Opinion: F1 needs to be boring in order to thrill

Opinion: F1 needs to be boring in order to thrill

20 June 2014 – "The show has not been good enough at some races this year and with one team dominating, the spectators want more excitement."

Those are the words of Fernando Alonso with regards to the 2014 Formula 1 season. There's an assumption that Formula 1's fans are underwhelmed with the spectacle provided by the new regulations and a concern that Mercedes's dominance is causing people to switch off the television.

It's true – to an extent. Television audiences have been dwindling in the sport, although that's partly down to its baffling reluctance to properly embrace new media and its transition to pay-per-view in the unending quest for more money. If fewer people are able to watch the programme, of course audience figures will drop…

The sport faces several other issues – none more so pressing than the financial problems being encountered by a worrying amount of teams – but 'the show' is not one of them.

The boom of social media and the reportage of every tiny piece of information mean that Formula 1 is in the news 24/7. Every minute of every practice session is shown. No stone is unturned. Coverage now in leading nations is brilliant, but it also has the down side that it is far easier to criticise less interesting events. You'll hear talk of how races have been 'underwhelming' or 'failed to live up to expectation' – part of this is down to people hyping up every single event as if it's the best thing in the history of the world, rather than just another round in a championship approaching its 1000th event.

This season, there have been a couple of outstanding races – in Bahrain and Canada – while Monaco was also an exciting race. Some have had some moments of intrigue and suspense, especially if you know where to look, while a couple featured little engaging action. Rose-tinted glasses lead people to believe that past seasons featured non-stop swashbuckling racing in every event, which was far from the case. Certain periods of history rightly have iconic status, but there were some races in which very little happened.

But that's not a problem. In fact, it's rather a good thing.

There's a false assumption that Formula 1 must be consistently engaging – it's just not possible. No sport is exciting all of the time. People remember the epic Tennis matches between top players, but for every one there are several straightforward games. For every controversial 4-3 football match, there's a draw with a couple of wayward shots on goal.

But those less interesting events only serve to make the properly exciting ones even better. It's just the way sport works and to change it in favour of artificial non-stop action (a direction in which Formula 1 has teetered towards across the last few years) would be completely wrong. Such as the proposal, set to be approved by the World Motor Sport Council, for standing restarts after Safety Car periods rather than the current rolling restart. It's a ridiculous concept that reeks of a sport ignoring its prevalent problems and proposing answers for questions no-one asked. Such as double points. Football doesn't propose wider goals after 0-0 results, so why does Formula 1 consistently propose ludicrous ideas to 'spice up the show'?

Besides, the most vocal criticism of Formula 1 this season has come from a leading team whose glory days are becoming increasingly distant, with little hope of improvement in the short-term. The leading team, Mercedes, hasn't been complaining. It's up to everyone else to aspire to their sort of dominance, rather than criticise the regulations that have led to it.

Spicing up the 'show' solely in the pursuit of entertainment is synthetic and the antithesis of what Formula 1 is about.

Phillip Horton
Twitter: @PHortonF1


Do you agree? Join in the discussion via our interactive Facebook panel below...

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Wednesday 27 May 2015

  2. 17:32

    Book F1 tickets and join the action live!

    F1
  3. Hinchcliffe released from hospital 16:48

    Hinchcliffe released from hospital

    James Hinchcliffe was released from hospital on Tuesday, following surgery for the injuries he sustained during practice for the…

    Indy
  4. Wilson to make FE debut in Moscow 15:33

    Wilson to make FE debut in Moscow

    Justin Wilson will make his Formula E debut with Andretti Autosport at next month's Moscow round. Wilson competed in last…

    FE
  5. Grosjean 'didn't brake test' Verstappen 14:39

    Grosjean 'didn't brake test' Verstappen

    Lotus says it has data to prove that Romain Grosjean did not brake test Toro Rosso rival Max Verstappen prior to their collision…

    F1
  6. Video: Nico Rosberg's Monaco blog 14:16

    Video: Nico Rosberg's Monaco blog

    Nico Rosberg reflects on a dramatic Monaco Grand Prix that yielded his third straight win in the principality.

    F1
  7. Mallya targets constant points with new car 12:28

    Mallya targets constant points with new car

    Force India team boss Vijay Mallya has set his sights on recording constant points finishes when the outfit's full 2015…

    F1
  8. Verstappen vows to come back stronger 10:51

    Verstappen vows to come back stronger

    Toro Rosso rookie Max Verstappen says he will emerge a stronger driver from his dramatic accident at last weekend's Monaco Grand…

    F1
  9. Rossi in 'perfect' place for Mugello 10:35

    Rossi in 'perfect' place for Mugello

    MotoGP championship leader Valentino Rossi says he arrives at Mugello in a "perfect" frame of mind after his strong start to the…

    MotoGP
  10. 10:15

    Gallery: Best photos from the Monaco GP

    F1
  11. Häkkinen: Verstappen penalty unfair 10:12

    Häkkinen: Verstappen penalty unfair

    Mika Häkkinen believes that it was wrong of the stewards to hand Max Verstappen a grid penalty for his clash with Romain…

    F1
  12. Ecclestone: Rosberg, Vettel 'bad for business' 09:43

    Ecclestone: Rosberg, Vettel 'bad for business'

    Formula 1 supremo Bernie Ecclestone has said that German drivers Nico Rosberg and Sebastian Vettel are "not so good" for the…

    F1
  13. Feature: Monaco GP's key questions 09:27

    Feature: Monaco GP's key questions

    In the build up to last weekend's Monaco Grand Prix, GPUpdate.net posed five key questions and contemplated the potential…

    F1
  14. Video of the Day: Berlin ePrix highlights 05:00

    Video of the Day: Berlin ePrix highlights

    Watch highlights from the eighth round of the Formula E championship at Berlin's Tempelhof Airport.

    FE
  15. Tuesday 26 May 2015

  16. Scan reveals further Iannone injury 19:11

    Scan reveals further Iannone injury

    Ducati's Andrea Iannone has had another set back ahead of his home race in Italy this weekend after a scan revealed a further…

    MotoGP
  17. Daly to replace Hinchcliffe for Detroit 14:18

    Daly to replace Hinchcliffe for Detroit

    Conor Daly will remain in IndyCar after Schmidt Peterson Motorsports confirmed that he will replace the injured James…

    Indy
  18. Briatore: Alonso better off at McLaren 13:31

    Briatore: Alonso better off at McLaren

    Flavio Briatore says Fernando Alonso is better placed at McLaren compared to Ferrari, despite the Spaniard having failed to…

    F1
  19. No further action in de Villota accident 11:29

    No further action in de Villota accident

    Manor Grand Prix Racing will face no further action over the testing crash involving Maria de Villota following the conclusion…

    F1
  20. Williams cannot repeat Monaco - Smedley 11:08

    Williams cannot repeat Monaco - Smedley

    Williams Head of Performance Engineering Rob Smedley says the squad must examine where it went wrong at the Monaco Grand Prix in…

    F1
  21. Arrivabene: Ferrari outsmarted Mercedes 09:49

    Arrivabene: Ferrari outsmarted Mercedes

    Ferrari Team Principal Maurizio Arrivabene says the squad outsmarted Mercedes strategically in order to collect second position…

    F1
  22. Monaco Grand Prix: Winners and Losers 08:56

    Monaco Grand Prix: Winners and Losers

    Nico Rosberg took a third straight Monaco win as dominant Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton was skewered by an incorrect pit…

    F1
  23. Video of the Day: Red Bull's Energy Station 05:23

    Video of the Day: Red Bull's Energy Station

    Find out more about Red Bull's floating Energy Station, which it brought to the Monaco Grand Prix.

    F1
  24. Monday 25 May 2015

  25. Montoya: First Indy 500 win was easier 15:45

    Montoya: First Indy 500 win was easier

    Juan Pablo Montoya described his first Indianapolis 500 win as "easy" compared to his victory at the 99th running of the…

    Indy
  26. Video: Max drives Jos around Monaco 14:27

    Video: Max drives Jos around Monaco

    Watch as Max Verstappen takes father Jos for a lap of the Monaco Grand Prix circuit in a Renault Clio.

    F1
  27. Smith, Espargaró set for Suzuka 8 Hours 13:42

    Smith, Espargaró set for Suzuka 8 Hours

    MotoGP team-mates Bradley Smith and Pol Espargaró will form part of the rider line-up for the factory Yamaha team at this…

    MotoGP
  28. Rosberg still thought Hamilton would win 11:52

    Rosberg still thought Hamilton would win

    Nico Rosberg has explained that he still thought Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton would win the Monaco Grand Prix despite his…

    F1
  29. Massa hits out at 'dangerous' Verstappen 10:21

    Massa hits out at 'dangerous' Verstappen

    Williams driver Felipe Massa has criticised Max Verstappen following the Toro Rosso rookie's contact with Romain Grosjean, and…

    F1
  30. Kvyat buoyed by best Formula 1 finish 10:02

    Kvyat buoyed by best Formula 1 finish

    Red Bull driver Daniil Kvyat expressed his delight after securing the best result of his short Formula 1 career at the Monaco…

    F1
  31. Video: Ricciardo, Räikkönen make contact 09:42

    Video: Ricciardo, Räikkönen make contact

    Daniel Ricciardo barged past Kimi Räikkönen for fifth with this move late in the Monaco Grand Prix.

    F1
  32. Räikkönen expected Ricciardo penalty 09:36

    Räikkönen expected Ricciardo penalty

    Kimi Räikkönen says he expected Daniel Ricciardo to be penalised by the stewards after their clash in the closing stages of…

    F1
  33. Pérez: Force India maximising opportunities 08:34

    Pérez: Force India maximising opportunities

    Sergio Pérez says his Force India team is maximising its opportunities after he started and finished in seventh position at the…

    F1
  34. Video of the Day: Prost on Renault's F1 plans 05:27

    Video of the Day: Prost on Renault's F1 plans

    Renault ambassador Alain Prost discusses the French brand's future intentions regarding Formula 1.

    F1
  35. 01:12

    Championship standings after Monaco

    F1
  36. Sunday 24 May 2015

  37. 21:54

    Latest IndyCar photos: 99th Indy 500

    Indy
  38. Montoya wins thrilling Indy 500 21:41

    Montoya wins thrilling Indy 500

    Juan Pablo Montoya has won the 99th running of the Indianapolis 500 in a back-and-forth battle with several cars, beating…

    Indy
  39. 18:02

    Latest F1 photos: Sunday in Monaco

    F1
  40. Button says points a 'hugely positive step' 17:40

    Button says points a 'hugely positive step'

    Jenson Button says scoring points in the Monaco Grand Prix marks a "hugely positive step" for the renewed McLaren-Honda…

    F1
  41. Renault 'going in the right direction' 17:30

    Renault 'going in the right direction'

    Renault believes that it is heading "in the right direction" after the brand recorded its best result of the season at the…

    F1
  42. Verstappen given five-place grid penalty 16:47

    Verstappen given five-place grid penalty

    Max Verstappen has been given a five-place grid penalty for the Canadian Grand Prix following his clash with Romain Grosjean in…

    F1
  43. 16:35

    Follow the 99th Indianapolis 500 live!

    Indy
more news