United States Grand Prix: Winners and Losers

United States Grand Prix: Winners and Losers

23 October 2017 – Lewis Hamilton put himself on the brink of a fourth world title, some midfield drivers starred, while a controversial penalty changed the order. GPUpdate.net presents its winners and losers from the US Grand Prix.

Winners

This was sheer brilliance from a driver-team combination operating at a near-impregnable level. No-one is unstoppable in sport, but Lewis Hamilton is in the form of his life, as displayed at the Circuit of the Americas, a venue where he typically thrives. Hamilton flew through practice, romped to pole position, and remained unflustered after a so-so getaway enabled Sebastian Vettel to grab the lead. "I was behind Sebastian but even though he got me at the start I was like, 'Okay, I'm going to get him'," said Hamilton post-race. "I just tried to stay on him, I saw him pushing a lot, was like, 'He's going to kill his tyres, I'll wait for a second', and he did." Hamilton's DRS-assisted manoeuvre was decisive and thereafter he was in a league of his own, despite a brief post-stop scare, when the undercut left Vettel deceptively close. This was Hamilton at his best. Barring a disaster, he will be crowned champion in Mexico on Sunday.

Carlos Sainz Jr. stepped out of the Toro Rosso, climbed into the Renault, and immediately underlined just why the manufacturer moved to acquire his services. In just a solitary race he put in a more spectacular display than Jolyon Palmer managed during his entire Renault career, and was on the pace all weekend. Despite his inexperience in the R.S.17, Sainz Jr. made Q3 and recovered from a less-than-stellar first lap, the highlight an utterly inspired move on Sergio Pérez around the outside of Turns 17/18. It resulted in seventh place – a fine reward for his weekend's efforts. A direct comparison with Nico Hülkenberg is impossible due to the German's non-participation in Q2, owing to engine changes, and subsequent retirement, but Sainz Jr.'s display will have made Hülkenberg sit up and take notice – and that can only be positive for Renault.

The rise of Esteban Ocon has been one of the encouraging subplots in 2017 and he was impeccable in Austin, overcoming illness during qualifying and a pre-race power unit scare to collect sixth place. This was a measured, low-key drive, but exactly the sort of performance required by a midfield team – and in doing so prompted Pérez to again attempt to exert his authority with a mid-race radio message inferring, incorrectly, that he was the quickest Force India driver. Ocon's result ensured that he has scored in 16 of this year's 17 races – only Hamilton has a better record – and has finished his first 26 F1 races, a new record. Reliability and speed is a potent combination – and he is only getting better with each passing race. Daniil Kvyat, meanwhile, also warrants a shout out, after taking a point on his return, after a weekend which included missing FP1/3, and suffering from power issues in the race.

Losers

You are reading a motorsport-dedicated website, you know what happened, you know the fallout. Max Verstappen was penalised through the letter of the law, and the decision of the stewards is justifiable. However, the Dutchman has reason to feel aggrieved. This situation has arisen through poor track design, allied to inconsistent stewarding, leaving drivers uncertain of the rules. More work is required from various sides to avoid a repeat; track limits should be strictly regulated – and with a clear (and obviously safe) grass/gravel deterrent to deter dubious manoeuvres, as opposed to the current painted tarmac which has become the dominant feature on the inside, and outside, of many new-build circuits. Rather than merely pontificate on one incident, this should be used as the catalyst to completely overhaul the system, be self-critical, revise the culture and the approach – regulatory application and stewarding should be high on the agenda – to ensure that matters change for the positive, and Formula 1 does not get stuck in this cycle of conflict.

On home ground, this was an abject display from Haas. The team's performance has fluctuated wildly this season – almost as dramatically as in its rookie campaign – and at Austin it was towards its lowest ebb. Failing to get the tyres into the correct window hindered the team once more in qualifying, while a basic miscommunication would have cost Kevin Magnussen, though ironically an absence of pace meant his penalty was meaningless. Magnussen, having described his new tyres as "like a used set" in qualifying, stumbled into Pascal Wehrlein on the opening lap and was later spun by the other Sauber of Marcus Ericsson at the same spot. Grosjean, meanwhile, tried a one-stop strategy but described the last few laps as "pretty dangerous", amid deteriorating pace, and was never realistically in contention for points.

Is it fair to label Fernando Alonso a loser? On the basis of his performance, absolutely not, but in the grand scheme of race results, undoubtedly so – though it was not remotely his fault. Alonso, perhaps fuelled by his Indianapolis 500 experience, embraced the weekend's off-track action with a crowd-pleasing show at the Fan Forum, and used the helmet design he sported at the iconic 500-mile event. On-track he was sublime, as he made Q3, fought hard to maintain his position early on, and was on course for seventh when an MGU-H failure reared its head. "In the last few races we have lost so many points – possibly 15 or 20 – which probably could have helped our position in the championship for myself and also the team," rued Alonso, and not without merit. Next year cannot come soon enough.

Written by: Phillip Horton

related

Comments

Latest News
Full
Compact

  1. Wednesday 21 February 2018

  2. 12:51

    Syahrin secures Tech 3 Yamaha MotoGP ride

    MotoGP
  3. 12:49

    Alonso won't suffer from missing Prologue - Toyota

    F1
  4. 12:47

    What we've learned from MotoGP testing so far

    MotoGP
  5. 12:45

    The battle for F1's most coveted seat

    F1
  6. 12:43

    BT Sport extends UK MotoGP TV deal to 2021

    F1
  7. 12:41

    McLaren planning "substantial" update for Australia

    F1
  8. Tuesday 20 February 2018

  9. 13:31

    Lowe: F1 2018 could be battle of bargeboards

    F1
  10. 13:29

    Red Bull testing plans unaffected despite crash

    F1
  11. 13:27

    What Williams is risking in a 'dangerous world'

    F1
  12. 13:25

    Sauber reveals Alfa Romeo-backed C37

    F1
  13. Monday 19 February 2018

  14. 15:02

    Why AI could be F1's next big thing

    F1
  15. 15:00

    Ricciardo shakes down RB14 at Silverstone

    F1
  16. 14:58

    Red Bull reveals its 2018 Formula 1 car

    F1
  17. Sunday 28 January 2018

  18. Video: Button celebrates birthday with Ricciardo 09:12

    Video: Button celebrates birthday with Ricciardo

    Go behind-the-scenes with Jenson Button during his birthday celebrations at Big Bear Lake, before he is joined by Red Bull ace…

    F1
  19. Saturday 27 January 2018

  20. Video: 2018 Daytona 24 Hours: Qualifying 14:18

    Video: 2018 Daytona 24 Hours: Qualifying

    Watch behind the scenes as the United Autosports team qualify for the endurance challenge at Daytona, with Fernando Alonso…

    Misc
  21. Friday 26 January 2018

  22. Video: Sim Racing Girl visits Red Bull 15:59

    Video: Sim Racing Girl visits Red Bull

    The latest personality to get behind the wheel of the state-of-the-art simulator at Red Bull's Milton Keynes HQ is none other…

    F1
  23. Thursday 25 January 2018

  24. Gasly hopes STR can maximise testing time 12:46

    Gasly hopes STR can maximise testing time

    Pierre Gasly believes Toro Rosso-Honda must ensure it establishes a reliable base early on, in order to maximise track time…

    F1
  25. Video: 2018 Yamaha MotoGP bike launch 08:10

    Video: 2018 Yamaha MotoGP bike launch

    Yamaha Racing and Yamaha Music Italy's newly composed soundtrack introduce the 2018 Movistar Yamaha MotoGP YZR-M1s.

    MotoGP
  26. Wednesday 24 January 2018

  27. Hamilton sure Mercedes can repeat reliability 14:46

    Hamilton sure Mercedes can repeat reliability

    Reigning World Champion Lewis Hamilton says repeating his reliability record in Formula 1 this year will be tricky, but believes…

    F1
  28. Video: Jenson Button vlog: From LA to Tokyo 10:48

    Video: Jenson Button vlog: From LA to Tokyo

    Catch up with Jenson Button in his latest vlog entry as he jets from Los Angeles to Tokyo for the launch of Honda's Super GT…

    Misc
  29. Tuesday 23 January 2018

  30. Video: Movistar Yamaha teases 2018 launch 13:47

    Video: Movistar Yamaha teases 2018 launch

    Movistar Yamaha gets ready for its 2018 team launch, with Valentino Rossi and Maverick Viñales set to take the wraps off its…

    MotoGP
  31. Hubert completes ART's GP3 driver line-up 13:39

    Hubert completes ART's GP3 driver line-up

    Anthoine Hubert says winning the GP3 title is his target for the 2018 season after confirmation that the Frenchman will remain…

    GP3
  32. Monday 22 January 2018

  33. Pirelli: F1 unlikely to return to tyre competition 13:24

    Pirelli: F1 unlikely to return to tyre competition

    Pirelli Racing Manager Mario Isola says he doubts that Formula 1 will ever return to competition between two tyre manufacturers…

    F1
  34. Video: Kubica on Williams reserve role 09:32

    Video: Kubica on Williams reserve role

    Robert Kubica talks about joining the Williams team and what his reserve and development driver role will involve through the…

    F1
  35. Sunday 21 January 2018

  36. Hughes back in GP3 with dominant ART team 12:52

    Hughes back in GP3 with dominant ART team

    Jake Hughes will return to the GP3 Series this year after signing a deal to compete for the championship's dominant force ART…

    GP3
  37. Video: Rallye Monte-Carlo 2018 preview 09:46

    Video: Rallye Monte-Carlo 2018 preview

    Next weekend marks the start of the 2018 World Rally Championship with the iconic Rallye Monte-Carlo; get set for the…

    Misc
  38. Saturday 20 January 2018

  39. New York becomes FE finale after Montreal axe 10:44

    New York becomes FE finale after Montreal axe

    New York will host the final round of this year's Formula E championship after series organisers opted not to replace the…

    FE
  40. Video: Force India's farewell to VJM10 09:19

    Video: Force India's farewell to VJM10

    Watch as Force India puts Sergio Pérez's VJM10, used throughout the course of the 2017 season, into retirement, with the car…

    F1
  41. Friday 19 January 2018

  42. 15:02

    Overview: 2018 Formula 1 grid line-up in full

    F1
  43. Video: Verstappen and Ricciardo in Crazy Carts 11:19

    Video: Verstappen and Ricciardo in Crazy Carts

    Red Bull pair Max Verstappen and Daniel Ricciardo are going a little stir crazy waiting for Formula 1 to return - and take to…

    F1
  44. Thursday 18 January 2018

  45. Russell steps up to Formula 2 with ART 09:27

    Russell steps up to Formula 2 with ART

    Mercedes-backed GP3 champion George Russell will graduate to Formula 2 with ART in 2018. Russell, 19, stormed to last year's…

    F2
  46. Folger to miss MotoGP season through illness 09:07

    Folger to miss MotoGP season through illness

    Tech 3 Yamaha rider Jonas Folger will sit out the 2018 MotoGP season, having struggled to recover physically and mentally after…

    MotoGP
  47. Video: Marrakesh's most dramatic moments 07:02

    Video: Marrakesh's most dramatic moments

    Watch every crash, spin, slide and save from last weekend's Marrakesh round of the all-electric Formula E championship.

    FE
  48. Wednesday 17 January 2018

  49. Chaves unconcerned by one-car Harding entry 16:32

    Chaves unconcerned by one-car Harding entry

    Gabby Chaves has played down suggestions that Harding's one-car effort could prove to be disadvantageous, pointing to the…

    Indy
  50. Kari stays in GP3, switches to MP Motorsport 10:06

    Kari stays in GP3, switches to MP Motorsport

    Niko Kari will continue in the GP3 Series this year, having switched from Arden to category newcomers MP Motorsport. Formula…

    GP3
  51. Tuesday 16 January 2018

  52. Fenestraz joins Carlin for Formula 3 campaign 13:54

    Fenestraz joins Carlin for Formula 3 campaign

    Formula Renault champion Sacha Fenestraz will contest this year's European Formula 3 Championship with Carlin. Fenestraz…

    F3
  53. Kubica gets development role with Williams 11:32

    Kubica gets development role with Williams

    Robert Kubica has landed a role as Williams' reserve and development driver for 2018, which will involve test and practice runs…

    F1
  54. Williams confirms Sirotkin for 2018 seat 11:18

    Williams confirms Sirotkin for 2018 seat

    Williams has announced that Sergey Sirotkin will partner Lance Stroll for the 2018 campaign, with Robert Kubica, on the comeback…

    F1
  55. Video: Rosberg's Twitter Q&A with fans 08:42

    Video: Rosberg's Twitter Q&A with fans

    2016 Formula 1 World Champion Nico Rosberg responds to a variety of questions posed by fans on Twitter.

    F1
  56. Monday 15 January 2018

  57. Aitken secures Formula 2 step with ART GP 18:30

    Aitken secures Formula 2 step with ART GP

    Renault junior driver Jack Aitken will graduate to Formula 2 with ART Grand Prix this season, the French team has…

    F2
more news