Technical: Formula 1's impending FRIC ban

Technical: Formula 1's impending FRIC ban

10 July 2014 – A shadow of uncertainty has been cast over the Formula 1 field ahead of next weekend's German Grand Prix, with governing body the FIA clamping down on the use of FRIC suspension systems. GPUpdate.net technical guru Matt Somerfield overviews the life of the concept and looks at the implications of the ban.

After the British Grand Prix, the FIA and more specifically Charlie Whiting issued a technical directive to the teams concerning the use of 'FRIC' suspensions going forward, with an imminent ban looming as close as the German Grand Prix. Only a unanimous agreement by the teams will see the decision staved off until 2015.

For those uninitiated in front-to-rear-interconnected suspension, its use is not exclusive to Formula 1 and it is something that has been prevalent in the sport for many years (decades even). The first examples pre-date even that of 'active' suspension used in the early 90s, most effectively by Williams. This is an important crossroads as FRIC or interconnected suspensions are passive and must not be confused with their active cousin. Active was an assisted system that relied on onboard computer systems and electronic actuators, whereas interconnected suspensions and more recently FRIC are passive using the standard hydraulic system (albeit with hydraulic elements replacing the standard heave elements) alongside accumulators to match the effect seen at both ends of the car. 



FRIC therefore controls a cars' pitch and roll (pitch is most prevalent under braking and acceleration, whilst roll is most prevalent when invoking a change in direction), making the car both mechanically more compliant but also creating a more consistent aerodynamic platform. The movement of hydraulic fluid front to rear (and vice versa) allows the designers to run the car at a consistent baseline and in more of an aggressive stance (rake) which creates consistent and more downforce than if the systems weren't employed.

This control of pitch and roll also has its benefits in terms of tyre wear with both being tuned to allow the drivers and engineers a more expansive operating window, making the tyres conducive to more or less heat and therefore wear, dependant on the prevailing track and weather conditions.

So if they have been around for such a long time, it begs the question 'Why now?' The directive explains more.

"Having now seen and studied nearly every current design of front-to-rear linked suspension system, as well as reviewing future developments some teams have shared with us, we are firmly of the view that the legality of all such systems could be called into question, particularly with respect to compliance with Article 3.15 of the F1 Technical Regulations," the directive reads.

"As these systems, in one form or another, have been in use for some time we are inclined to permit their continued use for the remainder of the current season, however, we feel we would need the agreement of all participating teams to take this approach. We would therefore be very grateful if you could indicate whether you may be in a position to agree with such an approach.

"Failing this, we would have to consider making a report to the stewards about the non-compliance of any car fitted with a system which appears to allow the response of the suspension at either or both of the rear corners to drive the response of the suspension at either or both of the front corners (or vice versa)."

Reading through the directive, we must remember that these are not regulatory. This is a forewarning by Whiting that the FIA will no longer stand for a breach of the regulations that has been maturing over the last few years. 

Just because everyone is cheating, it doesn't make it right.  

It is a shot across the bows, designed to make the teams aware that for 2015 this practice will cease to be legal, especially with the changes made by the FIA in 2015's regulations and ratified by the World Motor Sport Council (WMSC) a few weeks ago pertaining to the skids and plank. These changes will make it difficult to run with such an aggressive rake, due to the now mandated material of Titanium for the skids (whereas most teams have been using Tungsten over the last few years as it wears less). If the topic of FRIC was left alone the teams would make concerted efforts in this area to overcome the changes made to the skids for 2015, nullifying their effect. This change is being introduced to force the teams to run with less rake and to further rob them of downforce, creating a car more focused on mechanical grip, an objective of the new regulations (2014/15).

A wholesale change of this magnitude mid-season is frankly not possible, some of the teams' solutions can't simply be deactivated and replaced with conventional suspension elements. Although not as dangerous as when the FIA cut off active suspension development, a sudden loss of these systems could have huge aerodynamic implications, with cars designed around the suspension's consistent platform failing to create the correct forces and worst of all flow detachment in critical areas of the track causing mass instability.

The teams that have the least mature solutions would of course benefit if they didn't agree to the continued use of FRIC but performance will be relative. Those with the money and resources are most likely to excel under new conditions too. Lotus nee Renualt was the first to re-develop this technology during the last ruleset (2009-2013). But that's not to say they have the best version, with Mercedes' iteration seemingly the most advanced of the current grid. Even Marussia's stride toward the midfield is owed in part to their adoption of a FRIC suspension.

It remains to be seen if the teams will unanimously agree to keep it in place for the rest of the campaign.

Stay tuned to GPUpdate.net for further technical features throughout the 2014 Formula 1 season

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Saturday 23 July 2016

  2. Rosberg keeps pole after investigation 19:38

    Rosberg keeps pole after investigation

    Mercedes driver Nico Rosberg has kept his pole position at the Hungarian Grand Prix after Stewards determined that no further…

    F1
  3. Nissany collects first victory despite collision 19:31

    Nissany collects first victory despite collision

    Lotus driver Roy Nissany took his first Formula V8 3.5 victory despite colliding with rival Egor Orudzhev during the first race…

    FV8 3.5
  4. Parry bags first win as De Vries stalls 17:50

    Parry bags first win as De Vries stalls

    Koiranen's Matt Parry claimed his maiden victory in the GP3 Series after pole sitter Nyck de Vries stalled on the dummy grid at…

    GP3
  5. Gasly takes another win in Prema 1-2 16:42

    Gasly takes another win in Prema 1-2

    Red Bull youngster Pierre Gasly moved into the lead of the GP2 Series standings as he claimed his second victory in as many…

    GP2
  6. 16:37

    Latest F1 photos: Saturday at Hungaroring

    F1
  7. Sainz Jr. says sixth 'came from nowhere' 16:36

    Sainz Jr. says sixth 'came from nowhere'

    Carlos Sainz Jr. says his sixth-place starting position for the Hungarian Grand Prix "came from nowhere" after a low-key final…

    F1
  8. Vettel: 'Sleeping' Button cost me top-three 16:19

    Vettel: 'Sleeping' Button cost me top-three

    Sebastian Vettel feels that a "sleeping" Jenson Button cost him a potential top-three starting position for the Hungarian Grand…

    F1
  9. Ricciardo felt 'angry' after yellow flags 16:11

    Ricciardo felt 'angry' after yellow flags

    Daniel Ricciardo says he felt "angry" inside his cockpit after late yellow flags scuppered his final Hungarian Grand Prix…

    F1
  10. Rosberg expects to keep Hungary pole 15:48

    Rosberg expects to keep Hungary pole

    Nico Rosberg expects to keep pole position for the Hungarian Grand Prix, despite suggestions that he drove too fast under yellow…

    F1
  11. 15:04

    Hungarian Grand Prix: Qualifying results

    F1
  12. Rosberg snatches pole in eventful qualifying 15:02

    Rosberg snatches pole in eventful qualifying

    Nico Rosberg snatched pole position for the Hungarian Grand Prix from Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton amid late yellow flags…

    F1
  13. 12:46

    Follow qualifying for the Hungarian GP!

    F1
  14. FIA warns of drive-through over track limits 11:11

    FIA warns of drive-through over track limits

    Formula 1 Race Director Charlie Whiting has warned that drivers are likely to receive drive-through penalties if they repeatedly…

    F1
  15. 11:04

    Hungarian Grand Prix: Full Practice 3 results

    F1
  16. Rosberg tops FP3, Red Bull splits Mercedes 11:03

    Rosberg tops FP3, Red Bull splits Mercedes

    Nico Rosberg edged out Max Verstappen by two thousandths of a second during Saturday morning's final free practice session for…

    F1
  17. 09:52

    Follow final practice for the Hungarian GP!

    F1
  18. De Vries takes stunning maiden GP3 pole 09:27

    De Vries takes stunning maiden GP3 pole

    McLaren young driver Nyck de Vries secured his maiden GP3 pole position with a stunning last-gasp effort during qualifying at…

    GP3
  19. Haas: No driver decision until after Monza 08:20

    Haas: No driver decision until after Monza

    Haas Team Principal Guenther Steiner says the squad will not make a decision on its 2017 driver line-up until after the European…

    F1
  20. Video of the Day: Newgarden quizzed 05:26

    Video of the Day: Newgarden quizzed

    IndyCar quizzes Josef Newgarden on his knowledge of the series and his own motor racing career.

    Indy
  21. Friday 22 July 2016

  22. 17:02

    Latest F1 photos: Friday at Hungaroring

    F1
  23. Recurring fuel issue hampers Palmer 16:45

    Recurring fuel issue hampers Palmer

    Renault driver Jolyon Palmer was left to rue a recurring fuel system issue which restricted his running during Friday's practice…

    F1
  24. Vettel: Mercedes' advantage no surprise 16:44

    Vettel: Mercedes' advantage no surprise

    Sebastian Vettel says Mercedes' advantage over the field during Friday practice at the Hungarian Grand Prix came as no surprise…

    F1
  25. Bottas, Sainz Jr. reprimanded over pit entry 16:19

    Bottas, Sainz Jr. reprimanded over pit entry

    Valtteri Bottas and Carlos Sainz Jr. have been reprimanded by the Hungarian Grand Prix stewards for pit entry violations during…

    F1
  26. Rosberg lauds 'impressive' opening day 15:43

    Rosberg lauds 'impressive' opening day

    Nico Rosberg hailed an "impressive" Mercedes performance during Friday practice at the Hungaroring as the team dominated the…

    F1
  27. 15:34

    Latest GP2 photos: Friday at Hungaroring

    GP2
  28. Gasly flies to GP2 pole position in Hungary 15:32

    Gasly flies to GP2 pole position in Hungary

    Red Bull junior driver Pierre Gasly set three lap times quick enough for pole position as he dominated GP2 qualifying at the…

    GP2
  29. Hamilton apologises to Mercedes for shunt 15:22

    Hamilton apologises to Mercedes for shunt

    Lewis Hamilton has apologised to Mercedes after his accident during Friday's second practice session for the Hungarian Grand…

    F1
  30. Ricciardo sure Red Bull is second best 15:05

    Ricciardo sure Red Bull is second best

    Daniel Ricciardo says he and Red Bull are "where we expected to be" after finishing second to Mercedes during Friday practice in…

    F1
  31. 14:34

    Hungarian Grand Prix: Full Practice 2 results

    F1
  32. Rosberg fastest in FP2 as Hamilton crashes 14:33

    Rosberg fastest in FP2 as Hamilton crashes

    Nico Rosberg set the pace during Friday afternoon's second free practice session for the Hungarian Grand Prix, again comfortably…

    F1
  33. Hamilton checked over after FP2 crash 13:42

    Hamilton checked over after FP2 crash

    Lewis Hamilton was checked over at the Hungaroring medical centre following his crash in Friday afternoon's second practice…

    F1
  34. 12:52

    Follow second practice for the Hungarian GP!

    F1
  35. Formula V8 3.5 grid reduced to 13 drivers 12:39

    Formula V8 3.5 grid reduced to 13 drivers

    Absentees mean that the Formula V8 3.5 grid has been reduced to just 13 drivers for the British round of the championship at…

    FV8 3.5
  36. Leclerc feels he could handle GP3/F1 step 11:58

    Leclerc feels he could handle GP3/F1 step

    Ferrari youngster Charles Leclerc says he would feel ready to make the step up from the GP3 Series to Formula 1 for 2017 if such…

    F1
  37. Video: Nico Rosberg/Toto Wolff on new deal 11:02

    Video: Nico Rosberg/Toto Wolff on new deal

    Nico Rosberg and Toto Wolff comment on the German's two-year contract extension with Mercedes.

    F1
  38. Mercedes sees Rosberg as the 'real deal' 10:55

    Mercedes sees Rosberg as the 'real deal'

    Toto Wolff has described Nico Rosberg as the "real deal" after the German signed a contract extension, tying him to Mercedes…

    F1
  39. 10:36

    Hungarian Grand Prix: Full Practice 1 results

    F1
  40. Hamilton leads Rosberg in first practice 10:35

    Hamilton leads Rosberg in first practice

    Lewis Hamilton edged out team-mate Nico Rosberg during Friday's first free practice session for the Hungarian Grand Prix, which…

    F1
  41. 08:52

    Follow first practice for the Hungarian GP

    F1
  42. Rosberg signs two-year contract extension 08:18

    Rosberg signs two-year contract extension

    Nico Rosberg has signed a new two-year contract extension at Mercedes, after a drawn-out negotiation process, taking him through…

    F1
more news