Column: Addressing the weight issue

Column: Addressing the weight issue

5 April 2014 – Height is an important yet frequently disregarded aspect of a sportsperson. In football, taller players tend to be goalkeepers due to the greater height and reach, thus being able to protect more of the goal. Up front, attackers must play to their strength. The likes of Lionel Messi [5ft 7in/169cm] can weave in and out of defenders due to his agility, while others such as Zlatan Ibrahimović [6ft 5in/195cm] have more strength and visibility.

Both have pulled off the sublime and the ridiculous; Messi's goal against Arsenal in the Champions League in 2011, or his solo effort against Real Madrid in the same competition show his brilliance. For Ibrahimović, witness his goal for Sweden against England for sheer wonderment. Would Ibrahimović have been able to do what Messi did, or vice versa? Possibly, but unlikely. They played to their strengths and did so in captivating fashion.

So what relevance does this have in the world of Formula 1?

Well, talent comes in all shapes and sizes yet in Formula 1 this season the tallest drivers are supremely disadvantaged. Lighter drivers are at an advantage in terms of ballast; those with additional height simply cannot be as light as their shorter rivals. Sauber's Adrian Sutil has been most vocal about the subject.

"There is a danger," said Sutil. "You are driving more than 300 kilometres per hour on the straights and we need to be in good shape, in our bodies and our mind. It's not so easy any more, and you can't guarantee every driver is 100 per cent from a physical point of view. And I can feel it. I lost three or four kilos compared to last year.

"All the tall drivers, not just me, have to lose so much weight. There's not so much you can lose anyway. You can't even train because you want to lose the muscles you have. It's a difficult situation at the moment and I don't think it's fair. Small drivers can eat whatever they want, get a belly, yet because we are naturally heavier we get a penalty, something like half a second per lap or more. That's not because they are better drivers, just because they are lighter. This is not as it should be in Formula One because I still see it as a sport."

It would be naïve to suggest that Sutil could suddenly become a top competitor if the weight issue is resolved, for some of his issues are caused by Sauber's heavy car, but he has a point. Mark Webber revealed last year on social media that the minimum weight has been too low for "ages", and says 60/65kg is the target for drivers.

The minimum weight limit for 2014 is 691kg, up from 642kg in 2013, but the majority of that has been taken up by the new, heavier power units. Every driver has been slimming beyond belief across the winter to hit the minimum limit, with a couple now looking absurdly skinny. The figure banded about for an extra 10kg is in the region of 0.3s/lap, with heavier drivers also penalised in terms of the distribution of ballast. So why has Formula 1 once again found itself in a predicament?

"The lightest drivers have a problem with it, they block it," said Sutil of possible rule changes. "I think it's unfair. I wouldn't like to win against a driver who is 20kg heavier. If I win by a tenth in qualifying, this is not the truth."

"We want to have a good sport and us drivers could do a bit more if we hold together. Everyone should think about what we do and why we are in this situation. Is there any reason for it? No. The sport would be the same or better if we had a normal weight limit. We could eat properly, be happy at the circuit and not have this discussion.

Of course, as ever in Formula 1 it is about gaining a competitive advantage. Felipe Massa, one of the shortest drivers on the grid and therefore least affected by the weight issue, takes a different viewpoint.

"I think this is a problem with his team," said Massa. "If a team has a heavier engine or a heavier car, it's up to them to do a better job. I am light, and I am happy to be light, but if I was 10kg heavier I wouldn't have any problems. My team did a better job and I don't think it's fair for a team that did a better job on the rules to be put on that level. It's like if somebody finds something better with the engine or aerodynamics. These are the rules."

Massa has an advantage that neither he nor Williams will want to give up in a sport dominated by politics and money, the latter of which is of vital importance to any team. However, Massa misses the point. Sauber can undoubtedly improve their car and make it lighter, but no amount of tweaks to a front wing or changes to a bargeboard will alter the fact that Sutil will never be able to be as slim as Massa. It is a physical impossibility that leaves him at a disadvantage. This is not just a Sutil versus Massa battle, as it affects drivers up and down the grid but it is an issue that needs resolving in the interests of the sport. Just last week Lewis Hamilton, a driver towards the shorter end of the height spectrum, tweeted a picture of himself looking forlornly at a jar of cookies, captioned 'if only'. No-one would be foolish enough to suggest that drivers are only winning because of their height, but it is absurd when Nico Hülkenberg is praised for a strong race and pundits have to add "considering his height".

For next season, the minimum weight limit will be raised by 10kg to 2015, which will ultimately be seen as aiding the plight of the taller drivers. The move was voted on by the F1 Strategy Group to come into force for 2014, but one team objected. Yet designers will always design a car to be as quick as possible, irrespective of the driver, who is just seen as a fleshy inconvenience. Teams will still require drivers to be as slim as possible, and so the problem will remain. A fairer method in the Machiavellian world of Formula 1 would be to introduce a minimum limit for the combination of a driver plus his seat. In theory, that would result in a level playing field.

This might not happen, but something has to be done to avoid taller drivers putting themselves in danger. Formula 1 should be able to appreciate both the Messis and Ibrahimovićs of the racing world.

Phillip Horton
Twitter: @PHortonF1

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Saturday 28 May 2016

  2. 18:52

    Latest F1 photos: Saturday in Monaco

    F1
  3. Verstappen to start Monaco GP from pits 18:50

    Verstappen to start Monaco GP from pits

    Red Bull has confirmed that Max Verstappen will start the Monaco Grand Prix from the pit lane, after he crashed out of…

    F1
  4. Kvyat cleared over failed floor test 18:45

    Kvyat cleared over failed floor test

    Stewards at the Monaco Grand Prix have cleared Daniil Kvyat to start from eighth place on the grid, after Toro Rosso cited floor…

    F1
  5. Kvyat's car fails post-qualifying checks 17:35

    Kvyat's car fails post-qualifying checks

    Toro Rosso has been summoned to the stewards after Daniil Kvyat's STR11 failed post-qualifying checks at the Monaco Grand…

    F1
  6. Grosjean rues out-lap traffic after Q2 exit 17:17

    Grosjean rues out-lap traffic after Q2 exit

    Romain Grosjean says getting stuck behind the Mercedes drivers on his warm-up lap during qualifying for the Monaco Grand Prix…

    F1
  7. Hülkenberg: Fifth place a 'nice surprise' 17:11

    Hülkenberg: Fifth place a 'nice surprise'

    Nico Hülkenberg says qualifying fifth on the grid for the Monaco Grand Prix was a "nice surprise" as he looks to end a…

    F1
  8. Alonso struggling despite Q3 appearance 15:58

    Alonso struggling despite Q3 appearance

    Fernando Alonso says he is struggling with the handling of McLaren's Honda-powered MP4-31 despite his Q3 appearance in…

    F1
  9. Matsushita cruises to victory in Monaco 15:56

    Matsushita cruises to victory in Monaco

    Nobuharu Matsushita kick-started his and defending champion ART Grand Prix's season as he cruised to victory during the GP2…

    GP2
  10. Vettel: We should have done a better job 15:46

    Vettel: We should have done a better job

    Sebastian Vettel has conceded that he and Ferrari should have done "a better job" during qualifying for the Monaco Grand…

    F1
  11. Horner hails 'dynamite' Ricciardo lap 15:24

    Horner hails 'dynamite' Ricciardo lap

    Christian Horner heaped praise on Daniel Ricciardo for delivering a "dynamite" lap to secure pole position for the Monaco Grand…

    F1
  12. Hamilton: Pole was 'there for the taking' 15:10

    Hamilton: Pole was 'there for the taking'

    Lewis Hamilton reckons pole position at the Monaco Grand Prix was "there for the taking" before he encountered technical…

    F1
  13. Ricciardo: Pole on my mind all weekend 14:58

    Ricciardo: Pole on my mind all weekend

    Red Bull's Daniel Ricciardo says that securing pole position was at the forefront of his mind as he entered the Monaco Grand…

    F1
  14. 14:20

    Monaco Grand Prix: Full Qualifying results

    F1
  15. Ricciardo claims sensational Monaco pole 14:16

    Ricciardo claims sensational Monaco pole

    Daniel Ricciardo claimed his maiden pole position with a stunning qualifying performance in Monaco, ahead of Mercedes' Nico…

    F1
  16. Verstappen hopes for rain after Q1 exit 13:41

    Verstappen hopes for rain after Q1 exit

    Max Verstappen says he is hoping for wet weather to affect Sunday's Monaco Grand Prix after he crashed out of qualifying during…

    F1
  17. 12:48

    Follow qualifying for the Monaco GP!

    F1
  18. Räikkönen to take five-place grid penalty 12:39

    Räikkönen to take five-place grid penalty

    Kimi Räikkönen will take a five-place grid penalty for the Monaco Grand Prix after a gearbox change. Räikkönen finished…

    F1
  19. F1 set to introduce 'halo' over 'aeroscreen' 11:35

    F1 set to introduce 'halo' over 'aeroscreen'

    Formula 1 has reportedly decided to introduce the 'halo' cockpit protection system over the alternate 'aeroscreen' for 2017…

    F1
  20. 11:08

    Monaco Grand Prix: Full Practice 3 results

    F1
  21. Vettel tops final Monaco GP practice 11:05

    Vettel tops final Monaco GP practice

    Ferrari driver Sebastian Vettel topped the timesheets during Saturday morning's ultra-close final free practice session for the…

    F1
  22. Renault spends three tokens on upgrade 10:34

    Renault spends three tokens on upgrade

    Renault is the only engine manufacturer to have spent development tokens for the Monaco Grand Prix. Renault used three tokens…

    F1
  23. Video: Pirelli outlines wider 2017 tyres 10:03

    Video: Pirelli outlines wider 2017 tyres

    Formula 1 will undergo significant technical changes for 2017, with Pirelli's tyres playing a key role.

    F1
  24. Pirelli offers first look at wider tyres 10:01

    Pirelli offers first look at wider tyres

    Pirelli has offered a first glimpse of what its Formula 1 tyres could look like from 2017 after presenting the wider rubber on a…

    F1
  25. 09:52

    Follow final practice for the Monaco GP!

    F1
  26. Video of the Day: McLaren's 50 years in F1 05:27

    Video of the Day: McLaren's 50 years in F1

    McLaren celebrates its 50 years in F1 with a special film, presented by team partner Richard Mille.

    F1
  27. Friday 27 May 2016

  28. Giovinazzi penalised, Matsushita gets pole 17:22

    Giovinazzi penalised, Matsushita gets pole

    Nobuharu Matsushita will start GP2's Sprint Race from pole position on Saturday following a penalty for Prema's Antonio…

    GP2
  29. 16:34

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  30. Video: Ferrari's Monaco technical guide 15:32

    Video: Ferrari's Monaco technical guide

    Ferrari Technical Director James Allison talks about the demands of the Monte-Carlo street circuit.

    F1
  31. Kvyat feeling 'better and better' in STR11 13:06

    Kvyat feeling 'better and better' in STR11

    Daniil Kvyat says that his feeling at the wheel of Toro Rosso's STR11 is getting "better and better" on a lap-by-lap basis as he…

    F1
  32. Markelov takes maiden win in GP2 thriller 11:46

    Markelov takes maiden win in GP2 thriller

    Artem Markelov surged from 15th on the grid and profited from a litany of Virtual Safety Car (VSC) periods to provisionally…

    GP2
  33. Haryanto misses long runs due to crash 11:22

    Haryanto misses long runs due to crash

    Manor driver Rio Haryanto was left to rue the lack of any meaningful long runs during practice for the Monaco Grand Prix, after…

    F1
  34. Video: Sauber drivers on Monaco GP 10:03

    Video: Sauber drivers on Monaco GP

    Sauber drivers Felipe Nasr and Marcus Ericsson talk about the challenges of the Monaco Grand Prix.

    F1
  35. Sauber expects to resolve issues 'shortly' 09:24

    Sauber expects to resolve issues 'shortly'

    Sauber team boss Monisha Kaltenborn has expressed confidence that Sauber will resolve its financial issues in the near future…

    F1
  36. Baz confirmed to miss Catalan Grand Prix 08:12

    Baz confirmed to miss Catalan Grand Prix

    Avintia rider Loris Baz will miss next weekend's MotoGP round at the Circuit de Barcelona-Catalunya as a result of the injuries…

    MotoGP
  37. Pirelli pleased with full Ultra Soft debut 07:42

    Pirelli pleased with full Ultra Soft debut

    Pirelli hailed a positive start with its new Ultra Soft tyre compound as the purple-marked rubber made its race weekend debut on…

    F1
  38. Gasly to start from pits after penalty 07:28

    Gasly to start from pits after penalty

    GP2 Series leader Pierre Gasly must start today's Monaco Feature Race from the pit lane after failing to stop at the weighbridge…

    GP2
  39. Video of the Day: FI drawing challenge 05:12

    Video of the Day: FI drawing challenge

    Force India drivers Sergio Pérez and Nico Hülkenberg take part in a special Monaco drawing challenge.

    F1
  40. Thursday 26 May 2016

  41. 19:02

    Latest F1 photos: Thursday in Monaco

    F1
  42. Button 'lucky' in drain cover incident 18:53

    Button 'lucky' in drain cover incident

    Jenson Button says he felt "lucky" to escape unharmed after his car struck a drain cover during first practice for the Monaco…

    F1
  43. Rosberg expecting 'very close' battle 16:24

    Rosberg expecting 'very close' battle

    Mercedes driver Nico Rosberg is expecting a "very close" fight with Red Bull at the Monaco Grand Prix, given the times posted in…

    F1
more news