Opinion: F1 needs to be boring in order to thrill

Opinion: F1 needs to be boring in order to thrill

20 June 2014 – "The show has not been good enough at some races this year and with one team dominating, the spectators want more excitement."

Those are the words of Fernando Alonso with regards to the 2014 Formula 1 season. There's an assumption that Formula 1's fans are underwhelmed with the spectacle provided by the new regulations and a concern that Mercedes's dominance is causing people to switch off the television.

It's true – to an extent. Television audiences have been dwindling in the sport, although that's partly down to its baffling reluctance to properly embrace new media and its transition to pay-per-view in the unending quest for more money. If fewer people are able to watch the programme, of course audience figures will drop…

The sport faces several other issues – none more so pressing than the financial problems being encountered by a worrying amount of teams – but 'the show' is not one of them.

The boom of social media and the reportage of every tiny piece of information mean that Formula 1 is in the news 24/7. Every minute of every practice session is shown. No stone is unturned. Coverage now in leading nations is brilliant, but it also has the down side that it is far easier to criticise less interesting events. You'll hear talk of how races have been 'underwhelming' or 'failed to live up to expectation' – part of this is down to people hyping up every single event as if it's the best thing in the history of the world, rather than just another round in a championship approaching its 1000th event.

This season, there have been a couple of outstanding races – in Bahrain and Canada – while Monaco was also an exciting race. Some have had some moments of intrigue and suspense, especially if you know where to look, while a couple featured little engaging action. Rose-tinted glasses lead people to believe that past seasons featured non-stop swashbuckling racing in every event, which was far from the case. Certain periods of history rightly have iconic status, but there were some races in which very little happened.

But that's not a problem. In fact, it's rather a good thing.

There's a false assumption that Formula 1 must be consistently engaging – it's just not possible. No sport is exciting all of the time. People remember the epic Tennis matches between top players, but for every one there are several straightforward games. For every controversial 4-3 football match, there's a draw with a couple of wayward shots on goal.

But those less interesting events only serve to make the properly exciting ones even better. It's just the way sport works and to change it in favour of artificial non-stop action (a direction in which Formula 1 has teetered towards across the last few years) would be completely wrong. Such as the proposal, set to be approved by the World Motor Sport Council, for standing restarts after Safety Car periods rather than the current rolling restart. It's a ridiculous concept that reeks of a sport ignoring its prevalent problems and proposing answers for questions no-one asked. Such as double points. Football doesn't propose wider goals after 0-0 results, so why does Formula 1 consistently propose ludicrous ideas to 'spice up the show'?

Besides, the most vocal criticism of Formula 1 this season has come from a leading team whose glory days are becoming increasingly distant, with little hope of improvement in the short-term. The leading team, Mercedes, hasn't been complaining. It's up to everyone else to aspire to their sort of dominance, rather than criticise the regulations that have led to it.

Spicing up the 'show' solely in the pursuit of entertainment is synthetic and the antithesis of what Formula 1 is about.

Phillip Horton
Twitter: @PHortonF1


Do you agree? Join in the discussion via our interactive Facebook panel below...

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Monday 15 September 2014

  2. Radio traffic rule also applies to pit boards 17:31

    Radio traffic rule also applies to pit boards

    Formula 1's governing body, the FIA, has sent a fresh technical directive to the teams confirming that the radio message...

    F1
  3. Video: Van der Garde wins at Goodwood 15:48

    Video: Van der Garde wins at Goodwood

    Relive highlights as Sauber reserve driver Giedo van der Garde claims victory in the RAC TT Celebration race at the Goodwood...

    F1
  4. 14:02

    Photos: Goodwood Revival 2014

    F1
  5. Wehrlein named Mercedes reserve driver 13:06

    Wehrlein named Mercedes reserve driver

    DTM racer Pascal Wehrlein, just a day after claiming his maiden victory in the touring car championship at the Lausitzring,...

    F1
  6. Singapore keeps pair of DRS zones 12:42

    Singapore keeps pair of DRS zones

    Governing body the FIA has chosen to retain two DRS zones for this year's Singapore Grand Prix. The night race featured...

    F1
  7. Redding to ride Marc VDS Honda in 2015 10:32

    Redding to ride Marc VDS Honda in 2015

    Marc VDS will run Scott Redding on a Factory Honda in MotoGP in 2015, when it steps up from Moto2. Redding had been...

    MotoGP
  8. Prodromou starts work at McLaren 10:04

    Prodromou starts work at McLaren

    Peter Prodromou has officially started work at McLaren in his new position of Chief Engineer. Prodromou signed a deal...

    F1
  9. Video: Ericsson in Swedish F1 demo 09:40

    Video: Ericsson in Swedish F1 demo

    Caterham driver Marcus Ericsson returned to his native Sweden for the Örebro Race Day last weekend. Watch as he wows the...

    F1
  10. MotoGP announces software freeze 09:08

    MotoGP announces software freeze

    MotoGP has announced that manufacturers will not be permitted to develop their own software beyond June 2015, as the premier...

    MotoGP
  11. 09:06

    Photos: Singapore Grand Prix preparations

    F1
  12. Ericsson: Brakes Caterham's main weakness 08:04

    Ericsson: Brakes Caterham's main weakness

    Marcus Ericsson says instability under braking is currently the primary problem facing Caterham as it bids to close the gap...

    F1
  13. Singapore memories: Räikkönen's bold pass 05:06

    Singapore memories: Räikkönen's bold pass

    Relive one of the finest overtakes from the short history of the Singapore Grand Prix, with then Lotus driver Kimi Räikkönen...

    F1
  14. Sunday 14 September 2014

  15. 17:01

    Latest MotoGP photos: Sunday at Misano

    MotoGP
  16. Márquez happy despite Misano crash 16:58

    Márquez happy despite Misano crash

    Marc Márquez says he was happy to collect a point for 15th place, despite sliding out of contention for victory in the San...

    MotoGP
  17. 13:59

    Latest FR3.5 photos: Sunday at the Hungaroring

    FR 3.5
  18. Nato beats Merhi to victory in Hungary 13:58

    Nato beats Merhi to victory in Hungary

    Norman Nato profited from a strong start to claim victory in the final race of the Formula Renault 3.5 round at the...

    FR 3.5
  19. Rossi wins at Misano as Márquez crashes 13:51

    Rossi wins at Misano as Márquez crashes

    Valentino Rossi claimed a popular first victory of the season at Misano as World Champion Marc Márquez was only 15th after...

    MotoGP
  20. Hülkenberg: Force India desperate for fifth 09:14

    Hülkenberg: Force India desperate for fifth

    Nico Hülkenberg says Force India is "desperate" to finish in the top five of the Constructors' Championship as they bid to...

    F1
  21. I'm still in the title hunt, says Hamilton 06:02

    I'm still in the title hunt, says Hamilton

    Lewis Hamilton is adamant that he remains in the hunt for this year's World Championship as he bids to close down the...

    F1
  22. Video of the Day: Beijing ePrix highlights 05:12

    Video of the Day: Beijing ePrix highlights

    Enjoy highlights of the first ever Formula E race on the streets of Beijing, won by Audi Sport Abt's Lucas di Grassi after a...

    Formula E
  23. Saturday 13 September 2014

  24. 16:30

    Latest Formula E photos: Beijing ePrix

    Formula E
  25. Prost handed grid penalty for Heidfeld clash 16:28

    Prost handed grid penalty for Heidfeld clash

    Nicolas Prost has been handed a 10-place grid penalty for the next round of the Formula E Championship after he was deemed...

    Formula E
  26. Rosberg 'determined' to hold on to lead 15:30

    Rosberg 'determined' to hold on to lead

    Championship leader Nico Rosberg says he is determined to hold on to his advantage in the title race as the Formula 1 season...

    F1
  27. 14:01

    Latest MotoGP photos: Saturday at Misano

    MotoGP
  28. Lorenzo secures first pole of 2014 at Misano 14:00

    Lorenzo secures first pole of 2014 at Misano

    Jorge Lorenzo claimed his first pole position of the season during a tightly contested qualifying session for the San Marino...

    MotoGP
  29. 13:52

    Latest FR3.5 photos: Saturday at the Hungaroring

    FR 3.5
  30. Merhi takes dominant victory at wet Hungaroring 13:51

    Merhi takes dominant victory at wet Hungaroring

    Roberto Merhi claimed a dominant Formula Renault 3.5 victory in the first race of the weekend at a wet Hungaroring. Merhi...

    FR 3.5
  31. Heidfeld 'not mad' with Prost despite Beijing crash 12:00

    Heidfeld 'not mad' with Prost despite Beijing crash

    Nick Heidfeld says he is 'not mad' at Formula E rival Nicolas Prost despite the pair colliding while fighting for victory...

    Formula E
  32. Patience key to Singapore success – Ricciardo 12:00

    Patience key to Singapore success – Ricciardo

    Red Bull driver Daniel Ricciardo believes that having patience in Singapore is key due to the manner in which the Marina Bay...

    F1
  33. Video: Dramatic end to Formula E opener 10:31

    Video: Dramatic end to Formula E opener

    Nicolas Prost sends Nick Heidfeld into a violent collision with the fence after the duo make contact while battling for the...

    Formula E
  34. Di Grassi wins first ePrix after final corner crash 10:10

    Di Grassi wins first ePrix after final corner crash

    Lucas di Grassi claimed victory after an incredible final lap in the first ever ePrix around the streets of Beijing, with...

    Formula E
  35. Iannone heads Dovizioso in Misano practice 09:47

    Iannone heads Dovizioso in Misano practice

    Andrea Iannone set the fastest time during the third practice session for the San Marino Grand Prix at Misano. Iannone...

    MotoGP
  36. Pat Symonds on the Williams revival 09:30

    Pat Symonds on the Williams revival

    Under the technical guidance of Pat Symonds, Williams has returned to the sharp-end of the grid this season. GPUpdate.net...

    F1
  37. FIA to review Super Licence qualifications 07:00

    FIA to review Super Licence qualifications

    The FIA is to review the process by which a driver qualifies for a Super Licence after questions were raised in the wake of...

    F1
  38. Video of the Day: Ricciardo vs Kvyat on two wheels 05:00

    Video of the Day: Ricciardo vs Kvyat on two wheels

    Red Bull driver Daniel Ricciardo and Toro Rosso's Daniil Kvyat go head-to-head on two wheels.

    F1
  39. Friday 12 September 2014

  40. 17:18

    Latest MotoGP photos: Friday at Misano

    MotoGP
  41. Palmer optimistic over 2015 F1 chances 15:52

    Palmer optimistic over 2015 F1 chances

    GP2 championship leader Jolyon Palmer says he is "optimistic" that he will be on the Formula 1 grid in 2015. Palmer, 23,...

    F1
  42. Grosjean sure of improved Lotus showing 15:39

    Grosjean sure of improved Lotus showing

    Romain Grosjean is sure that Lotus will fare better at next weekend's Singapore Grand Prix after the team endured a trying...

    F1
  43. Pic completes Formula E line-up 15:13

    Pic completes Formula E line-up

    Andretti Formula E has confirmed that Lotus reserve driver Charles Pic will race for them at Saturday's inaugural ePrix in...

    Formula E
  44. Dovizioso recovers from crash to set pace 13:58

    Dovizioso recovers from crash to set pace

    Andrea Dovizioso set the fastest time for Ducati in wet conditions during second practice for the San Marino Grand Prix at...

    MotoGP
more news