'soon'

    Sergio Pérez says it is his intention to remain as a Force India driver next season, and expects a fresh deal to be announced…

    F1
  7. Cecotto Jr. makes Trident GP2 return 11:02

    Cecotto Jr. makes Trident GP2 return

    Johnny Cecotto Jr. will make a return to the GP2 Series this weekend alongside Ferrari youngster Raffaele Marciello at…

    GP2
  8. 10:42

    Formula 1 2016: Driver line-ups so far

    F1
  9. Williams boosted by line-up stability 10:38

    Williams boosted by line-up stability

    Sir Frank Williams says his eponymous team is in a "fantastic position" ahead of the 2016 season, thanks to the stability of…

    F1
  10. Williams keeps Massa, Bottas for 2016 10:01

    Williams keeps Massa, Bottas for 2016

    Williams will continue with an unchanged driver line-up of Felipe Massa and Valtteri Bottas for the 2016 season, the pair…

    F1
  11. Trummer re-joins Hilmer for Monza 09:06

    Trummer re-joins Hilmer for Monza

    Simon Trummer will make a return to the GP2 Series with Hilmer Motorsport for this weekend's round at Monza. Trummer, who…

    GP2
  12. Video of the Day: Hamilton's Monza preview 05:26

    Video of the Day: Hamilton's Monza preview

    Mercedes driver and championship leader Lewis Hamilton looks ahead to the Italian Grand Prix at Monza.

    F1
  13. Wednesday 2 September 2015

  14. Video: Toro Rosso duo play word tennis 14:35

    Video: Toro Rosso duo play word tennis

    Toro Rosso youngsters Carlos Sainz Jr. and Max Verstappen play word tennis ahead of the Italian GP.

    F1
  15. Renault confident over power unit performance 13:40

    Renault confident over power unit performance

    Renault Director of Operations Rémi Taffin says that the power unit supplier can head into this weekend's Italian Grand Prix…

    F1
  16. Williams targets Monza podium repeat 12:24

    Williams targets Monza podium repeat

    Williams Head of Vehicle Performance Rob Smedley believes that there is no reason why the squad cannot target a repeat of its…

    F1
  17. Honda braced for 'big challenge' at Monza 10:32

    Honda braced for 'big challenge' at Monza

    McLaren's engine supplier Honda says it is braced for a "big challenge" at this weekend's Italian Grand Prix, due to the…

    F1
  18. Preview: Five key questions for Italy 09:35

    Preview: Five key questions for Italy

    Formula 1 heads to the historic Monza circuit this weekend to signal the end of the European part of the 2015 season. Here…

    F1
  19. Mardenborough steps up to GP2 with Carlin 09:13

    Mardenborough steps up to GP2 with Carlin

    British driver Jann Mardenborough will make his GP2 Series debut with Carlin at this weekend's round of the championship at…

    GP2
  20. Armand to make Pons return at Silverstone 08:24

    Armand to make Pons return at Silverstone

    Philo Paz Armand is set to make his return to the Formula Renault 3.5 Series at Silverstone this weekend. Armand, a rookie in…

    FR 3.5
  21. Factfile: The 2015 Italian Grand Prix 07:43

    Factfile: The 2015 Italian Grand Prix

    Formula 1's European leg comes to an end with this weekend's Italian Grand Prix. Ahead of the event at the Autodromo Nazionale…

    F1
  22. Video of the Day: Vettel's Monza preview 05:26

    Video of the Day: Vettel's Monza preview

    Quadruple World Champion Sebastian Vettel looks ahead to his first Italian Grand Prix as a Ferrari driver.

    F1
  23. Tuesday 1 September 2015

  24. 17:42

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  25. Sainz Jr. set for 10-place grid drop at Monza 17:30

    Sainz Jr. set for 10-place grid drop at Monza

    Toro Rosso rookie Carlos Sainz Jr. is set to take a 10-place grid drop for this weekend's Italian Grand Prix at Monza, with…

    F1
  26. Video: Ferrari previews home F1 race 14:08

    Video: Ferrari previews home F1 race

    Ferrari previews its home Formula 1 race, the Italian Grand Prix at Monza, which takes place this weekend.

    F1
  27. Button hopeful deployment issues fixed 12:43

    Button hopeful deployment issues fixed

    Jenson Button says McLaren-Honda has been working hard to ensure that the deployment problems he endured at the Belgian Grand…

    F1
  28. Rosberg targets qualifying, start gains 12:04

    Rosberg targets qualifying, start gains

    Nico Rosberg is focused on improving his qualifying pace and start procedure at the Italian Grand Prix, as he bids to get on…

    F1
  29. Hülkenberg signs new Force India deal 11:27

    Hülkenberg signs new Force India deal

    Nico Hülkenberg will remain as a Force India driver until at least the end of the 2017 Formula 1 campaign, after the 24 Hours…

    F1
  30. Wilson wins IndyCar fan favourite award 11:26

    Wilson wins IndyCar fan favourite award

    The late Justin Wilson was posthumously awarded IndyCar's fan favourite accolade at the end-of-season championship celebration…

    Indy
  31. Niederhauser to make GP2 debut at Monza 09:29

    Niederhauser to make GP2 debut at Monza

    Patric Niederhauser will make his GP2 debut with Team Lazarus at this weekend's Monza round. Niederhauser, who finished 10th…

    GP2
  32. Video of the Day: Kvyat demos F1 car in Russia 05:26

    Video of the Day: Kvyat demos F1 car in Russia

    Red Bull's Daniil Kvyat showcased Formula 1 machinery at the recent Kazan City Racing event in Russia.

    F1
  33. Monday 31 August 2015

  34. Pirelli completes Vettel tyre investigation 17:53

    Pirelli completes Vettel tyre investigation

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli has completed its investigation into the circumstances surrounding Sebastian Vettel's failure in…

    F1
  35. Hülkenberg keen to make up for DNS 14:24

    Hülkenberg keen to make up for DNS

    Nico Hülkenberg is hopeful that he can make up for his non-start in Belgium with a return to the points-paying positions at…

    F1
  36. Video: Dixon snatches title with Sonoma win 13:34

    Video: Dixon snatches title with Sonoma win

    Watch highlights as Scott Dixon wins the double-points Sonoma finale to snatch his fourth IndyCar title.

    Indy
  37. Pérez: We must keep aiming for podium 12:06

    Pérez: We must keep aiming for podium

    Sergio Pérez says Force India should continue to target podium finishes over the remainder of the 2015 season, after an…

    F1
  38. Monza tyre selection 'way more sensible' 10:41

    Monza tyre selection 'way more sensible'

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli has been praised for making a "way more sensible" compound selection for this weekend's Italian…

    F1
  39. Márquez concedes 2015 title chances over 10:15

    Márquez concedes 2015 title chances over

    Repsol Honda rider Marc Márquez has admitted that his chances of defending his MotoGP title are all but over after he crashed…

    MotoGP
  40. Rossi 'very proud' of British Grand Prix win 09:32

    Rossi 'very proud' of British Grand Prix win

    Yamaha's Valentino Rossi described himself as "very proud" after mastering wet conditions to win the British Grand Prix and…

    MotoGP
  41. Video of the Day: Driven by Data - Heat 05:11

    Video of the Day: Driven by Data - Heat

    F1 brakes reach extreme temperatures, as McLaren outlines in the final part of its technical video series.

    F1
  42. 01:16

    Latest IndyCar photos: Sunday at Sonoma

    Indy
  43. Peerless Dixon beats Montoya to IndyCar crown 01:12

    Peerless Dixon beats Montoya to IndyCar crown

    For the fourth time in his storied career, Scott Dixon has won the Verizon IndyCar Series championship, bettering Juan Pablo…

    Indy
  44. Sunday 30 August 2015

  45. Helmet auction to benefit Justin Wilson fund 21:43

    Helmet auction to benefit Justin Wilson fund

    All of the IndyCar drivers in today's season finale have decided to donate their helmets to a large online auction for the…

    Indy
more news