Reaction: Formula 1 drivers on halo device

Reaction: Formula 1 drivers on halo device

27 July 2017 – Formula 1 drivers were quizzed about the planned introduction of the halo head protection device for the 2018 season during media day at the Hungarian Grand Prix. Following early comments made by Grand Prix Drivers' Association Director Romain Grosjean, GPUpdate.net has gathered a selection of other opinions.

For the halo

Sebastian Vettel:
"The halo test I did was last year in Abu Dhabi, and for sure you need to get used to it, but at least it didn't impact on vision. Obviously there's been a lot of talk as I got it. Overall you need to understand that it's a decision that helps us in car in case something goes very wrong. For sure if you look at Formula 1, the way Formula 1 cars look and so on, I can understand if people say that it doesn't belong on a Formula 1 car. On the other hand, I think times are changing, you are moving forward. If you offer the system as it stands, with the power it has to give us additional protection… offer that to Justin Wilson, sometime ago, then I think he would take it, and we would all be happy to take it, to help save his life. We can't turn back clock, but knowing that something is there that helps us in certain situations, it would be ignorant and stupid to ignore. Overall it's supposed to help us, so that's what we need to remember. With aesthetics, it's always difficult to please everybody, but I think the halo system we saw last year will probably not be the one we see next year, the year after. It's one of those things where maybe they start off not so good looking and actually they're not so bad."

Fernando Alonso:
"I think first is the safety. If this device can help in many of the fatal accidents that we had in the last 10-15 years, we are all happy to implement the device. If we could go back in time and save lives we would all be happy, so that's the first and only thing that we should talk [about]. With the aesthetics, I don't care too much, to be honest. Formula 1 has changed a lot. From my first year in 2001 to now, the cars are very different; the height of the front nose, the height of the cockpit to protect the helmet area. 40 or 50 years ago they didn't have seatbelts and when seatbelts were implemented there was not any debate. For me there is no question. I'm happy to implement any head protection, extra head protection for next year. If the FIA studied and developed the halo, and this is the most effective way to protect the head of the drivers, this is more than welcome, in my opinion."

Sergio Pérez:
"I'm in favour of it. Safety always comes first. If we had the halo now, probably over the last six or seven years it would have saved at least a life. I think once we implement the halo the teams will improve it. It needs a lot of work, but I think that it will be improved a lot. We have very clever engineers in Formula 1 and now that all the teams know that it will be in place next year I believe that they will improve it a lot."

Marcus Ericsson:
"I think it's positive. Safety should be prioritised. I think the FIA has done a good job to really look into this. If this is the best solution at the moment then I think it's a no-brainer to go for it for next year. If it could save someone in the future I think it's great. I tested it last year and I didn't really notice it at all, so that's a good thing that it's not going to change anything when you drive, you'll have the same feeling. It maybe doesn't look the prettiest, but I think it's something we'll get used to. Always when there are big changes in F1 it doesn't look so pretty at first, but then people get used to it, and I think it's going to be the same thing with the halo."

Against the halo

Max Verstappen:
"I don't like it. Of course, at the end of the day, you have to respect the decision of the FIA, but I think since we introduced the Virtual Safety Car, that reduced a lot of risk when you are speeding under yellows flags in the race. Also, the wheel tethers are quite strong at the moment, so I don't think you will lose a wheel very easily. And when there are parts flying around it's not really going to protect you, so I don't really understand why we should need it."

Kevin Magnussen:
"I'm against it. I don't think it's what Formula 1 is about. I think there should be... a more clever way to improve the safety. I don't think the halo is the right way. In general, I don't agree that safety always is number one, I think there is a limit where it comes too safe to be exciting. I think part of the reason Formula 1 is popular because of the element of danger. I think it's moved on huge amounts in the last 30 years, and that's been very good, but I think it's safe enough now that it's exciting and it feels right to go racing. We could always make it more safe, we could make the cars go a maximum of 80km/h, but it would be very boring. You can always make it safer, but you will make it less exciting."

Nico Hülkenberg:
"I'm still going to race, I won't retire! But I was never a big supporter of the halo or the additional head protection and I'm still not. It's not my decision, it's the FIA making the safety rules and requirements. It's that element of aesthetics, the looks, it doesn't look pretty, for sure. It will protect [against] something... a freak accident, one out of a million. But we have security and the protection of the cars is getting better. These tethers that keep the tyres get better and better, so there's less chance of a tyre and heavy things flying around. I'm not sure that this additional protection is necessary, because all the other areas keep improving and we will compromise the looks quite a lot."

Jolyon Palmer:
"I think it's a mistake. There's no coming back from it sadly; this will be the end of F1 as we know it with an open cockpit. It's an overreaction to problems in other series. Since 1994 there's been one [driver] fatality, which is tragic, but the halo wouldn't have stopped it, so the halo would have stopped no death in F1 in 23 years. Because of an IndyCar incident, F2 incident, different tracks, different safety measures, we're introducing something that changes the whole tradition and history of it. I think it's the wrong move."

Neutral views

Esteban Ocon:
"All the drivers were in favour of the halo, or not the halo, but the solution to bring safety, and in that aspect we can't complain now that we have something for more safety. For sure, it's not the most aesthetic one, and not a fantastic solution, but it's the best the FIA has, and we're happy the FIA works for safety. For sure in the future if there's a better solution everyone will be happy to get it."

Pascal Wehrlein:
"It's positive that it's safer for us. I think what everyone dislikes about it is how it looks. The cars this year look fantastic compared to previous years, much faster and more aggressive, and it seems like with how the cars look everything is going in the right direction, but then the halo is something not so positive for the look… I think the main point for the FIA was to improve the safety, and the halo is doing that. We have to look on the positive side that it's safer, and on the negative side that it looks worse."

Stoffel Vandoorne:
"I think aesthetically it's not the nicest thing we've put on the car and I think a lot of people agree with that. We've been pushing to improve head protection, the FIA have done a lot of investigations into what would be the best solution, trying a couple of different solutions, with the screen being tested as well. I think for them, that [the halo] was the best solution. I don't think it's a big surprise to see it in 2018 on the cars."

Lance Stroll:
"I have ever driven with it. I know a lot of drivers have, but I don't know what it looks like from inside the cockpit. If it makes the car safer and if the drivers are happy with visibility then I don't see why we shouldn't use it."

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Thursday 21 September 2017

  2. FIA amends Super Licence points for 2018 19:34

    FIA amends Super Licence points for 2018

    The FIA has restructured the Super Licence points system for 2018, with several championships having their allocation reduced…

    F1
  3. 19:02

    Follow us on Instagram for the best photos!

    F1
  4. FIA outlines 2019 F3 International proposal 18:59

    FIA outlines 2019 F3 International proposal

    The FIA has outlined its ambition for the proposed FIA F3 International Championship, which is set to replace the current…

    F3
  5. Switzerland joins 2017/18 Formula E calendar 18:42

    Switzerland joins 2017/18 Formula E calendar

    Switzerland will feature on the Formula E calendar in the 2017/18 season, with a street race to take place in…

    FE
  6. Video: IndyCar Sonoma remix highlights 16:36

    Video: IndyCar Sonoma remix highlights

    Watch remix highlights of IndyCar's season-ending Grand Prix of Sonoma, in which Penske driver Josef Newgarden claimed his…

    Indy
  7. Sauber confirms Leclerc for four FP1 runs 15:09

    Sauber confirms Leclerc for four FP1 runs

    Sauber will field Ferrari-backed Charles Leclerc during four practice sessions over the remainder of the season, ahead of an…

    F1
  8. 15:04

    Overview: 2017/18 Formula E line-up so far

    FE
  9. Piquet Jr. joins Evans at Jaguar for S4 15:02

    Piquet Jr. joins Evans at Jaguar for S4

    Nelson Piquet Jr. has joined Mitch Evans at Jaguar for Formula E's fourth season. Ex-Formula 1 driver Piquet Jr. was crowned…

    FE
  10. 14:35

    Overview: Complete 2018 MotoGP line-up

    MotoGP
  11. Siméon signs for Avintia, completes '18 grid 14:33

    Siméon signs for Avintia, completes '18 grid

    Moto2 race winner Xavier Siméon will make the step up to MotoGP next season, joining Avintia on a two-year deal, in a move that…

    MotoGP
  12. Rossi passed fit to compete at Aragón GP 13:43

    Rossi passed fit to compete at Aragón GP

    Valentino Rossi has passed the medical check required to compete at this weekend's Aragón Grand Prix, just three weeks on from…

    MotoGP
  13. McLaren-Honda stint 'a proper disaster' 12:37

    McLaren-Honda stint 'a proper disaster'

    McLaren's latest partnership with Honda was "a proper disaster" for the team's credibility, says Racing Director Eric Boullier…

    F1
  14. Video: Verstappen 'moves on' from clash 12:18

    Video: Verstappen 'moves on' from clash

    Red Bull driver Max Verstappen vows to move on after his first-lap clash with Ferrari drivers Kimi Räikkönen and Sebastian…

    F1
  15. Barberá to step down to Moto2 with Pons 11:45

    Barberá to step down to Moto2 with Pons

    Héctor Barberá will step back down to Moto2 in 2018, after signing a deal with Pons, bringing to a close an eight-season spell…

    MotoGP
  16. Video: Singapore GP strategy analysis 10:12

    Video: Singapore GP strategy analysis

    Mercedes reflects on the strategies used at last weekend's dramatic wet/dry Singapore Grand Prix.

    F1
  17. Ganassi to downsize to two cars in 2018 09:22

    Ganassi to downsize to two cars in 2018

    Chip Ganassi Racing will downsize from four to two cars for the 2018 season. Scott Dixon will continue in the No. 9 Honda…

    Indy
  18. 'F1 teams should be calling Newgarden' 07:48

    'F1 teams should be calling Newgarden'

    Formula 1 teams should be showing interest in newly-crowned IndyCar champion Josef Newgarden, given his rate of development…

    F1
  19. Video: 72 hours - Spielberg to Silverstone 05:42

    Video: 72 hours - Spielberg to Silverstone

    Race team packdown, motorhome build, 1,680 km, 72 hours. Mercedes' logistics partner, DB Schenker, oversaw an incredible…

    F1
  20. Wednesday 20 September 2017

  21. Video: Pushing more US drivers into F1 16:32

    Video: Pushing more US drivers into F1

    SAFEisFAST looks at F4 USA and the role it is set to play in pushing more US drivers into F1.

    F4
  22. F1 title turnarounds to give Vettel hope 15:12

    F1 title turnarounds to give Vettel hope

    Ferrari driver Sebastian Vettel finds himself 28 points down on Mercedes rival Lewis Hamilton after a dramatic Singapore Grand…

    F1
  23. Rossi to attempt comeback at Aragón GP 12:40

    Rossi to attempt comeback at Aragón GP

    Valentino Rossi will attempt to return to action at this weekend's Aragón Grand Prix, around three weeks after sustaining…

    MotoGP
  24. Video: Why is there wood on a race car? 12:18

    Video: Why is there wood on a race car?

    What purpose does a plank of wood serve onboard a racing car? Formula E explains...

    FE
  25. Mahindra holds on to Heidfeld, Rosenqvist 12:12

    Mahindra holds on to Heidfeld, Rosenqvist

    Mahindra Racing has retained Nick Heidfeld and Felix Rosenqvist for the upcoming Formula E season. Ex-Formula 1 driver…

    FE
  26. Sato secures return to RLL for 2018 season 11:40

    Sato secures return to RLL for 2018 season

    Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing (RLL) has announced that reigning Indianapolis 500 champion Takuma Sato will return to its…

    Indy
  27. Pérez donates to Mexico earthquake fund 11:19

    Pérez donates to Mexico earthquake fund

    Force India driver Sergio Pérez has donated three million pesos (around £125,000) to help those affected by the recent…

    F1
  28. Boullier: Alonso wants to stay at McLaren 11:04

    Boullier: Alonso wants to stay at McLaren

    McLaren chief Eric Boullier has claimed that Fernando Alonso "wants to stay" at McLaren for the 2018 season, when the team will…

    F1
  29. Video: Is sleep the key to success in F1? 09:27

    Video: Is sleep the key to success in F1?

    Mercedes highlights the importance of sleep and recovery in Formula 1 and beyond.

    F1
  30. DeFrancesco joins Carlin for final F3 rounds 09:20

    DeFrancesco joins Carlin for final F3 rounds

    Devlin DeFrancesco will join Carlin's European Formula 3 line-up for the final two rounds of the 2017 season at the Red Bull…

    F3
  31. Brown: Renault move 'not a short-term fix' 07:38

    Brown: Renault move 'not a short-term fix'

    McLaren's decision to part ways with Honda and move to Renault power for the 2018 season "is not a short-term fix", according to…

    F1
  32. Video: McLaren presents 'Project Invincible' 05:32

    Video: McLaren presents 'Project Invincible'

    McLaren Applied Technologies introduces its latest personalised healthcare solution, the 'Project Invincible' shield, made from…

    F1
  33. Tuesday 19 September 2017

  34. Rossi reports 'improved feeling' at Misano 18:11

    Rossi reports 'improved feeling' at Misano

    Valentino Rossi reported an "improved feeling" and a "more positive impression" as he tested for the second day in a row at…

    MotoGP
  35. In photos: Newgarden's path to the title 16:32

    In photos: Newgarden's path to the title

    IndyCar has a new champion in the form of Josef Newgarden after the American assimilated to Penske with ease, capturing four…

    Indy
  36. Aston Martin shows interest in engine supply 15:11

    Aston Martin shows interest in engine supply

    Aston Martin "might be interested" in becoming a Formula 1 engine supplier, depending on the make-up of the post-2020…

    F1
  37. In photos: Story of the Singapore Grand Prix 14:19

    In photos: Story of the Singapore Grand Prix

    Lewis Hamilton took full advantage of first-lap drama at Marina Bay to claim victory and move 28 points clear of title rival…

    F1
  38. F1 completes first 'truly live' 360º video trial 12:46

    F1 completes first 'truly live' 360º video trial

    Formula 1, in conjunction with technology partner Tata Communications, successfully completed the first test of "truly live…

    F1
  39. Video: IndyCar Sonoma extended highlights 12:02

    Video: IndyCar Sonoma extended highlights

    Watch extended highlights of IndyCar's title-deciding Grand Prix of Sonoma. Penske driver Josef Newgarden secured his maiden…

    Indy
  40. Sauber to revise procedures after Singapore 11:44

    Sauber to revise procedures after Singapore

    Sauber team boss Frédéric Vasseur says procedures will be revised after a "system error" compounded another challenging Grand…

    F1
  41. Pirelli reveals Malaysian GP tyre selections 11:24

    Pirelli reveals Malaysian GP tyre selections

    Formula 1 tyre supplier Pirelli has revealed drivers' selections for the Malaysian Grand Prix, with Red Bull and Ferrari going…

    F1
  42. Video: Verstappen on fitness in Formula 1 10:48

    Video: Verstappen on fitness in Formula 1

    Red Bull's Max Verstappen explains why a rigorous and meticulous training regime plays such a crucial role in the making of a…

    F1
  43. Magnussen praises F1 'for letting us race' 10:38

    Magnussen praises F1 'for letting us race'

    Haas driver Kevin Magnussen has praised Formula 1 chiefs "for letting us race" at the Singapore Grand Prix, after rain cast…

    F1
more news