Opinion: F1 needs to be boring in order to thrill

Opinion: F1 needs to be boring in order to thrill

20 June 2014 – "The show has not been good enough at some races this year and with one team dominating, the spectators want more excitement."

Those are the words of Fernando Alonso with regards to the 2014 Formula 1 season. There's an assumption that Formula 1's fans are underwhelmed with the spectacle provided by the new regulations and a concern that Mercedes's dominance is causing people to switch off the television.

It's true – to an extent. Television audiences have been dwindling in the sport, although that's partly down to its baffling reluctance to properly embrace new media and its transition to pay-per-view in the unending quest for more money. If fewer people are able to watch the programme, of course audience figures will drop…

The sport faces several other issues – none more so pressing than the financial problems being encountered by a worrying amount of teams – but 'the show' is not one of them.

The boom of social media and the reportage of every tiny piece of information mean that Formula 1 is in the news 24/7. Every minute of every practice session is shown. No stone is unturned. Coverage now in leading nations is brilliant, but it also has the down side that it is far easier to criticise less interesting events. You'll hear talk of how races have been 'underwhelming' or 'failed to live up to expectation' – part of this is down to people hyping up every single event as if it's the best thing in the history of the world, rather than just another round in a championship approaching its 1000th event.

This season, there have been a couple of outstanding races – in Bahrain and Canada – while Monaco was also an exciting race. Some have had some moments of intrigue and suspense, especially if you know where to look, while a couple featured little engaging action. Rose-tinted glasses lead people to believe that past seasons featured non-stop swashbuckling racing in every event, which was far from the case. Certain periods of history rightly have iconic status, but there were some races in which very little happened.

But that's not a problem. In fact, it's rather a good thing.

There's a false assumption that Formula 1 must be consistently engaging – it's just not possible. No sport is exciting all of the time. People remember the epic Tennis matches between top players, but for every one there are several straightforward games. For every controversial 4-3 football match, there's a draw with a couple of wayward shots on goal.

But those less interesting events only serve to make the properly exciting ones even better. It's just the way sport works and to change it in favour of artificial non-stop action (a direction in which Formula 1 has teetered towards across the last few years) would be completely wrong. Such as the proposal, set to be approved by the World Motor Sport Council, for standing restarts after Safety Car periods rather than the current rolling restart. It's a ridiculous concept that reeks of a sport ignoring its prevalent problems and proposing answers for questions no-one asked. Such as double points. Football doesn't propose wider goals after 0-0 results, so why does Formula 1 consistently propose ludicrous ideas to 'spice up the show'?

Besides, the most vocal criticism of Formula 1 this season has come from a leading team whose glory days are becoming increasingly distant, with little hope of improvement in the short-term. The leading team, Mercedes, hasn't been complaining. It's up to everyone else to aspire to their sort of dominance, rather than criticise the regulations that have led to it.

Spicing up the 'show' solely in the pursuit of entertainment is synthetic and the antithesis of what Formula 1 is about.

Phillip Horton
Twitter: @PHortonF1


Do you agree? Join in the discussion via our interactive Facebook panel below...

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Thursday 27 April 2017

  2. 17:12

    Follow GPUpdate on Instagram in 2017!

    F1
  3. Rins out for 'six to eight weeks' after surgery 16:07

    Rins out for 'six to eight weeks' after surgery

    Suzuki rider Álex Rins has undergone successful surgery in Barcelona following a heavy accident during practice for the Grand…

    MotoGP
  4. 15:22

    Latest Formula 1 photos: Thursday at Sochi

    F1
  5. Video: Ferrari's Russian GP preview 15:02

    Video: Ferrari's Russian GP preview

    Ferrari looks ahead to this weekend's Russian Grand Prix by analysing the challenges of the Sochi Autodrom.

    F1
  6. Bottas not worried about team orders 14:43

    Bottas not worried about team orders

    Valtteri Bottas says he is not worried about Mercedes imposing any team orders, expressing confidence that "all of my good…

    F1
  7. Drivers offer mixed views over 'shield' 14:11

    Drivers offer mixed views over 'shield'

    Formula 1 drivers have offered mixed views over the 'shield' head protection device that could be introduced from the 2018…

    F1
  8. Haas moves to Carbon Industrie brakes 13:41

    Haas moves to Carbon Industrie brakes

    Haas will run with Carbon Industrie brake products from this weekend's Russian Grand Prix at Sochi Autodrom, following a…

    F1
  9. In photos: Russian GP from 2014-16 11:23

    In photos: Russian GP from 2014-16

    Sochi Autodrom, situated in and around the Olympic Park, will host the fourth Russian Grand Prix this weekend. GPUpdate.net…

    F1
  10. Speed bumps added to Turn 2 at Sochi 09:18

    Speed bumps added to Turn 2 at Sochi

    Speed bumps have been added to Sochi Autodrom's Turn 2 ahead of this year's Russian Grand Prix, in a bid to stop drivers from…

    F1
  11. Video: What's on Robin Frijns' phone? 09:02

    Video: What's on Robin Frijns' phone?

    Find out what's on Robin Frijns' phone, including photos of an epic karting battle with Stoffel Vandoorne.

    FE
  12. Lowe expects 'strong' Williams in Russia 08:45

    Lowe expects 'strong' Williams in Russia

    Williams Chief Technical Officer Paddy Lowe says he expects a "strong" performance from Williams at this weekend's Russian Grand…

    F1
  13. Video of the Day: Sergio Pérez on Sochi 05:38

    Video of the Day: Sergio Pérez on Sochi

    Force India driver Sergio Pérez talks through a lap of the Sochi Autodrom, home of the Russian Grand Prix, where he secured a…

    F1
  14. Wednesday 26 April 2017

  15. Pagenaud hails 'courageous' Alonso over Indy 15:48

    Pagenaud hails 'courageous' Alonso over Indy

    Reigning IndyCar champion Simon Pagenaud thinks Fernando Alonso's decision to compete at this year's Indianapolis 500 is…

    Indy
  16. Suzuki: COTA result crucial for development 14:18

    Suzuki: COTA result crucial for development

    Suzuki Team Manager Davide Brivio says Andrea Iannone's performance at the Circuit of the Americas will be "crucial" for the…

    MotoGP
  17. Hülkenberg hopeful over Renault race pace 11:27

    Hülkenberg hopeful over Renault race pace

    Renault's Nico Hülkenberg is hopeful that the team will be able to demonstrate improved race pace in Russia this weekend…

    F1
  18. Video: Onboard lap of Sochi Autodrom 10:22

    Video: Onboard lap of Sochi Autodrom

    Ahead of this weekend's Russian Grand Prix, ride onboard for a lap of the 5.8km Sochi Autodrom circuit.

    F1
  19. Wolff encouraged by progress of juniors 09:34

    Wolff encouraged by progress of juniors

    Mercedes boss Toto Wolff has praised the progress made by youngsters Pascal Wehrlein and Esteban Ocon in Formula 1 this season…

    F1
  20. Monger thanks supporters after accident 08:41

    Monger thanks supporters after accident

    Billy Monger has expressed gratitude for the "awesome and truly inspirational" support he has received in the wake of his…

    Misc
  21. Hildebrand to make return at Phoenix 08:24

    Hildebrand to make return at Phoenix

    J. R. Hildebrand will return to IndyCar at Phoenix this weekend, having sat out the preceding event at Barber through…

    Indy
  22. Preview: F1 field faces Olympic challenge 07:32

    Preview: F1 field faces Olympic challenge

    Formula 1 moves on to Sochi Autodrom for the fourth round of the season, where another Ferrari/Mercedes battle is anticipated.…

    F1
  23. Video of the Day: GP of Alabama cutdown 05:37

    Video of the Day: GP of Alabama cutdown

    Watch extended highlights of last weekend's Grand Prix of Alabama at the Barber Motorsports Park.

    Indy
  24. Tuesday 25 April 2017

  25. F1 to focus on 'shield' system for 2018 20:13

    F1 to focus on 'shield' system for 2018

    Formula 1 is to favour a 'shield' head protection device for the 2018 season, rather than the previously proposed 'halo' system…

    F1
  26. Pérez: Force India has taken opportunities 15:47

    Pérez: Force India has taken opportunities

    Sergio Pérez has praised Force India for taking its chances in the early rounds of the 2017 season, enough to put the team at…

    F1
  27. Sirotkin to get practice run in Russia 14:15

    Sirotkin to get practice run in Russia

    Renault reserve driver Sergey Sirotkin will make his first practice outing of the season at his home Grand Prix in Russia, the…

    F1
  28. Pirelli expecting one-stop Russian GP 13:30

    Pirelli expecting one-stop Russian GP

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli is expecting this weekend's Russian Grand Prix to be a one-stop race, given the "low-severity…

    F1
  29. Video: Michelin's all-weather FE tyres 12:04

    Video: Michelin's all-weather FE tyres

    Formula E provides an insight into the technology behind Michelin's all-weather tyres.

    FE
  30. Lorenzo: Front tyre graining hid step 11:12

    Lorenzo: Front tyre graining hid step

    Ducati's Jorge Lorenzo is adamant that he made another "step forward" at the Grand Prix of the Americas, pinning his late slump…

    MotoGP
  31. Newgarden hails 'fluid' Penske integration 09:53

    Newgarden hails 'fluid' Penske integration

    Josef Newgarden has praised Penske for its efforts to help him integrate over the off-season, after he claimed his first victory…

    Indy
  32. Video: Alonso's Alabama IndyCar visit 09:03

    Video: Alonso's Alabama IndyCar visit

    Follow Fernando Alonso as he tours the IndyCar paddock at the Barber Motorsports Park.

    F1
  33. Alonso targets two-car McLaren finish 07:32

    Alonso targets two-car McLaren finish

    Fernando Alonso hopes that McLaren-Honda will be able to record a two-car finish at this weekend's Russian Grand Prix, after a…

    F1
  34. Video of the Day: Kvyat 360° Sochi lap 05:36

    Video of the Day: Kvyat 360° Sochi lap

    Toro Rosso's Daniil Kvyat takes you on a virtual 360° lap of Sochi Autodrom ahead of the Russian GP.

    F1
  35. Monday 24 April 2017

  36. Video: Alonso press conference at Barber 16:04

    Video: Alonso press conference at Barber

    Watch as Fernando Alonso fields questions about his upcoming attempt at the Indianapolis 500.

    F1
  37. In photos: Alonso visits IndyCar paddock 12:35

    In photos: Alonso visits IndyCar paddock

    Fernando Alonso attended last weekend's Grand Prix of Alabama as part of his preparations for an assault on the Indianapolis 500…

    F1
  38. Video: Performing a perfect FE pit-stop 12:02

    Video: Performing a perfect FE pit-stop

    Venturi driver Maro Engel talks through the key elements to pull off a perfect Formula E pit-stop.

    FE
  39. Viñales vows to return 'stronger' after crash 11:12

    Viñales vows to return 'stronger' after crash

    Maverick Viñales says he will quickly put his crash at the Grand Prix of the Americas to the back of his mind and return…

    MotoGP
  40. Venturi calls up Dillmann for Paris ePrix 10:20

    Venturi calls up Dillmann for Paris ePrix

    Tom Dillmann will make his Formula E debut with Venturi in next month's Paris ePrix. Dillmann, who won the Formula V8 3.5…

    FE
  41. Rossi's 2017 title lead 'a great surprise' 10:02

    Rossi's 2017 title lead 'a great surprise'

    Valentino Rossi says it comes as "a great surprise" to himself and Yamaha that he leads the MotoGP title race after the first…

    MotoGP
  42. Video: IndyCar GP of Alabama highlights 09:32

    Video: IndyCar GP of Alabama highlights

    Watch highlights of Sunday's IndyCar Grand Prix of Alabama at the Barber Motorsports Park.

    Indy
  43. Márquez 'back' in title race with Austin win 09:16

    Márquez 'back' in title race with Austin win

    Repsol Honda rider Marc Márquez says he is "back in the championship" fight after his victory at the Grand Prix of the Americas…

    MotoGP
  44. Video of the Day: Prema's 'Guess the song' 05:24

    Video of the Day: Prema's 'Guess the song'

    Prema Formula 2 drivers Charles Leclerc and Antonio Fuoco, along with Formula 4 pair Juri Vips and Juan Manuel Correa, challenge…

    F2
more news